I give this media_gossip three and a half stars
A media gossip newsletter discussing tensions at The Atlantic between editorial and podcast divisions, observations about American home aesthetics, and the author's experience attending industry panels and events. The piece includes brief mentions of media industry dynamics and social media reactions to various outlets' coverage.
Summary
This week's media gossip column opens with a commentary on American interior design, noting that homeowners are forced to make rental units and flipped properties feel homey using affordable solutions like motivational signs and flat-screen televisions. The author then recounts attending two panels—one for Evereden about youth mental health and technology, and another for Substack focusing on mental health and technology with newsletter sponsorship elements. The author describes being overwhelmed and overworked that week, sprinting between venues in Manhattan while Substack staff advised them to calm down. The author had conversations with Brittany Spanos about Taylor Swift's team (Tree Paine), and with Michele Dale and Meg Youngblood about Timothee Chalamet and Gaylor Swift fan community topics. The main media gossip story concerns internal tension at The Atlantic between Editor-in-Chief Jeffrey Goldberg and CEO Nick Thompson over the podcast division. Editorial staff feel that Thompson's podcast strategy is undercutting the editorial side by cannibalizing potential interview guests and blurring boundaries between business and editorial operations. The column concludes by noting that New York Magazine appears to have responded to The Atlantic's history of recruiting its writers by publishing Atlantic-style critical stories about a socialist mayor.
About this episode
Plus: A Substack advertising dinner, tensions at The Atlantic, and the outlets who fell for AI freelancers.
Key Insights
- The author argues that Americans are constrained by purchasing affordable home décor solutions to make rental and flipped properties feel personal, resulting in a homogeneous aesthetic of motivational signs and mass-market televisions
- Atlantic editorial staff believe that CEO Nick Thompson's podcast division is competing with editorial for the same interview subjects, creating a conflict between business and editorial goals
- The author experienced burnout from overcommitting to multiple industry events in a single week, requiring intervention from colleagues to manage stress levels
- New York Magazine appears to be responding to The Atlantic's pattern of recruiting their writers by publishing similar critical coverage of political figures
- The author suggests that media industry events provide networking opportunities where staff from competing outlets exchange insider information about culture and media figures
Topics
Transcript
Welcome to media_gossip, Embedded’s special weekly edition of … media gossip, sent every Friday. You’re getting this because you subscribe to Embedded, but you can opt out here . Nick’s Riff This Week Why American homes are so ugly inside: “We’re stuck trying to make gray-floored, landlord-special-painted flips and rental units feel homey with affordable solutions like buying ‘Bless our nest’ signs from Wayfair and hanging massive, cheap flat screen televisions in our living rooms. ” Left: I was on a panel for Evereden about youth mental health and technology. Right: I was at a dinner for Substack about MY mental health and technology (newsletter sponsorships). This was one of those weeks where, due to my own decisions, I was…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Embedded
The end of short-form content
Kate Lindsay argues that major social media platforms (TikTok, Instagram, Twitter) are dying as genuine social platforms due to AI-generated content flooding feeds, while predicting a shift toward long-form content on platforms like YouTube, Substack, and newsletters that have proven more durable and resistant to AI dilution.
camping for our anniversary
No transcript content was provided to analyze.
Never quit your side hustle for a staff job
Nick and Kate discuss the origin and evolution of their media newsletter Embedded, from its accidental launch on Substack during the pandemic to nearly being absorbed into The Atlantic. They reflect on early mistakes, the value of reader monetization, and why declining The Atlantic's offer was ultimately the right decision.
Why am I so bad at replying to texts?
Kate Lindsay, editor of Embedded, discusses her decade-long struggle with replying to texts, a New Year's resolution she has failed at every year since at least 2017. She acknowledges owing responses to multiple people despite liking them and finding the conversations non-threatening, attributing her poor texting habits to a personal failing she repeatedly excuses.
This media_gossip has been redacted
Episode 75 of Hip Replacement features Kate Lindsay discussing her relationship with The Sims and gaming habits, while the episode also covers Patreon's user exodus, the New York Times Amy Griffin piece, and a lesbian bar's role in journalism.