The historical trap Putin can't escape - Sarah Paine
Sarah Paine argues that continental powers like Imperial China and Imperial Russia face catastrophic and irreversible consequences when they botch strategy. She uses the Bolshevik Revolution and its aftermath as a case study in how entire social classes and civilizations can be permanently erased. Continental powers, unlike maritime ones, operate without insurance policies.
Summary
In this excerpt, historian Sarah Paine presents a stark warning about the nature of continental power and strategic failure. She opens by arguing that when continental powers make strategic mistakes, the consequences can be total and permanent — entire civilizations, social orders, and ways of life can vanish forever. This is contrasted implicitly with maritime powers, which historically have had more resilience and 'insurance policies' against catastrophic failure.
Paine uses a photograph of an aristocrat's whimsical palace — now long gone — as a visual anchor to illustrate the human cost of revolutionary upheaval in Russia. She describes what happened in Russia as one of the most horrific genocides of the 20th century, carried out by the Bolsheviks, who explicitly promised to eliminate entire social classes. She emphasizes the word 'eliminate' in its most literal sense: these classes were not displaced or marginalized but destroyed entirely.
She then outlines the sequential waves of destruction that accomplished this: the Bolshevik Revolution, the Russian Civil War, collectivization, and finally the Great Purges, which she says 'finished the job.' Together, these events represent the defining characteristic of continental power dynamics — a world with no safety net, no fallback, and no recovery mechanism once strategic catastrophe is set in motion.
Key Insights
- Paine argues that when continental powers botch strategy, the consequences are not merely setbacks but can result in the permanent erasure of their entire known world — civilizations, institutions, and social classes gone forever.
- Paine identifies Imperial China, Imperial Russia, and other venerable civilizations as historical examples of continental powers that suffered irreversible collapse due to strategic failure.
- Paine characterizes the Bolshevik-led destruction of Russia's aristocratic and social classes as one of the most horrific genocides of the 20th century, stressing that 'get rid of' meant literal, permanent elimination.
- Paine describes the destruction of Russia's old social order as a sequential, multi-phase process: the Bolshevik Revolution, the Russian Civil War, collectivization, and the Great Purges each played a distinct role in completing the annihilation.
- Paine concludes that the continental world is fundamentally 'a world without insurance policies,' meaning continental powers have no fallback or recovery mechanism once catastrophic strategic errors are made.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] The problem for the likes of Putin is if a continental power botches strategy, its known world can vanish forever. And this is what happened to Imperial China, Imperial Russia, and many venerable civilizations. I love this photograph of a aristocrat's whimsical palace that's long gone as a result of one of the most horrific genocides of the 20th century when the communists made good their promise to get rid of entire social classes. And I mean get rid of like gone forever. And with the Bolevik revolution, the ensuing Russian civil [0:30] war followed by collectivization and then the great purges that finish the job. This is the continental world. It is a world without insurance policies.
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Dwarkesh Patel
The Army Sent to Stop Cortés Joined Him Instead - Si Sheppard
Spanish conquistador Cortés faced a threat from Governor Velázquez of Cuba, who sent Don Narvaez with a larger force to arrest him for exceeding his authority. Rather than being defeated, Cortés defeated Narvaez in battle and persuaded the expeditionary force to join him by promising shared wealth from the empire, turning potential enemies into reinforcements.
How 168 Men Captured the Inca Emperor - Si Sheppard
Francisco Pizarro, with only 168 men, captured the Inca Emperor Atahualpa in 1532 at Cajamarca by using psychological tactics with horses and an ambush strategy. Despite Atahualpa's show of dominance and his large army, Pizarro's surprise attack and capture of the emperor allowed him to control the entire Inca social hierarchy.
The Myth of the Helpless Aztecs and Inca - Si Sheppard
Si Sheppard argues that the Aztecs and Incas were not helpless victims but actively developed countermeasures and adaptive strategies against Spanish conquistadors, including terrain manipulation, weapon improvisation, and tactical learning—though they lacked sufficient time to fully master foreign technologies.
How Conquistadors Conquered the Aztecs - Si Sheppard
Conquistador success against the Aztecs relied primarily on steel weapons, horses, and psychological tactics rather than firearms. Steel armor and swords proved far more effective than indigenous weapons made of wood, stone, and obsidian, while horses—animals unknown to the Aztecs—provided decisive military and logistical advantages.
How did a few hundred Spanish soldiers topple two empires? – Si Sheppard
Military historian Si Sheppard explains how a few hundred Spanish conquistadors were able to conquer the Aztec and Inca Empires within just a few years through a combination of technological advantages (horses, steel weapons), psychological warfare, diplomatic manipulation of existing divisions among indigenous peoples, and the catastrophic impact of disease. The conquests were contingent on individual leadership decisions and geographic factors, but were fundamentally enabled by the conquistadors' ability to exploit internal rifts within empires that appeared monolithic from the outside.