He BUILT INSANE Collection in 5 Years!
Adam built an impressive sports card collection over 5 years by purchasing undervalued, aesthetically appealing cards at $300-$1,500 each, which has since tripled to quadrupled in value. The collection, valued at $125,000+, is being sold to fund a mountain house purchase, with the seller planning to shift to a more selective, raw card collecting approach going forward.
Summary
This video follows a visit to collector Adam's home in North Carolina to evaluate his sports card collection, which he built over approximately 5 years starting around 2018-2019 and ramping up significantly during the pandemic. Adam's collection strategy centered on three core principles: buying undervalued cards before they appreciated significantly, selecting aesthetically pleasing cards he personally enjoyed, and maintaining a disciplined budget of $300-$1,500 per card.
Key pieces of the collection include a complete 1986 Fleer Jordan set (base and sticker, all PSA 7s) purchased for $9,000 five years ago, now valued around $25,000. A 2018 Topps Downtown Tom Brady was acquired for approximately $1,400 and is now worth roughly $14,000. Other notable cards include vintage pieces like a 1948 Leaf Babe Ruth, 1933 Goudey Ruth, 1950 Bowman Jackie Robinson and Yogi Berra, and multiple high-grade Jordan cards. Adam also collected basketball stars like Pete Maravic (rookie in an 8, purchased for $125 at an antique store), Wilt Chamberlain, and various specialty cards including patches and autographed cards from contemporary athletes.
Adam's collection reflects a personal connection to sports history—he grew up with his mother at card shows, collected as a child, stepped away during his teenage years, and resumed collecting seriously during the COVID-19 pandemic. His geographic location in the DC area influenced many selections (Redskins, Orioles, Cal Ripken). He was strategic about finding undervalued refractors and insert cards before they appreciated significantly.
The collection includes some missteps, such as a counterfeit Kaboom he purchased on eBay and some rookie autographs that didn't pan out (Jaden Daniels), but overall the investment strategy succeeded dramatically. The entire collection approximately doubled or tripled in value over the 5-year period. Adam is selling to fund furniture purchases and renovations for a newly acquired mountain house near Black Mountain, North Carolina, with his wife's decorator purchases exceeding budget. He plans to continue collecting but more selectively, focusing on raw cards and pieces he genuinely loves aesthetically rather than pursuing high grades and maximum resale value.
Key Insights
- Adam purchased his 1986 Fleer Jordan complete set (base and sticker, all PSA 7s) for $9,000 approximately five years ago, and it has since tripled in value to approximately $25,000, representing one of his most successful investments.
- Adam adopted a deliberate strategy of buying undervalued refractors and insert cards that hadn't yet appreciated significantly, rather than pursuing already-expensive 'big hitter' cards, which proved highly effective for his collection growth.
- A 2018 Topps Downtown Tom Brady purchased for approximately $1,400 in 2020-2021 is now valued around $14,000, demonstrating exceptional returns on what Adam believed was simply an aesthetically appealing card at the time.
- Adam purchased a 1968 Topps Pete Maravich rookie in an 8 grade from an antique store in the mountains for approximately $125, which he describes as possibly the best acquisition of his entire collection.
- Adam's entire collecting strategy relied on maintaining a disciplined budget of $300-$1,500 per individual card across nearly his entire collection, allowing him to build depth while doubling his money in less than five years without overextending financially.
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Guys, you better buckle up because today we got something special. This is the centerpiece right here. >> Absolutely. >> We're in the [music] wrong business. >> I love the vintage cards. >> That card, it's probably $14,000 today. We shouldn't just forget about the [music] 86 fleer set. >> [music] >> We're getting ready to go check out some original Steph Curry downtowns. An 86 [0:31] graded set with a Jordan rookie and a Jordan sticker rookie. A bunch of other rare basketball cards. But here's the here's the nuance. Adam said, "Hey, if you want this, you got [music] to spend $125,000 to come get it." So, we're here in North Carolina and we're going to go…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from CHASING CARDBOARD
WHAT means more than SPORTS CARDS?
A collector discusses their sports card collection that was saved for their son, who passed away from septic shock in May. Now struggling with the loss and lack of family interest, they no longer want to keep the collection.
Women’s football? DID IT REALLY EXIST?
A documentary-style interview discusses women's professional football, specifically featuring a player who played defensive end and left tackle for the Dallas Stampedes. The conversation challenges stereotypes about women in football while humorously acknowledging the physical demands and intensity of the sport.
When LIFE is hard, sell SPORTS CARDS
A person shares their health journey of surviving breast cancer and managing MS, celebrating being cancer-free and having their MS stalled after 5 years of fighting. They express gratitude for their survival and acknowledge the difficulty of their health battles.
She Asked Me to Buy EVERYTHING! 👀
A sports card collector named Jana, a 60-year-old former professional football player and lifelong collector, sells her extensive '90s basketball and baseball card collection to Ty for $4,000. Despite her visual impairment from eye surgeries, Jana shares stories about her collecting journey starting as a child with her grandparents, and two Kobe Bryant rookie cards graded by Beckett later show mixed results.
We Grade The Top Cards in Collection!
The content follows a visit to Beckett Grading headquarters in Dallas where the host submits a collection of 85-90 Kobe Bryant basketball cards for professional grading. Colin, Beckett's general manager, discusses the company's operational challenges, recent capacity expansions, and their competitive advantages. The episode concludes with a detailed reveal of all graded cards, highlighting their grades and condition.