We Grade The Top Cards in Collection!
The content follows a visit to Beckett Grading headquarters in Dallas where the host submits a collection of 85-90 Kobe Bryant basketball cards for professional grading. Colin, Beckett's general manager, discusses the company's operational challenges, recent capacity expansions, and their competitive advantages. The episode concludes with a detailed reveal of all graded cards, highlighting their grades and condition.
Summary
The episode begins with an in-person visit to Beckett Grading's facilities in Plano, Texas, just outside Dallas. The host explains that they are submitting cards from a Phoenix-based collector named Art who has an extensive Kobe Bryant collection. Colin, Beckett's general manager, gives a tour of their new automated pickup locker system, which addresses the challenge of overwhelming demand for in-person drop-offs. Colin reveals that immediately after reopening submissions following a pause in early August, Beckett received 64,000 card submissions in just the first two days.
During the interview, Colin addresses common criticisms from the hobby community about why Beckett doesn't simply hire more graders or implement AI to speed up processing. He explains that grading requires extensive expertise and that new graders typically take 12-18 months of training before they can accurately assess card authenticity and apply Beckett's grading standards. Despite this challenge, Beckett has hired over 20 new graders in the past year and increased their daily processing capacity from 4,500 cards per day to 7,500 cards per day. Colin also mentions upcoming improvements including the ability to sell Beckett cards through the PSA marketplace and a new website redesign.
The second half of the episode transitions to revealing the graded cards. The host and co-host Matt Coleman retrieve the graded submissions and go through approximately 85-90 cards one by one. Notable highlights include a 2004 Finest Red X-Fractor graded BGS 95, multiple numbered refractors graded 9 or higher, a Topps Pristine card (numbered 16 of 25) that the original owner Art believed was worth $60,000 (graded BGS 9.5), and a Downtown Kobe Bryant pack-pulled card graded BGS 10 (described as the collector's favorite). The reveal demonstrates strong grading results overall, with most cards receiving grades between 8.5 and 9.5, very few perfect 10s, and one particularly poor grade of a BGS 6.
The episode concludes with the host reflecting positively on the Beckett experience, noting they spent approximately $10,000 for express grading of 85-90 cards. The host also shares that Art will receive additional payment based on their agreed-upon arrangement, which prompted Art to share that his daughter was recently accepted to Arizona State University for aerospace engineering, suggesting the card sale earnings will help fund her education.
Key Insights
- Beckett received 64,000 card submissions within just the first two days of reopening after a temporary pause, indicating massive pent-up demand in the market despite booking delays of six weeks or more
- New Beckett graders require 12-18 months of training before they can be trusted to make accurate authenticity and grading assessments, meaning the company's capacity increases are fundamentally limited by human expertise development rather than hiring speed
- Beckett increased daily processing capacity from 4,500 cards per day at the start of the year to 7,500 cards per day, and hired over 20 new graders in the past year despite these training bottlenecks
- The most anticipated upcoming Beckett feature is the ability for customers to sell Beckett-graded cards through the PSA marketplace, which is expected to improve liquidity and market accessibility
- Out of approximately 85-90 submitted Kobe Bryant cards, only one card received a perfect BGS 10 grade, demonstrating that achieving perfect grades on vintage basketball refractors is exceptionally difficult even for high-quality collections
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] We were at some point [music] going to reach a breaking point form. First two days alone, I think we had 64,000 cards submitted. >> Are you what? >> This is the one that actually Art was [music] thinking was worth $60,000 and the biggest card in the lot. [music] All right, so we're here at Beckett just outside of Dallas. So, what normally is full of cameras, it's full [0:30] of graded or soon to be graded cards. It's been a while since we've done an in-person drop off. Last [music] one we did was like PSA 3 years ago. First time ever doing it at Becket. [music] We're meeting with the general manager, Colin. I have some…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from CHASING CARDBOARD
WHAT means more than SPORTS CARDS?
A collector discusses their sports card collection that was saved for their son, who passed away from septic shock in May. Now struggling with the loss and lack of family interest, they no longer want to keep the collection.
Women’s football? DID IT REALLY EXIST?
A documentary-style interview discusses women's professional football, specifically featuring a player who played defensive end and left tackle for the Dallas Stampedes. The conversation challenges stereotypes about women in football while humorously acknowledging the physical demands and intensity of the sport.
When LIFE is hard, sell SPORTS CARDS
A person shares their health journey of surviving breast cancer and managing MS, celebrating being cancer-free and having their MS stalled after 5 years of fighting. They express gratitude for their survival and acknowledge the difficulty of their health battles.
She Asked Me to Buy EVERYTHING! 👀
A sports card collector named Jana, a 60-year-old former professional football player and lifelong collector, sells her extensive '90s basketball and baseball card collection to Ty for $4,000. Despite her visual impairment from eye surgeries, Jana shares stories about her collecting journey starting as a child with her grandparents, and two Kobe Bryant rookie cards graded by Beckett later show mixed results.
He Bought Kobe Cards Before Kobe Became a Legend
A collector shares their early Kobe Bryant card collection acquired before his fame, purchasing cards based on personal interest rather than investment strategy. The collection contains numerous valuable cards including refractors, SPs, and relics that have become highly sought-after.