The Unknowns of Motherhood
Alex Cooper discusses the psychological and physical challenges of transitioning to motherhood, emphasizing that women can simultaneously feel excited and terrified about becoming mothers without shame. She explores the concept of 'matrescence,' the grief of losing one's former identity, and argues that society's toxic binary expectations of mothers prevent honest conversations about the real fears and ambivalence that accompany pregnancy.
Summary
In this episode of Call Her Daddy, Alex Cooper addresses what she calls "the unknowns of motherhood" by exploring the complex, often unspoken emotions surrounding pregnancy and the transition to motherhood. She begins by establishing that becoming pregnant doesn't erase the previous 20-30 years of identity, and that women should feel no shame for mourning aspects of their former lives while simultaneously being excited about motherhood.
Cooper introduces the scientific term 'matrescence'—a parallel to adolescence that describes the massive physical, hormonal, and psychological transformation of becoming a mother. She notes that while society gives teenagers grace during their identity crisis, pregnant women and new mothers are expected to instantly become serene, selfless goddesses. Recent neuroscience research shows that pregnancy and childbirth trigger one of the most radical rapid restructurings of the human brain ever observed.
A central theme is the toxic binary society imposes on mothers: you're either a grateful goddess who never complains, or you're ungrateful, bitter, and unfit to be a mother. There is no middle ground. Cooper argues this forces women into isolation and prevents honest dialogue. She emphasizes that clinical psychological research explicitly states that ambivalence—holding two opposing emotions simultaneously—is the most normal and healthy part of entering parenthood.
Cooper discusses the physical transformation, describing pregnancy as making women feel simultaneously like superheroes (capable of creating life) and hostages in their own bodies (losing control). She explores how this impacts relationships with partners, noting that the dynamic shifts permanently as couples transition from being lovers to co-parents. She also addresses the grief of losing independence, freedom, and one's former identity, while acknowledging that this grief doesn't diminish love for the baby.
Throughout, Cooper advocates for normalizing conversations about motherhood's difficulties the way people discuss other life challenges—complaining about jobs, families, and relationships without judgment. She argues that shame thrives in silence, but when women are allowed to express both excitement and fear, the shame evaporates. She ends by reassuring listeners that having these fears and concerns indicates they actually care and are already showing up for their children.
About this episode
Join Alex in the studio for a conversation about the unknowns of becoming a mom. She opens up about the fear of losing yourself, the thoughts you’re scared to say out loud and what no one prepares you for when everything starts to change. From relationship changes and body image to the pressure to be the “perfect parent,” Alex gets into the honest reality of motherhood and the importance of removing the stigma around these types of conversations.
Key Insights
- Cooper argues that society enforces a toxic binary where mothers must be either grateful goddesses or ungrateful complainers, with no allowance for nuance or mixed emotions.
- Recent neuroscience research shows that pregnancy and childbirth trigger one of the most radical rapid restructurings of the human brain ever observed, yet society offers no grace for this transformation comparable to what's given to teenagers.
- Clinical psychology research explicitly establishes that ambivalence—simultaneously holding opposing emotions—is the most normal and healthy part of entering parenthood, yet women are shamed for experiencing it.
- Cooper contends that the shame surrounding maternal fears doesn't come from the fear itself but from the cultural demand for absolute, unwavering gratitude that makes women hide their authentic emotions.
- Cooper observes that women are allowed to complain and vent about jobs, families, and relationships without judgment, but motherhood is treated as taboo territory where any expression of difficulty is seen as ingratitude.
- Cooper argues that losing control of one's body during pregnancy creates psychological tension between feeling like a superhero capable of creating life and feeling like a hostage in an uncontrollable vessel.
- Cooper claims that the unknowns of motherhood—career impact, relationship changes, loss of independence—are real, rational fears equivalent to climbing Mount Everest, not character flaws.
- Cooper states that having fears about motherhood actually indicates a mother already cares deeply and is already showing up for her child, contradicting the notion that doubt signals inadequacy.
Topics
Transcript
Call Her Daddy is brought to you by Southern New Hampshire University. Daddy gang, let's get real, okay? We like to make our own rules. Southern New Hampshire University gets it. They let you learn what you want with over 200 career-focused programs, where you want with 100% online courses, and how you want with no set class times. Basically, you get to call the shots from day one. Visit snhu.edu slash callherdaddy to learn more. Call Her Daddy is brought to you by American Eagle. Okay, so fall is almost here and the new arrivals from American Eagle, kind of obsessed. We're talking sweet dresses, soft sweaters you'll want to live in, on-trend jeans and cargos you'll want to…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Call Her Daddy
Reneé Rapp: Breakups, Body Image & Coming Out (FBF)
Renée Rapp discusses her journey from a small town in North Carolina to Broadway and stardom, opening up about her struggles with eating disorders, hidden sexuality, toxic relationships that required her to minimize her success, and how fame has paradoxically helped her embrace her sensitive, emotional nature.
Trixie Mattel: Makeup, Motels & Moving On
Trixie Mattel discusses her journey from a small Wisconsin town to becoming a successful drag queen, entrepreneur, and media personality. She shares insights on overcoming trauma, the importance of creative process over outcomes, and her various business ventures including the Trixie Motel in Palm Springs.
Is Your Parent a Narcissist? (FBF)
Clinical psychologist Dr. Sherry Campbell discusses toxic family dynamics and narcissistic parenting with host Alex Cooper, sharing her personal experience as a scapegoated child and offering strategies for setting boundaries, including gray rocking and cordial contact, ultimately advocating for survivors to prioritize their wellbeing over maintaining abusive family relationships.
Malin Akerman: The Hunting Wives, Hustling & Healing
Malin Akerman discusses her journey from Sweden to Canada to Los Angeles, her experiences in modeling and acting, her marriage, motherhood, and her role in the hit series 'The Hunting Wives.' She shares insights about personal growth, therapy, relationships, and the importance of vulnerability and communication.
Before You Blow Up Your Life
Host Alex discusses whether to make major life changes, presenting three key questions to ask before 'blowing up your life': Are you bored (needing stimulation vs. being dissatisfied)? Are you escaping something (running away vs. running toward)? Are you idealizing a fantasy rather than seeing reality? The episode emphasizes making informed decisions from an internal place rather than seeking external fixes for internal problems.