Reneé Rapp: Breakups, Body Image & Coming Out (FBF)
Renée Rapp discusses her journey from a small town in North Carolina to Broadway and stardom, opening up about her struggles with eating disorders, hidden sexuality, toxic relationships that required her to minimize her success, and how fame has paradoxically helped her embrace her sensitive, emotional nature.
Summary
In this episode of Call Her Daddy, Renée Rapp shares her formative years growing up in Huntersville, North Carolina, where she felt like an outsider in a conservative, homophobic environment. She recounts her childhood confidence in declaring she would be Beyoncé, though this conviction masked deep insecurity and sensitivity. Rapp details her turbulent high school experience, including bullying from other students' mothers in the theater community who created group chats mocking her.
Rapp discusses her journey to self-discovery regarding her sexuality, explaining that at 14 she realized she was attracted to women but grew up hearing only negative narratives about queer people from her family. She describes a panic attack when she first came out to herself as gay, later understanding she was bisexual. For years, she says she never formally came out because people laughed at her attempts, and her family only became fully accepting when she landed a visible role on the television show College Girls.
A major focus of the conversation centers on her experience on Broadway in Mean Girls, where she faced significant body image trauma. Rapp reveals that costume designers changed her outfit without her consent—adding a skirt over a corset—because they deemed her body inappropriate for the original design. While already battling an eating disorder that progressed from binge eating to severe restriction, she was forced to perform while malnourished and facing online criticism about her appearance. She notes that people told her the costume change was meant to "highlight her curves," which she recognized as gaslighting.
Rapp describes a painful relationship where she hid her professional successes to avoid making her partner and his family uncomfortable, essentially shrinking herself to maintain the relationship. She characterizes this as one of her greatest heartbreaks—not because of the breakup itself, but because she realized she had abandoned her own ambitions. Upon the breakup, she experienced an immediate shift in perspective, calling her manager to declare it would be "the greatest motherfucking year" of her life, recognizing that suppressing her success had been the real tragedy.
Regarding her acting career, Rapp expresses ongoing anxiety about being typecast as her character Layton on Sex and the City: The College Years, worried that people won't see her as a musician or individual. She discusses her personal style being vastly different from her character's, and her initial reluctance to pursue acting, believing she wasn't a good actor. However, she now acknowledges enjoying the work and the close friendship with co-star Aaliyah Sheppard.
Rapp reveals that she has a pattern of dating people who look similar to each other, noting they appear to be "from the same mother and father." She mentions currently being in a happy relationship where she feels appreciated and doesn't need to make herself smaller. The interview concludes with Rapp performing two songs: "Too Well," about moving past anger toward an ex, and "Bruises," which originated from an incident where she told a friend she'd had sex on his couch, only to have her friend group mock her for it—inspiring the song about how easily she bruises emotionally.
About this episode
Reneé Rapp joins Call Her Daddy to discuss the hardships she's navigated while managing the rise of her career. Reneé speaks about growing up in North Carolina and the difficulties she faced when trying to come out to her friends and family. She explains why her first year on set at Sex Lives of College Girls was a horrible experience and why she hated going into work. Reneé opens up about her struggles with disordered eating and how those struggles were exacerbated while working on Broadway. She details her experience in a toxic relationship and takes Alex through her dating history person by person. Stick around for Reneé’s live performance of “Too Well” and “Bruises." This episode includes discussion of disordered eating. Please keep this in mind when deciding if, how and when you’ll listen.
Key Insights
- Rapp grew up with absolute confidence she would become a star despite having no logical basis for that belief, attributing it entirely to 'delusion' as a child.
- Rapp experienced years of bullying not just from peers but from other students' mothers who created group chats to mock her and her casting in theater productions.
- Rapp's family and extended community only became publicly accepting of her bisexuality once she became visible on a television show, which she resents because they withheld that acceptance when she needed it as a child.
- During her Mean Girls Broadway run, costume designers unilaterally changed her outfit to add a skirt over a corset, framing it as flattering when it was actually a response to her body size being deemed unsuitable for the original design.
- Rapp actively hid her professional successes and career achievements from her romantic partner to avoid making him and his family uncomfortable, fundamentally compromising her own ambitions.
- Upon breaking up with her partner, Rapp immediately felt liberated and believed her entire career trajectory would change because she no longer had to suppress her success to make someone else comfortable.
- Rapp dates people who look remarkably similar to each other, and admits she was in a phase of exclusively dating blonde women, partially because she subconsciously method acts her character's romantic preferences.
- Rapp expresses that fame has paradoxically validated the sensitive and emotional traits that made her a 'ticking time bomb' outcast as a child, transforming them into celebrated aspects of her public persona.
Topics
Transcript
Call Her Daddy is brought to you by American Eagle. Holiday outfits just got way easier. American Eagle's new arrivals are basically everything you need right now. Super soft sweaters, lightweight layers, comfy lounge styles, heritage faves, and low rise jeans that are very much back in the rotation. Whether you're heading to a holiday thing or just hanging with your people, there's something for every plan. Just don't wait too long. Your new faves won't be around forever. You can check it all out at AE.com or just go to the store. Call Her Daddy is brought to you by Pandora Jewelry. Make their holiday unforgettable with a gift that says it all from Pandora Jewelry. I feel like…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Call Her Daddy
Trixie Mattel: Makeup, Motels & Moving On
Trixie Mattel discusses her journey from a small Wisconsin town to becoming a successful drag queen, entrepreneur, and media personality. She shares insights on overcoming trauma, the importance of creative process over outcomes, and her various business ventures including the Trixie Motel in Palm Springs.
Is Your Parent a Narcissist? (FBF)
Clinical psychologist Dr. Sherry Campbell discusses toxic family dynamics and narcissistic parenting with host Alex Cooper, sharing her personal experience as a scapegoated child and offering strategies for setting boundaries, including gray rocking and cordial contact, ultimately advocating for survivors to prioritize their wellbeing over maintaining abusive family relationships.
Malin Akerman: The Hunting Wives, Hustling & Healing
Malin Akerman discusses her journey from Sweden to Canada to Los Angeles, her experiences in modeling and acting, her marriage, motherhood, and her role in the hit series 'The Hunting Wives.' She shares insights about personal growth, therapy, relationships, and the importance of vulnerability and communication.
Before You Blow Up Your Life
Host Alex discusses whether to make major life changes, presenting three key questions to ask before 'blowing up your life': Are you bored (needing stimulation vs. being dissatisfied)? Are you escaping something (running away vs. running toward)? Are you idealizing a fantasy rather than seeing reality? The episode emphasizes making informed decisions from an internal place rather than seeking external fixes for internal problems.
Dr. Orna Guralnik: Couples Therapy 101 (FBF)
Dr. Orna Guralnik discusses couples therapy, relationship dynamics, and how childhood trauma shapes adult romantic patterns. She explains when couples therapy is appropriate, how to navigate conflict productively, and why people stay in unhealthy relationships.