My Pregnancy Story
Alex Cooper of Call Her Daddy announces her pregnancy, sharing the emotional journey of trying to conceive, hiding the pregnancy, and ultimately deciding to go public. She reflects on why she delayed starting a family after marriage and how she knew she was finally ready. The episode blends personal storytelling with broader reflections on women's autonomy over their reproductive choices.
Summary
Alex Cooper opens the episode by announcing her pregnancy to the Daddy Gang, acknowledging that the topic can be sensitive for women on different parts of their own journeys. She recounts that a year prior, she had shared on the podcast that she and her husband Matt had decided to pause starting a family in the summer of 2024, shortly after their wedding, because she felt she needed more time for herself, her relationship, and her career.
Alex describes the turning point when she finally felt ready — a night in the hot tub with Matt where she told him the only thing missing from their life was a child. She describes the experience of trying to conceive as initially exciting and connecting, but gradually becoming more regimented and emotionally taxing. She tracked ovulation obsessively, and each negative test brought increasing disappointment and anxiety. She credits Matt's supportive attitude — framing it as something they were going through together — as essential during this period.
She then tells the story of discovering she was pregnant on a Tuesday morning after Matt had left for a work trip. After weeks of negative pink strip tests, she bought digital tests, and both came back positive immediately. She made the deliberate choice not to tell Matt over the phone, instead holding the secret for four agonizing days. She describes the mental and emotional experience of sitting alone with the news, conducting interviews for the show while internally bursting with excitement, and even lying to Matt over text claiming she had gotten her period to preserve the surprise. When Matt returned home, she placed the pregnancy test in his hands, and they shared an emotional, wordless moment together.
Alex discusses her first trimester in detail — the extreme hunger in early weeks, followed by severe nausea that she insists should not be called 'morning sickness' since it lasted all day. She describes curling up on her office floor between meetings to cope, and the counterintuitive advice that eating more frequently helps reduce nausea. She also opens up about pregnancy-related anxiety, particularly the fear between ultrasound appointments about the baby's wellbeing, which she says was alleviated once she could feel the baby kick.
She recounts attempting to hide the pregnancy at a major New York City work event, wearing a suit with buttons that kept popping open over her bump, lying horizontal in an SUV to prevent the buttons from bursting, and barely surviving the red carpet. The post-event rumors were about her and Matt's supposedly cold body language — not about a baby bump — which she considered a win. However, after that event, Matt encouraged her to announce, pointing out that the secrecy was causing more stress than relief. She posted a photo on May 17th from upstate New York and felt immediate relief.
The episode concludes with Alex reflecting on how she knew she was ready for motherhood, emphasizing that there was no single triggering event — just an internal feeling of readiness, combined with confidence in her partnership with Matt and satisfaction with how she had spent her late 20s and early 30s. She argues that women should not let societal timelines dictate their reproductive choices, that living freely in her 20s made her a more emotionally prepared parent, and that women's decisions — whether to have children young, old, alone, or not at all — deserve equal respect. She promises the show will not become exclusively a 'mom podcast' and will continue covering the full range of her life.
Key Insights
- Alex argues that trying to conceive starts as an exciting, connecting experience with a partner but quickly shifts into a regimented, scheduled, and emotionally taxing process once the ovulation tracking begins.
- Alex claims that each negative pregnancy test felt like 'starting from zero again,' creating a groundhog-day cycle of waiting, hoping, and disappointment that intensified her desire to get pregnant over time.
- Alex argues that the term 'morning sickness' is a dangerous misnomer — she describes it as an all-day debilitating condition, not a minor morning inconvenience, and says women should stop using the softened language.
- Alex found that eating more frequently — counterintuitive when nauseous — was the key to managing pregnancy nausea, and she wishes she had known this earlier in her first trimester.
- Alex says she is not naturally an anxious person, but pregnancy introduced a new form of anxiety: the fear between ultrasound appointments that the baby might not be okay, which she describes as hard to sit with but which was alleviated once she felt the baby kick.
- Alex deliberately chose not to tell Matt she was pregnant over the phone, holding the secret for four days while he was on a work trip, because she wanted them to share the moment in person — a decision she says was painful but ultimately meaningful.
- Alex claims she lied to Matt via text — telling him she had gotten her period — in order to completely eliminate any possibility he would suspect a pregnancy announcement upon returning home.
- Alex argues that the process of hiding her pregnancy at a public work event was causing her more anxiety than the idea of simply announcing it, which became the deciding factor in going public when she did.
- Alex contends that living freely and making her own choices in her 20s — including being hurt, making mistakes, and prioritizing herself — was a prerequisite for becoming the emotionally stable and ready person she is now as a parent.
- Alex argues that women should not copy her timeline or use her story as a guidebook, but rather use the sentiment of it — giving themselves grace to live on their own terms — as the actual takeaway.
- Alex claims that having a strong individual foundation and a secure partnership made her confident that she could handle parenthood, and that waiting until she felt genuinely ready rather than societally pressured was essential to her happiness.
- Alex states that Call Her Daddy will not become exclusively a mom podcast, framing her pregnancy as an additional layer to her identity rather than a replacement for her existing professional and personal persona.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access