Maria Georgas: I Made Out with My Boyfriend’s Mistress (FBF)
Maria Georgas discusses her Bachelor season experience, including the manufactured drama with other contestants, her decision to decline the Bachelorette offer, and her past relationship involving infidelity where she ultimately befriended the other woman involved. She reflects on her growth regarding vulnerability, walls, and her approach to future dating.
Summary
Maria Georgas appears on Call Her Daddy to discuss her Bachelor season and subsequent media attention. She addresses the drama that unfolded during filming, particularly the conflict with contestants Sydney and Medina, explaining that her comments about age were misinterpreted when overheard out of context. She clarifies her past connection with Nick Viall was merely friendship and that people speculated it was more serious than it was.
Regarding her personal relationship history, Maria shares details about her first serious boyfriend of eight months, during which she lived with him for three months. She discovered his infidelity by strategically checking security footage at his apartment building after noticing suspicious behavior. Rather than immediately confronting him, she met the other woman through mutual friends and they became genuine friends. She eventually made out with this woman while drinking, partly to understand what the boyfriend saw in her, and they remain close friends to this day.
Maria discusses her experience on The Bachelor with Joey Graziadei, revealing that she strategically used Jen kissing Joey as an excuse to leave because she intuitively knew she wasn't end game for him, even though she had genuine feelings. She explains her walls and self-protective mechanisms that led to pushing away interested partners, though she claims to have had an epiphany about this pattern.
The episode's most significant revelation involves Maria's decision to decline the Bachelorette role despite having fittings scheduled and the role essentially being hers to accept. She explains feeling overwhelmed and unprepared to isolate herself again in that environment, despite everyone's support. She addresses criticism from Wells Adams, who suggested she had unreasonable demands, defending her decision as prioritizing mental health over capitalizing on fame.
Maria discusses her approach to dating, preferring to meet someone organically without apps or social media. She plays a dating scenario game where she evaluates various red flags and preferences, including being turned off by men who flex their wealth, preferring guys who text back quickly, only sexting when exclusive, and being suspicious of men with fully stocked bathrooms for women. She describes her 'honesty hour' approach where she asks early dates what their exes would say about them.
About this episode
Hope you enjoy this throwback episode! Originally aired on April 30, 2024. Join Alex in the studio for Maria Georgas’ first exclusive interview after her time on The Bachelor. Maria does not hold back and tells some truly wild stories from her dating life before the show. She reveals the great lengths she went to in order to prove her boyfriend was cheating on her, including convincing the apartment concierge to show her security footage and making out with his mistress. Alex and Maria give their hilarious takes on bad first date scenarios and discuss what’s going on in Maria’s current dating life. Then, Alex asks the question we’ve all been wondering… was Maria approached to be The Bachelorette? Maria gets real about all the drama this season, how it impacted her, what really happened at hometowns, and the moment she wanted off the show entirely. This episode is full of tea, crazy stories, and great girl talk… Enjoy!
Key Insights
- Maria was offered and scheduled for the Bachelorette role with fittings completed, but declined it because she felt mentally unprepared to isolate herself again, prioritizing mental health over capitalizing on the opportunity.
- Maria discovered her boyfriend's infidelity by asking the apartment building's front desk to check security footage for a specific time period, claiming she lost her purse, then watched another woman arrive at 3:20 AM.
- Maria intentionally made out with her ex-boyfriend's mistress while drunk to understand what he saw in her, and subsequently became genuine friends with the woman rather than holding animosity toward her.
- Maria used Jen kissing Joey as a deliberate excuse to exit the Bachelor competition because she had already determined they weren't end game, even though she had real feelings for him.
- Maria claims she has self-sabotaging patterns where she pushes interested men away to test their commitment, causing them to leave, after which she realizes she wants them back when it's too late.
- Maria states she experienced an 'epiphany' about her relationship patterns and claims to be a 'whole different person now' who won't play games with people she's genuinely attracted to.
- Wells Adams publicly criticized Maria's Bachelorette decline, suggesting she had unreasonable demands like wanting her phone and a friend as a producer, which Maria characterizes as speaking from a place of ignorance.
- Maria experienced a villain edit narrative on her Bachelor season that she felt was unjustified, as she claimed to have been wrongly accused and that America ultimately supported her rather than buying the villain narrative.
- Maria states she has only had two significant boyfriends in her life, describing her past relationships as having 'loving feelings' but questioning whether she was ever truly in love.
- Maria prefers meeting romantic interests organically without dating apps and is skeptical of men who display wealth verbally, instead preferring those who demonstrate it through actions like offering to take her to Paris.
- Maria implements an 'honesty hour' strategy on early dates where she asks men what their exes would say about them to gauge how they speak about past relationships and their self-awareness.
- Maria states she will only sext someone if she's in an exclusive relationship with them, and views sporadic sexting as something that should be special rather than constant communication.
Topics
Transcript
Call Her Daddy is brought to you by Ross. Summer is here and Ross is where it begins. Summer is basically permission to dress and decorate like your mood board from flowy dresses and denim shorts to graphic tees you'll live in. Ross has the standout pieces to build your perfect wardrobe. And when it's time to refresh your outdoor space, think pillows, planters, trays, and all the little extras that turn your patio into a whole vibe. Find your nearest ross at rossstores.com call her daddy is brought to you by silk if you're trying to get more protein into your routine i know i am especially in the morning you already know it's not always easy to find…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Call Her Daddy
The Unknowns of Motherhood
Alex Cooper discusses the psychological and physical challenges of transitioning to motherhood, emphasizing that women can simultaneously feel excited and terrified about becoming mothers without shame. She explores the concept of 'matrescence,' the grief of losing one's former identity, and argues that society's toxic binary expectations of mothers prevent honest conversations about the real fears and ambivalence that accompany pregnancy.
How to Heal Your Trust Issues
Alexandra Cooper discusses how a formative relationship with a manipulative, unfaithful boyfriend created deep trust issues that followed her through subsequent relationships, and how she eventually healed those issues through therapy, self-awareness, and a partner (Matt) who consistently demonstrated trustworthiness and emotional safety.
Sonja & Luann: Pirates, Palm Beach & Picking Up Men
Sonja Morgan and Luann de Lesseps discuss their return to reality television with 'The Golden Life,' a new show featuring OG Real Housewives of New York cast members. They reflect on their decades-long friendship, dating experiences in their 60s, and how they've evolved as women and entrepreneurs since their original Housewives run.
Unreliable Boyfriends & Unexpected Proposals
Alex Cooper hosts a Call Her Daddy Sunday session where she answers listener questions about relationships, including topics like friendship betrayals, unreliable partners, flirting boundaries, long-distance visits, aggressive behavior, sexual compatibility, and unexpected proposals. She shares personal anecdotes from her college days and provides candid relationship advice based on her experiences.
Tinashe: Broke Boys, Golf Bros & Short Kings
Tinashe discusses her journey from a 14-year-old girl group member to an independent artist, navigating industry pressures while maintaining authenticity. She shares insights on dating standards, relationship patterns, and her new album 'Pop Star,' emphasizing the importance of not conforming to industry expectations and prioritizing personal fulfillment over external validation.