Denise Huskins: My Kidnapping Story (FBF)
Denise Huskins recounts her kidnapping in 2015 by a man who claimed to represent a criminal organization targeting her boyfriend Aaron's ex-fiancée. After her release, she faced widespread public disbelief, media scrutiny comparing her to the "Gone Girl" hoax narrative, and interrogation by law enforcement who suspected her of fabricating the story—until the perpetrator was caught attacking another family.
Summary
Denise Huskins, a 29-year-old physical therapist, was kidnapped from her boyfriend Aaron's home in Vallejo, California in March 2015 after they had spent an emotionally intimate evening discussing their seven-month relationship. The kidnapping was a meticulously planned home invasion involving multiple perpetrators with tactical equipment, laser pointers, and sedatives. Denise was told the abduction was intended for Aaron's ex-fiancée but was meant for her instead, then transported in car trunks to an isolated cabin where she was held for 48 hours, sexually assaulted twice, and threatened with recorded video being released online if she contacted police.
Denise's survival strategy involved psychological de-escalation and rapport-building with her captor rather than physical resistance, recognizing her physical limitations against an armed male attacker. She remained outwardly calm, gathered information about her surroundings, and attempted to humanize herself to her captor by engaging in conversations about his claimed military background and trauma.
Upon release, Denise was dropped near her mother's home and immediately sought legal counsel. However, the Vallejo Police Department held a press conference declaring her kidnapping a hoax, and law enforcement treated both Denise and Aaron as suspects rather than victims. The media and public drew comparisons to the "Gone Girl" narrative, with some theorizing she fabricated the story for attention or fame. An FBI agent told her attorney he was 99% certain she was lying. Despite submitting to a SART (Sexual Assault Response Team) examination and undergoing 18 hours of FBI interrogation, law enforcement remained skeptical.
A female detective named Misty Carrasquillo, investigating a separate kidnapping and assault case, discovered a blonde hair on swim goggles when her victim had dark hair. This led her to investigate beyond her assigned case and eventually connect the crimes, identifying the perpetrator and validating Denise's account. The lead detective who had publicly declared her story false was subsequently named officer of the year.
Denise describes the period after her release as more psychologically damaging than captivity itself. She lost her professional credibility as a physical therapist, experienced severe trauma from public shaming and disbelief, and struggled with hypervigilance and fear that her captor's threats to monitor her family would be carried out. She and Aaron remained together, supporting each other through therapy and gradually rebuilding their lives. They have since married, had children, and become advocates for law enforcement reform and victim support. Denise emphasizes that her survival was not due to exceptional strength or screaming, but rather her deliberate choice to remain calm, gather information, and build rapport—a survival technique many women unconsciously employ due to their physical vulnerability in violent situations.
About this episode
Join Alex in the studio for a powerful interview with kidnapping and assault survivor Denise Huskins. In 2015, Denise was taken from her boyfriend’s house in the middle of the night. She was held for days, drugged, and assaulted before finally being released by her captors. But when Denise told the police what had happened to her, nobody believed her. In fact, they attacked her. They called her a liar, hoaxster, fraud, and the real life “Gone Girl.” They claimed she’d made it all up for fame and attention. Today, Denise is here to tell her incredible story of overcoming trauma, staying calm in the midst of chaos, and fighting for the truth. This is an important conversation about what it takes for women to be believed, the problem with victim blaming, and how Denise was finally able to reclaim her name and her life.
Key Insights
- Denise employed a psychological survival strategy of rapport-building and de-escalation rather than physical resistance, recognizing that fighting against an armed captor would likely result in her death.
- The captor's politeness and procedural language masked underlying aggression, and Denise recognized this as potential psychological manipulation designed to condition her behavior through rewards and controlled freedom.
- Law enforcement immediately suspected Denise and Aaron of murder or conspiracy rather than treating them as victims, with the lead detective stating he was searching for a dead body, not a living survivor.
- The FBI agent investigating the case told Denise's attorney he was 99% certain she was lying and instructed him to watch the movie Gone Girl, demonstrating that law enforcement made victim credibility judgments based on fictional narratives rather than evidence.
- Women's trauma responses including calmness, lack of visible injury, and measured emotional expression were used against Denise as evidence of deception, whereas male victims' similar responses are recognized as normal survival tactics.
- A female detective (Misty Carrasquillo) was the only law enforcement officer to look beyond her assigned case and pursue connections that validated Denise's account, eventually identifying the perpetrator after the police department had publicly branded her a liar.
- Denise experienced greater psychological harm from public disbelief and media scrutiny after her release than from the kidnapping and assault itself, losing her professional identity and facing constant self-blame.
- The lead detective who publicly declared Denise's kidnapping a hoax and whose false accusations appeared in a widely-publicized press conference was subsequently awarded officer of the year by his department.
- Denise's survival instinct included consciously detaching from her body during sexual assault, viewing the experience from outside herself as a coping mechanism, which created long-term disconnection between her logical understanding and bodily processing of trauma.
- The captor's threats to monitor Denise's family for years and release video evidence of assault online created continued psychological captivity even after physical release, making her fear subsequent public exposure about her case.
- Denise credits her and Aaron's survival of their relationship to never blaming each other, maintaining open communication about struggles, and recognizing when dynamics needed to change rather than pointing fingers.
- Women are socialized to believe that fighting back will escalate violence, yet law enforcement and the public interpreted Denise's non-resistance as evidence of fabrication, reflecting a fundamental disconnect between female survival training and institutional expectations.
Topics
Transcript
Call Her Daddy is brought to you by Bright by Scotch Bright. Daddy gang, a lot of us obviously take pride in where we live, right? We want the decor to look good and then we want the lighting and the cleaning and all of it. And you want it to look spotless and you want it to look really nice, right? So level up your clean routine with Bright's line of sponges. Use the palm scrubber with a comfy grip for serious scrubs, the easy-to-fill leak-proof dish wand to keep hands out of the mess, or the scrub and wipe for a scrubbing side and a sudsing side. All three look good, scrub great, and they come with handy…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Call Her Daddy
Sophia Bush: Brooke Davis, Breakups & Beginning Again
Sophia Bush discusses her memoir covering her journey from USC to One Tree Hill stardom, her experiences with workplace harassment and sexualization, her failed marriages, and her recent marriage to Ashlyn Harris. She reflects on learning to trust her intuition, advocating for herself, and finding authentic happiness after years of dissociation and people-pleasing.
Heather McMahan: Dog Shows, Neck Lifts & Airport Fits
Heather McMahon discusses her comedy career, recent experiences hosting at the Ryder Cup and dog show, her neck lift recovery, gout diagnosis, move from her mother's house, and her new special 'Buy a Thread' on Hulu. She shares stories about travel mishaps, her dogs, and lessons learned about professional boundaries.
I am Jane Doe
Dr. Kate Manne, a feminist philosopher at Cornell University, discusses the Jane Doe case involving alleged gang rape at a Chi Phi fraternity in the context of broader institutional failures, rape culture, and the systematic betrayal of sexual assault survivors. The conversation examines why institutional systems fail victims, the role of misogyny and patriarchy in enabling sexual violence, and what meaningful change requires beyond awareness campaigns.
The Unknowns of Motherhood
Alex Cooper discusses the psychological and physical challenges of transitioning to motherhood, emphasizing that women can simultaneously feel excited and terrified about becoming mothers without shame. She explores the concept of 'matrescence,' the grief of losing one's former identity, and argues that society's toxic binary expectations of mothers prevent honest conversations about the real fears and ambivalence that accompany pregnancy.
How to Heal Your Trust Issues
Alexandra Cooper discusses how a formative relationship with a manipulative, unfaithful boyfriend created deep trust issues that followed her through subsequent relationships, and how she eventually healed those issues through therapy, self-awareness, and a partner (Matt) who consistently demonstrated trustworthiness and emotional safety.