DiscussionNews

Retail Real Estate Outlook: Holiday Sales and Tight Supply | Tom McGee, ICSC

America‘s Commercial Real Estate Show26m 9s

Tom McGee, CEO of ICSC, discusses strong retail sales growth with a forecasted 4.3-4.9% increase for Q4, driven by robust employment markets despite consumer concerns about inflation. The retail real estate sector faces a significant supply-demand mismatch, with high occupancy rates and limited new development since the financial crisis, while technology and AI are increasingly shaping how retailers and consumers interact.

Summary

Tom McGee, president and CEO of the International Council of Shopping Centers (ICSC), discusses the current state of retail and retail real estate in this interview. Despite economic headwinds including gas prices, tariffs, and global conflicts, retail remains strong. The employment market continues to support consumer spending at historically low unemployment rates. McGee forecasts retail sales growth of 4.3-4.9% in Q4, with consumers expected to spend an average of $650 on holiday items, reaching a total of $1.7 trillion in holiday-related sales.

A key finding is the significant income disparity in consumer behavior: the top 10% of income earners spend five times the average ($3,250+) and account for 50% of all consumer spending, while the remaining 90% remain price-conscious amid inflation concerns. This growing wealth disparity is driving overall sales averages despite cost pressures on middle and lower-income consumers.

On the real estate side, the industry faces a substantial supply-demand mismatch. Retail sales have more than doubled since the global financial crisis, yet there has been very little net new retail development. Retailers now use stores for multiple purposes, including fulfillment centers and omnichannel operations, creating unprecedented demand for well-positioned retail space. Occupancy rates remain at historically high levels across all segments—regional malls, open-air retail, and standalone properties. Grocery-anchored suburban open-air centers and traditional malls are the strongest performing sectors, benefiting from remote work trends that have reduced office-to-home commuting and increased local shopping trips.

Technology and AI are increasingly important to retailers and consumers. Consumers are better informed before shopping, researching products online and using AI tools. Retailers must adapt by determining whether individual stores serve convenience-oriented or discovery-oriented purposes and curating their store layouts and personnel training accordingly. Shopping centers must similarly align their tenant mix and physical design to support their positioning. McGee emphasizes that despite technological advances, fundamental retail principles remain critical: strong merchandising, competitive pricing, and exceptional customer service.

McGee also addresses challenges like vacant drugstore locations, attributing these to healthcare industry changes rather than retail dynamics. He notes that in the current tight supply environment, vacant retail space typically fills quickly, especially in well-positioned suburban locations. ICSC events, particularly the Vegas conference, serve primarily as deal-making platforms rather than traditional trade shows, with membership-driven networking that directly results in contracts and leasing activity.

The host Michael Bull shares practical examples of AI challenges in commercial real estate, including AI-generated business plans with excessive fluff, AI-drafted lease amendments that damage negotiations, and AI-created listing agreements that made reasonable business partners appear unreasonable. McGee reinforces that while AI should enable efficiency, it cannot replace the relationship-based nature of commercial real estate.

For the outlook, McGee predicts continued retail strength as long as employment holds, though some warning signs exist regarding income segment disparities in price sensitivity. He advises retailers and landlords to begin with consumer needs, maintain strong alignment between retailers and landlords, and curate experiences appropriate to the center's positioning—whether convenience or discovery-oriented.

About this episode

Holiday retail sales are forecast to grow 4.3% to 4.9% while retail space stays scarce. ICSC CEO Tom McGee joins Michael Bull, CCIM to explain why. Retail sales have more than doubled since the global financial crisis, yet very little new retail space has been built. The result is historically high occupancy across regional malls, open-air centers, and standalone retail, with retailers competing for well-positioned space. Tom breaks down ICSC's fourth quarter forecast of $1.7 trillion in retail sales, why the top 10% of earners account for 50% of all consumer spending, and why the other 90% are watching prices closely. The conversation covers the formats with the most momentum (grocery-anchored and suburban open-air centers), what happens to dark drugstores, and findings from ICSC's Shopping in the Age of AI report with McKinsey on convenience-oriented and discovery-oriented stores. Tom explains why ICSC events are built for dealmaking, including 4,000 participants at ICSC+PROPTECH in Las Vegas, and Michael shares how an AI-drafted markup of a listing agreement nearly derailed an $11 million listing. In this episode:00:00  Retail Outlook: Gas Prices, Tariffs, and Inflation01:10  Retail Sales Growth and a Strong Job Market03:30  Holiday Forecast: $1.7 Trillion, 4.3% to 4.9% Growth05:18  Top 10% of Earners Drive 50% of Consumer Spending06:20  Stock Market, Home Equity, and the Wealth Effect06:59  Gas Prices and Discretionary Spending07:50  Shopping in the Age of AI: Convenience vs. Discovery Stores10:53  ICSC Southeast: Dealmaking in Atlanta12:46  ICSC Las Vegas and 4,000 at ICSC+PROPTECH14:32  Who's Expanding: Discount, Grocery-Anchored, Open-Air16:20  Dark Drugstores: Why Vacant Retail Gets Snapped Up18:10  Retail Tips: Merchandising, Pricing, Customer Service20:09  Chick-fil-A Outparcels and Retail as Social Space21:49  AI-Lawyered Leases and Listing Agreements24:12  Final Takeaway: A Resilient Consumer and Warning Signs Connect with Tom McGee:https://www.linkedin.com/in/tommcgee2/ICSC Website: https://www.icsc.com Connect with Michael Bull & The Show:Michael Bull, CCIMBull Realty, Inchttps://www.linkedin.com/in/michaelbull/ For more commercial real estate market data, sector forecasts, and video episodes, visit CREshow.com. America's Commercial Real Estate Show is brought to you by our proud sponsors. TCN Worldwide: Commercial real estate property management, leasing, and sales solutions across the US and globally. Learn more: https://www.tcnworldwide.com Build Out: The ultimate product suite for commercial real estate brokerage firms looking to streamline their business. Learn more: https://www.buildout.com Bull Realty: Regional commercial real estate brokerage services headquartered in Atlanta, delivering market intel and strategies. Learn more: https://www.bullrealty.com Commercial Agent Success Strategies: Twenty-one cloud accessed commercial broker training videos with slide deck action notes. Learn more at https://www.commercialagentsuccess.com/ #RetailRealEstate #CommercialRealEstate #CRE #ICSC #ShoppingCenters #HolidaySales #RetailSales #ConsumerSpending #RetailAI #MichaelBull #CREShow

Key Insights

  • McGee argues that the top 10% of income earners spend five times the average consumer ($3,250+ vs. $650) and represent 50% of all consumer spending, meaning that overall retail growth statistics mask a significant price-conscious lower-income consumer base.
  • Despite retail sales more than doubling since the 2008 financial crisis, there has been very little net new retail real estate development, creating a tight supply-demand mismatch that keeps occupancy rates at historically high levels across all retail segments.
  • McGee contends that employment rates are more predictive of retail sales than stock market performance, with strong job confidence driving consumer spending regardless of other economic headwinds like inflation and gas prices.
  • Retailers and landlords must align store strategy around whether locations serve convenience-oriented purposes (quick in-and-out trips) or discovery-oriented purposes (lingering and browsing), as this determines appropriate store layout, merchandising, parking design, and tenant mix curation.
  • McGee emphasizes that despite increased AI and technology adoption, retail fundamentals remain unchanged: strong merchandising, competitive pricing, and exceptional customer service are the differentiators that allow retailers to compete effectively in any economic environment.

Topics

Retail sales forecasts and Q4 holiday shopping trendsIncome disparity in consumer spending patternsSupply-demand mismatch in retail real estateOccupancy rates and lack of new developmentTechnology and AI adoption in retailStore positioning: convenience vs. discovery-orientedStrong employment market supporting retail growthSuburban open-air and grocery-anchored centers outperformanceOmnichannel retail and fulfillment center integrationICSC networking and deal-making events

Transcript

welcome to America's commercial real estate show I'm Michael Bull thank you for being with us this show is brought to you by TCN worldwide comm check it out if you need commercial real estate brokerage services anywhere in the world or the U.S. Acquisitions, dispositions, property management, site selection, or just consulting. It's TCNWorldwide.com. Well, today we're going to talk about retail. And I think retail is an interesting topic today because what's going on in the economy? It seems like there's been these headwinds with gas prices, with tariffs, with wars, and people seem to be concerned. But how are retailers doing? How are consumers looking at it? How are retail properties doing? Well, let's find out. Please…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from America‘s Commercial Real Estate Show

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.