ResearchDiscussion

Office Vacancy Is High, So Why Are Rents Rising? | Phil Mobley, CoStar

America‘s Commercial Real Estate Show35m 3s

Phil Mobley from CoStar discusses the paradox of rising office rents despite high vacancy rates, explaining that the market is experiencing a K-shaped recovery where premium buildings are increasingly occupied while secondary buildings struggle. The office sector is stabilizing with structural changes in demand, reduced new supply, and a shift toward smaller lease sizes and occupier-driven purchases.

Summary

Phil Mobley, National Director of Office Analytics at CoStar, provides an in-depth analysis of the current office real estate market. The national office vacancy rate stands at 13.6%, approximately 100 basis points higher than the post-Great Recession peak, though it has declined 50 basis points over the past 15 months, indicating an ongoing recovery. However, the recovery is uneven and fractured across multiple dimensions.

The market is experiencing a pronounced K-shaped recovery. The top-tier, most desirable buildings are becoming increasingly occupied, while secondary and lower-quality buildings concentrate the majority of vacant space. Historically, 20% of buildings with 25%+ vacancy housed about two-thirds of all vacant space; this has now increased to 80%. Conversely, high-occupancy buildings (less than 10% vacant) now contain only 4% of total vacant space compared to the historical 10%. This polarization means success depends on building quality, location, amenities, ownership stability, and capital availability rather than simple class designations.

Rent growth is occurring despite high headline vacancy, with rents increasing 2.5% over the past 12 months—the highest rate since the pandemic. This paradox exists because desirable space is extremely tight, even as overall vacancy remains elevated. Landlords with strong capital stacks can invest in suite build-outs, lobby renovations, and pre-built spec suites to capture demand from smaller occupiers and fast-moving tenants like AI startups.

Geographic variation is significant. Midtown Manhattan shows strong trickle-down demand from Class A to Class B buildings, while markets like Washington D.C., Chicago, and Los Angeles struggle with employment headwinds and slower occupancy recovery. The Bay Area still exhibits elevated remote work compared to the national average.

Lease size has contracted 12-15% below pre-pandemic averages, driven by limited new supply and major corporate inability to relocate. This means leasing volume hasn't fully recovered despite transaction counts returning to historical levels. Back-to-office attendance has stabilized at approximately 70-80% of pre-pandemic levels and remains flat, with occupiers realizing value in collaborative office use even at reduced frequency.

Regarding AI's impact, Mobley notes that AI firms themselves have been hiring and leasing space, creating positive demand. However, the long-term displacement versus augmentation effects remain uncertain. Entry-level hiring may be slowing, though causation to AI specifically is unclear. The jury remains out pending potential recession scenarios where companies might permanently reduce headcount.

On investment sales, transaction volume was up 10% year-over-year through Q3 but has moved sideways recently due to 10-year Treasury volatility. Pricing corrected approximately 20% over nearly four years (versus 30% over two years during the Great Recession) and has been essentially flat for six months. User purchases have normalized from 30% back toward historical 12-15% levels as institutional investors have returned, though users still account for 20-25% of trades. Mobley forecasts cap rates will continue to compress for office, differentiating office from industrial and multifamily where cap rates are expected to move sideways or expand.

Longer-term forecasts show vacancy will decline only modestly due to supply contraction rather than demand resurgence. Demographics suggest job growth will remain muted at 0.3-0.5% annually versus 2% historically. Effective rent growth should continue driven by competition for premium space, even with flat aggregate demand. Removing non-competitive space from inventory won't significantly improve lease economics for occupiers seeking quality space, as they're already facing a tight market despite high headline vacancy.

The key to successful office investment is landlord capital strength and ability to strategically deploy it through renovations, TI packages, and building upgrades to compete with top-tier space.

About this episode

Office vacancy sits at 13.6%, yet rents just rose 2.5%. Michael Bull, CCIM and CoStar's Phil Mobley explain the office market outlook and cap rates. Phil Mobley, National Director of U.S. Office Analytics at CoStar, breaks down an office recovery that is real but uneven. National vacancy is down 50 basis points in 15 months, though still 100 basis points above the Great Recession peak. The buildings with at least 25% vacancy now hold about 80% of all vacant space, up from two-thirds historically, while the best buildings hold just 4%. Phil calls it the office sector's version of the K-shaped recovery. The conversation covers why lease sizes are running 12% to 15% below pre-pandemic averages, why office attendance has settled at 70% to 80% of pre-pandemic levels, and what AI means for office demand so far. On the investment side, office sales volume was up about 10% year over year through Q3 after a 20% price correction, user buyers have fallen from about 30% of trades back to 20% to 25%, and CoStar forecasts office cap rates to keep compressing even as industrial and multifamily cap rates hold flat or expand. Phil closes with the forecast: vacancy drifting lower but staying above 13% through the end of the decade, driven by shrinking supply more than new demand, and why landlord capital will be the deciding factor for the next five years. In this episode:00:00 Office Headlines vs. What's Really Happening01:33 National Office Vacancy at 13.6% and Falling02:55 The K-Shaped Office Recovery: 80% of Vacancy in 20% of Buildings05:34 Landlord Capital, Spec Suites and TI Packages06:45 Trickle-Down Demand: Manhattan vs. DC, Chicago and LA08:09 Lease Sizes 15% Smaller as New Supply Dries Up10:19 Return to Office: Attendance Holding at 70% to 80%14:30 AI and Office Employment: Augmenter or Displacer?18:28 Office Investment Sales: Volume Up 10%, Prices Down 20%23:04 Why CoStar Forecasts Office Cap Rates to Compress24:43 User Buyers: From 30% of Trades Back to 20% to 25%26:55 Buy of the Decade? Date the Rate, Marry the Deal28:25 Vacancy Forecast Above 13% and Rent Growth at 2.5%32:14 Final Takeaway: Landlord Capital Is King Connect with Phil Mobley:https://www.linkedin.com/in/phil-mobley/CoStar Website: https://www.costar.com Contact Michael Bull:[email protected] x 101Bull Realty, Inchttps://www.linkedin.com/in/michaelbull/ For more commercial real estate market data, sector forecasts, and video episodes, visit CREshow.com. America's Commercial Real Estate Show is brought to you by our proud sponsors. TCN Worldwide: Commercial real estate property management, leasing, and sales solutions across the US and globally. Learn more: https://www.tcnworldwide.com Bull Realty: Regional commercial real estate brokerage services headquartered in Atlanta, delivering market intel and strategies. Learn more: https://www.bullrealty.com Commercial Agent Success Strategies: Twenty-one cloud accessed commercial broker training videos with slide deck action notes. Learn more at https://www.commercialagentsuccess.com/ #CommercialRealEstate #CRE #OfficeMarket #OfficeRealEstate #CoStar #CapRates #OfficeVacancy #ReturnToOffice #RealEstateInvesting #CREShow

Key Insights

  • The office market is experiencing a K-shaped recovery where top-tier buildings achieve increasingly high occupancy while secondary buildings house 80% of total vacant space, creating a bifurcated market.
  • Rents are growing at 2.5% annually despite 13.6% headline vacancy because desirable space is extremely constrained while non-competitive space sits empty.
  • Lease sizes have contracted 12-15% below pre-pandemic levels because major corporations cannot find sufficient new supply to relocate and occupy, forcing smaller tenants to compete for fragmented space.
  • Back-to-office attendance has plateaued at 70-80% of pre-pandemic levels and has remained flat for the past 12 months, suggesting the market has reached a new equilibrium rather than continuing recovery toward pre-pandemic norms.
  • CoStar forecasts office cap rates will continue to compress as risk premiums decline and investors gain clarity on what makes buildings investable, unlike industrial and multifamily where cap rates are expected to remain flat or expand.
  • Institutional investors have re-entered the office market and now account for a larger share of purchases than 12 months ago, indicating growing confidence that office risk profiles are sufficiently understood for investment.
  • Occupiers seeking quality office space are already experiencing a tight market despite high headline vacancy because competitive space is concentrated in a finite set of buildings.
  • Job growth forecasts of 0.3-0.5% annually over the next five years suggest demand resurgence for office space is unlikely, meaning any vacancy improvements will come primarily from supply contraction rather than increased occupancy demand.

Topics

Office market recovery and K-shaped bifurcationRent growth paradox with high vacancyLandlord capital and building quality determinantsGeographic market fragmentationLease size contraction and small occupier trendsBack-to-office stabilization and remote workAI employment impact uncertaintyInvestment sales and cap rate compression forecastSupply constraints driving market dynamicsUser versus institutional investor purchase patterns

Transcript

MICHAEL BULL: Welcome to America's Commercial Real Estate Show, your source for market intel, forecast, and strategies. Hello, I'm Michael Bull. Thank you for being with us. Our show today is brought to you by TCN Worldwide. Look, if you need brokerage services anywhere in the world or in the U.S., check them out for acquisitions, dispositions, property management, site selection, or consulting. Visit TCNWorldwide.com. Well, let's get to our show today. I think the office sector is always kind of interesting to me. Especially where we are today with everything that's happened in the office world. But what's happening now? You know, it's been a while since we've had COVID. We've seen some buildings converted to other uses. We've…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from America‘s Commercial Real Estate Show

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.