DiscussionOpinion

We’ll Be Inferior to Our Grandchildren—and That’s Great

Y Combinator

A discussion about scaling societies and the relative ratio of good versus bad behavior, with one participant expressing concern that future generations will be intellectually superior to current humans, similar to how humans are vastly superior to ants.

Summary

The speakers are debating whether a larger, scaled-up version of society would necessarily be worse if it maintains the same relative proportions of crimes and violations versus cooperative behavior. One speaker argues that if the ratios remain consistent, a bigger world would simply be a bigger version of the current one, not necessarily worse. The other speaker expresses concern about this scaling, drawing an analogy to the relationship between humans and ants—suggesting that vastly superior beings would negotiate among themselves while treating current humans as intellectually inferior. This leads to a broader point about generational intellectual progression, acknowledging that future grandchildren will likely be intellectually superior to the current generation, which the speakers frame as a positive outcome despite the current generation being left behind.

Key Insights

  • The speaker argues that maintaining the same relative ratio of crimes and violations versus cooperative behavior when scaling up a world would not necessarily make it worse, just larger
  • The other speaker expresses concern that in a scaled-up world, current humans would be to future advanced beings what ants are to humans—vastly inferior intellectually
  • The speaker acknowledges that future grandchildren will be intellectually superior to the current generation
  • The concern is framed in terms of negotiation dynamics, where advanced future beings would negotiate among themselves while current humans lack comparable intellectual capacity
  • The speakers frame generational inferiority as a positive outcome despite its uncomfortable implications for the current generation

Topics

Scaling societies and social ratiosComparative intellectual capacity across generationsRelative good versus bad behavior in scaled systemsHierarchy and inferiority in advanced civilizationsGenerational progress and advancement

Transcript

[0:00] The point I'm saying is if we scale everything up and we have the same relative ratio of, you know, crimes and violations versus good cooperative behavior, then this looks like a better world because it's just bigger. So, you need to tell me why this world would have more of the bad stuff relative to the good stuff, not just it'll be bigger and have more of everything. >> I just worry that it would look a bit like our we be the ants, they would be the humans negotiating with with each other. We'd be vastly inferior to them intellectually. you know, the fate of their >> and we're going to be inferior to our [0:30] grandchildren.

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Y Combinator

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.