OpinionDiscussion

Larry Sabato, Founder and Director of the University of Virginia's Center for Politics

Walker Webcast34m 20s

Larry Sabato discusses the 2026 midterm elections as unique due to Trump's unpopularity and controversial policies, emphasizing that while prediction markets and polls provide useful trend data, no single indicator should be trusted in isolation. He identifies key Republican strengths (fundraising advantage, base enthusiasm, Trump's mobilization of supporters) and Democratic momentum, while cautioning against overconfident predictions about specific races like Texas and Michigan.

Summary

In this Walker Webcast episode, political analyst Larry Sabato from the University of Virginia's Center for Politics provides analysis of the 2026 midterm elections. He begins by establishing that while every midterm election is unique, the distinguishing feature of 2026 is the unprecedented political environment surrounding President Trump's administration. Sabato emphasizes that trends in polling data are more reliable than specific numbers, and warns against over-relying on any single indicator, including prediction markets.

On prediction markets specifically, Sabato acknowledges their utility but expresses concern about manipulation, citing examples like George Santos betting on his own attendance at the State of the Union address and profiting over $400,000. He notes that prediction markets often reflect underlying polling data rather than providing independent predictive power.

Sabato identifies Trump's low approval ratings (in the low 30s) as historically poor for an incumbent president during midterms, though he notes exceptions like Truman in 1948 who won re-election despite unpopularity. He argues that cost-of-living issues—particularly gas prices and food inflation—are significant headwinds for Republicans, as are concerns about the war in Iran, which he characterizes as a politically damaging move.

Regarding specific races, Sabato refuses to make definitive calls on competitive races like Texas Senate (Paxton vs. Tallarico), describing them as true toss-ups despite prediction markets showing 61-62% confidence for one candidate. He notes that Abbott's 12-year tenure as Texas governor may dampen Republican enthusiasm in that race. On Michigan's Senate race, he expresses concerns about Democrat Abdul El-Sayed's controversial background but notes the race remains competitive.

Sabato identifies three key Republican strengths: overwhelming financial advantages (hundreds of millions more than Democrats), the inherent structure of midterm elections that mobilizes both bases, and Trump's ability to energize Republican voters in deep-red districts and states, even if he cannot salvage competitive races. He predicts Democrats will turn out at higher rates than Republicans.

On governance, Sabato argues that divided government—with Democrats controlling at least one chamber—will result in legislative gridlock, which he suggests may be preferable to unified government. He predicts Trump has approximately a 1% chance of successfully appointing a Supreme Court justice, as any nominee acceptable to Trump's base would face unified Democratic opposition.

Addressing ballot initiatives, Sabato laments the complexity and length of modern ballots, particularly in states like California and Colorado, arguing that long ballots lead to poor democratic decision-making. He attributes this to populist movements that persist because politicians cannot effectively argue against direct democracy.

On data centers, Sabato criticizes their promoters for failing to prepare the public and address legitimate concerns about rural placement and electricity subsidies. He predicts data center opposition has reached grassroots momentum that may prove difficult to overcome even with federal intervention.

Finally, Sabato declines to handicap the 2028 presidential race, stating he wants to focus on one election at a time. He promotes Sabato's Crystal Ball, a free forecasting service from the University of Virginia, and suggests that while Republicans will likely nominate a MAGA-aligned candidate who must contend with Trump's continued influence, Democrats face an open field with 38 potential candidates, of which 10-20 are likely to run.

About this episode

Willy was joined by Dr. Larry Sabato, founder and director of the University of Virginia's Center for Politics and creator of Sabato's Crystal Ball. Together, they examined the upcoming midterm elections, the battle for control of Congress, shifting voter sentiment, and the key races that could determine the balance of power in Washington. They also discussed the reliability of polls and prediction markets, the impact of economic concerns on voters, growing political opposition to data centers, and what the election results could mean for the future of American politics. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Key Insights

  • Sabato argues that prediction markets are concerning when external actors invest large sums to deliberately tilt them, citing George Santos's $400,000 profit from betting on his own State of the Union attendance.
  • Trump's approval ratings in the low 30s represent historically poor performance for an incumbent president during midterms, comparable to Truman's unpopularity in 1946, though Sabato notes Truman won re-election in 1948.
  • Sabato claims that despite prediction markets showing 61-62% confidence in one candidate for the Texas Senate race, it remains a true toss-up, demonstrating that market confidence levels should not be treated as certainties.
  • Sabato predicts that divided government with Democrats controlling at least one chamber will result in complete legislative gridlock, as Republicans will block Democratic initiatives and Trump will veto any compromise legislation.
  • Sabato argues that Republicans have three significant strengths offsetting Democratic momentum: a hundreds-of-millions-dollar financial advantage, the mobilizing effect of midterm elections on both bases, and Trump's ability to energize voters in deep-red districts.
  • Sabato contends that long, complex ballots—particularly in California and Colorado with numerous ballot initiatives—lead to poor democratic decision-making because even engaged citizens cannot adequately research all items.
  • Sabato claims data center promoters failed fundamentally by not preparing the public and addressing logical objections, allowing grassroots opposition to build momentum that may now be irreversible even with state-level support.
  • Sabato predicts Trump has approximately 1% chance of successfully appointing a Supreme Court justice because any nominee acceptable to his base would face unified Democratic opposition with only possible exception of Senator Fetterman.

Topics

2026 midterm election analysisPrediction markets and polling reliabilityTrump approval ratings and political unpopularityCost-of-living impact on electionsRepublican and Democratic strengthsCompetitive Senate races (Texas, Michigan, Alaska)Divided government and legislative gridlockSupreme Court appointment prospectsBallot initiatives and direct democracyData center political opposition

Transcript

Walker & Dunlop brings you insights for life. Unique perspectives. From impactful leaders. This is the Walker Webcast. With Willie Walker. Good afternoon and welcome to another Walker webcast. It is my great joy to have my long-term friend, Larry Sabato, from the University of Virginia, join me to talk about the upcoming midterms. Larry, I am so thankful of your time, given how many people want to hear your insights on what we're going to see a little over a week from today. And so let's start here. How unique are the midterms, 2026 versus past midterm elections? I can truthfully say this, having been watching them, the first midterm I really watched was in 1962. In case you…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Walker Webcast

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.