Decision Day recap & obituaries for the eliminated teams! MLS Update
The hosts recap MLS Decision Day and the 2024 regular season, discussing eliminated playoff teams across both conferences, analyzing their failures and roster decisions. They also award end-of-season honors including MVP (Messi), Coach of the Year (BJ Callan), and share their best XI selections.
Summary
The episode opens with a Decision Day recap where Nashville SC clinched the historic Supporter's Shield with 77 points, their first in club history, while Lionel Messi secured a second consecutive Golden Boot. In the Western Conference playoffs chase, Portland, Seattle, and Real Salt Lake claimed the final three spots, eliminating LA Galaxy, Minnesota United, and Colorado Rapids. The hosts then systematically discuss teams that missed the playoffs, starting with the Eastern Conference.
In the East, the Red Bulls finished 10th with 42 points despite Michael Bradley's inaugural coaching season and young talent emerging from their academy system. The hosts note the team's chronic underinvestment and salary cap constraints limit their ability to compete despite their development track record. NYCFC struggled to a similar record, with Pascal Jansen losing his job after two seasons where the team was one of the youngest in MLS. The new stadium opening presents an opportunity for ownership (City Football Group) to finally invest in the project beyond just youth development.
Toronto FC missed the playoffs again despite significant offseason spending on Josh Sargent and other talent, hampered by injuries to key players and Robin Frazier's inability to establish coherent attacking tactics. Atlanta United continued their downward trend with an unbalanced roster lacking wingers, though Biel Mbolo's arrival offers some hope. Front office changes were made with VP of Sport Dimitros and Chief Scout Jonathan Spector departing.
DC United's situation is described as hopeless, with the team testing MLS's parity system through chronic mismanagement, poor recruitment (buying-low budgeting that doesn't produce results), and weak ownership engagement. They're now tied for most consecutive playoff misses.
CF Montreal faces existential uncertainty after owner Joey Saputo announced he's selling the team, expressing emotional attachment but revealing he won't discount the franchise to keep it in Montreal. He made clear MLS could relocate the team if a buyer wanted to do so, marking the most serious relocation threat since Columbus.
In the Western Conference, Minnesota United came closest to making playoffs but fell short despite Kelvin Yeboah's 18 goals, hampered by Nico Triantis's limited availability and a midseason 1-win-in-18 stretch. The roster lacks sufficient attacking talent to complement strong midfield options.
LA Galaxy, despite talent like Ricky Puig (currently injured from two ACL surgeries), finished outside the playoffs with one of the five worst defenses in MLS based on expected goals allowed. The hosts believe Greg Vanney's 2024 MLS Cup was more Puig's accomplishment than his own, and the team depends entirely on Puig's recovery to compete, creating risky pressure on an injured player.
Colorado Rapids showed some positivity under new coach Matt Wells's ambitious system despite selling key players like Hoffa Navarro and Lucas Harrington, though the season was ultimately disappointing. Wells arrived specifically to have time to build tactical depth, suggesting 2027 is his realistic timeline for success.
San Diego showed inexplicable decline from last season's top-three finish, with the hosts unable to clearly identify why—pointing to recurring red cards, late-game collapses, and possibly teams gaining tape on their unique system. The freezing out of a star player over valuation damaged the locker room.
Austin FC had a horrific season starting 0-9-0, with the hosts crediting poor roster construction by Rodolfo Burrell. New coach Jim Curtin and sporting director Khalid Alamad offer fresh starts, though major roster overhauls are needed.
Sporting KC finished with the worst defense in MLS history (81 goals against), leading to Rafael Vicky's firing. The club is undergoing a deeper rebuild under new majority owner Peter Malouk, who wants to make them "Midwest Miami," complicating plans and extending timelines. The hosts suggest Kansas City wait until after the European season to hire a higher-profile manager.
The episode concludes with rapid-fire awards: Messi (MVP), BJ Callan (Coach of Year), Antoine Griezmann (Newcomer), Kevin Sullivan (Young Player), Jason Palacios (Defender), Matt Turner and Brian Schwaki (competitive Goalkeeper race), and the hosts' differing best XIs.
About this episode
<p>Taylor, Jeff, and Joe combine to break down the latest from around MLS! We dive into Decision Day drama, examine what went wrong for this year’s fallen clubs, and run through our end-of-season awards!</p><br /><p><strong>WE HAVE MERCH!</strong></p><p>A limited number of tees and hats are available at totalsoccershow.com/merch!</p><br /><p><strong>JOIN THE TSS+ PATREON!</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.patreon.com/totalsoccershow" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Check out our Patreon</a>, which houses bonus podcasts, access to our exclusive Discord, videos, The TSS Scouting Network, and much more.</p><br /><p><strong>WATCH TSS EPISODES ON YOUTUBE!</strong></p><p><a href="https://www.youtube.com/@Total-Soccer-Show" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">We're posting all our episodes here</a>! Smash like and subscribe etc.!</p><hr /><p style="color: grey; font-size: 0.75em;"> Hosted on Acast. See <a href="https://acast.com/privacy" rel="noopener noreferrer" style="color: grey;" target="_blank">acast.com/privacy</a> for more information.</p>
Key Insights
- Nashville SC's goalkeeper Brian Schwaki had one of the greatest MLS goalkeeping seasons ever while being largely unknown, suggesting goalkeeper availability can dramatically swing a team's performance
- Red Bull New York continues the pattern of developing young academy players only to sell them once they ask for higher wages, operating as a development farm rather than a competitive squad
- NYCFC's new stadium represents a potential turning point only if ownership (City Football Group) stops treating them as third priority behind Girona and begins actual investment
- Toronto FC's young talent pool couldn't overcome the lack of discernible tactical principles under Robin Frazier, suggesting coaching philosophy matters as much as roster construction
- Atlanta United's 2018 redux strategy with Tata Martino lacks the fresh ideas necessary for evolution, resulting in a mismatched, identity-less squad despite significant spending
- DC United's chronic underinvestment and 'Moneyball with bullpen catchers' approach has now tied them for the most consecutive playoff misses, testing MLS's parity system
- Joey Saputo's refusal to discount Montreal's franchise value to keep the team local while allowing for MLS-directed relocation represents the most serious relocation threat since Columbus
- LA Galaxy finished outside the playoffs largely because Greg Vanney's 2024 MLS Cup victory was primarily Ricky Puig's accomplishment, and the team cannot compete without him
- Colorado Rapids' Matt Wells was hired specifically for multi-year project development, making 2027 a more realistic success timeline than this season
- San Diego's red card accumulation and defensive collapse appears to be a mental block rather than tactical incompetence, suggesting psychological factors broke the team's confidence
- Kansas City's 81-goal-against season represents historically bad defending and required Rafael Vicky's firing despite deeper club reconstruction issues beyond coaching
- The hosts note that in modern MLS, teams can transform with one or two key signings, but consistent improvement requires both tactical coherence and sustained ownership investment
Topics
Transcript
Wouldn't it be great if life's little upgrades didn't feel like a splurge? Like getting the aisle seat with extra legroom for a one-hour flight, ordering extra guac with zero hesitation, or paying for assembly on that swing set because you'd rather spend your Saturday doing literally anything else. It's called living filthy comfortable. And whatever filthy comfortable looks like to you, Schwab can help you find it with investing, trading, education, and human help, all in one place. Learn more at schwab.com. Investing involves risk, including loss of principle. If you're still sleeping on cotton or satin, that could be the reason for frizzy hair, sleep creases, overheating, and even breakouts. Dermatologists actually recommend switching to silk because it's…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Total Soccer Show: USMNT, Champions League, EPL, and more ...
Could Brighton win the Premier League? Why are Lazio supporters angrier than usual? | Listener Questions
The Sobosoccer Show hosts discuss listener questions about Brighton's Premier League ceiling, Lazio fan protests against ownership, South American league strength comparisons, the history of stadium segregation in football, and whether a team of world-class players could succeed without coaches or managers.
Mauricio Pochettino’s bombshell exit! | USMNT Weekly
The hosts discuss Mauricio Pochettino's imminent departure from the USMNT to coach Manchester United, analyzing his tenure, its impact on the team, and potential replacement candidates including Pep Guardiola, BJ Callaghan, and others. They also preview the upcoming Haiti matches and introduce new squad members like Santiago Castaneda.
A wild weekend for both Manchester clubs | Weekend Review
The Total Soccer Show Weekend Review discusses three major matches: Manchester United's dramatic 4-4 draw with Aston Villa from two goals down, Manchester City's concerning 3-1 defeat to Nottingham Forest, and Barcelona's 2-1 comeback win at Atletico Madrid. The hosts debate whether these results signal deeper structural issues at Manchester United and City, while praising Barcelona's composure.
Does Manchester United’s comeback change anything for Carrick? | Champions League Review
The Total Soccer Show reviews Champions League League Phase Match Day 4, featuring Manchester United's dramatic 3-2 comeback against Roma, Barcelona's dominant 3-0 win over Aston Villa, and Como's record-breaking 9-1 demolition of Lans. The hosts discuss tactical breakdowns, player performances, and what these results mean for each team's Champions League prospects.
Pulisic returns, Cavan Sullivan remains! Breaking down Pochettino's latest USMNT roster | USMNT Weekly
The Terminal Soccer Show's USMNT Weekly episode breaks down Mauricio Pochettino's 25-player roster for November's CONCACAF Nations League quarterfinal against Haiti, analyzing returning veterans like Pulisic and Balogun, notable absences like Tim Weah and Matt Turner, and surprising call-ups like Reed Baker-Whiting and Santiago Castaneda.