Why the Bond Market Remains Calm After the Blue Wave
Andrew Sheets argues that despite initial market concerns, fixed income markets have become more comfortable with Democratic midterm election gains due to reduced uncertainty, potential inflation relief, and historical precedent showing positive market returns following midterm elections regardless of party outcome.
Summary
Andrew Sheets, Global Head of Fixed Income Research at Morgan Stanley, discusses the implications of the U.S. midterm elections for fixed income markets. He opens with a cautionary note about political predictions in finance, then outlines the election results: Democrats achieved unexpectedly strong gains in both House and Senate races, won several key statewide races like the Texas governor's race, and secured the largest vote share for any party in nearly 50 years.
Sheets notes that the blue wave was initially perceived as market-negative, and markets did react negatively in the immediate hours following the election. However, he identifies several reasons why fixed income markets have become more comfortable with the outcome upon reflection. First, the resolution of election uncertainty itself is positive for markets, as uncertainty had previously driven reduced investor exposure. With results now known, investors have room to re-enter positions.
Second, inflation has been a significant headwind for fixed income markets in 2024. The market may interpret the election results as reflecting voter unpopularity of tariffs and certain foreign policies, potentially signaling future policy changes that could reduce inflation. Additionally, Morgan Stanley economists expect the next inflation report to show a notable decline.
Third, AI-related bond issuance has pressured yields and spreads. While the elections may not fundamentally change AI spending trends, potential regulatory changes and more gradual buildout timelines resulting from the new political landscape could ease supply pressure concerns.
Finally, Sheets presents a historical perspective: following all 11 midterm elections from 1982 to 2022, the S&P 500 was higher one year later regardless of which party won. While acknowledging this may be coincidental and not sophisticated analysis, he uses it to illustrate that elections, though important to countries, don't necessarily translate to significant market impacts.
About this episode
<p>For investors, the U.S. election was only one part of a much bigger equation. Our Global Head of Fixed Income Andrew Sheets discusses the balance of risks after the midterm results.</p><p>Read more <a href="https://www.morganstanley.com/insights?cid=mg-SM_CORP-insights-17607" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">insights</a> from Morgan Stanley.</p><p><br /></p><p>----- Transcript ----- </p><p><br /></p><p><strong>Andrew Sheets:</strong> Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Andrew Sheets, Global Head of Fixed Income Research at Morgan Stanley.</p><p>Today, what a blue wave means for fixed income.</p><p>It's Friday, November 6th at 2pm in London.</p><p>If the last decade has taught us anything, it's that financial professionals should approach political predictions and their market impact with a great deal of caution.</p><p>With that caveat in mind, let's talk about Tuesday's U.S. midterms and what they might mean for fixed income.</p><p>The word surprise has lost some meaning in investing over the years, but the U.S. election results qualify. Democrats won far more seats in both the House and the Senate than almost anyone expected. Key statewide races, such as Texas governor, also flipped unexpectedly. Democrats enjoyed the largest vote share of any party in almost 50 years.</p><p>Speaking to investors over the last month, this so-called blue wave, I think, was generally seen as the more market negative outcome. And indeed, in the first hours after U.S. polls closed, that was the market reaction.</p><p>But with the results behind us and in the cold light of day, I think there are a number of reasons why fixed income markets over time have grown more comfortable with the result.</p><p>First, markets hate uncertainty, and a variety of measures suggest that investors had reduced exposure into Tuesday, whether as a direct function of the vote or due to broader volatility from everything from technology to Brazil. Uncertainty is now lower. After all, we know the result, and investors should have some room to add if they want to.</p><p>Second, one factor that has been weighing on fixed income markets this year has been inflation. It's been too high, with both tariffs and energy prices contributing to upward pressure. To the extent that the market sees these results reflecting the unpopularity of tariffs or certain foreign policy, investors could assume that these policies are more likely to change down the road. And that could help to push down long-term bond yields. And much more immediately, unrelated to the election, I note that our economists expect that the next U.S. inflation number this month is going to show a notable step down.</p><p>Another factor that's weighed on fixed income this year has been AI spending, which has generated record amounts of bond issuance, pushing up both spreads and yields. Our analysts don't think that the midterms change the big picture on AI. But to the extent that some changes in statewide power result in more regulation and a more elongated build-out – well, that could help ease some of the concerns around supply pressure and potential mismatches between supply and demand.</p><p>But maybe the reason not to fret too much about the midterms is even more simple. Following the last 11 midterm elections from 1982 to 2022, the S&P 500 was higher one year later after all of them, regardless of the party that won.</p><p>Now, it's possible that going 11 for 11 is just a coincidence; and this is hardly a sophisticated analysis. But I think it speaks to the fact that while elections matter a great deal to the country in question, they don't always mean as much to markets.</p><p>Thank you, as always, for your time. If you find Thoughts on the Market useful, let us know by leaving a review wherever you listen. And also tell a friend or colleague about us today</p>
Key Insights
- Sheets argues that the immediate market pessimism about the blue wave results shifted as investors realized that resolved election uncertainty itself is beneficial for markets, providing room for repositioning after the reduction in pre-election hedging.
- The speaker claims that market interpretation of election results as a rejection of tariff and foreign policies could reduce expectations for inflation-driving measures, supported by anticipated declines in upcoming inflation data.
- Sheets presents empirical evidence that the S&P 500 rose following all 11 midterm elections between 1982 and 2022 regardless of party victory, suggesting elections carry less market significance than commonly perceived despite their importance to countries.
Topics
Transcript
Welcome to Thoughts on the Market. I'm Andrew Sheets, Global Head of Fixed Income Research at Morgan Stanley. Today, what a blue wave means for fixed income. It's Friday, November 6th at 2pm in London. If the last decade has taught us anything, it's that financial professionals should approach political predictions and their market impact with a great deal of caution. With that caveat in mind, let's talk about Tuesday's U.S. midterms and what they might mean for fixed income. The word surprise has lost some meaning in investing over the years, but U.S. election results qualify. Democrats won far more seats in both the House and the Senate than almost anyone expected. Key statewide races, such as Texas governor,…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Thoughts on the Market
China's Bet on Physical AI
Morgan Stanley strategists discuss China's shift from cloud-based AI to physical AI deployment in manufacturing, robotics, and industrial automation. They forecast a $12 trillion incremental Industry 5.0 investment over 10 years, with significant productivity gains and corporate earnings improvements expected from 2028 onwards, contingent on investment discipline, housing stabilization, and social welfare reforms.
Europe's AI Moment
Morgan Stanley's European TMT conference discusses four critical themes shaping Europe's tech landscape: data center rollout constraints (power, planning, politics, financing, and construction costs), the need for sovereign AI capabilities in Europe, the rise of agentic AI as a transformative computing paradigm, and power efficiency as an emerging priority across the industry.
2027 Equities Outlook: Why the Correction Isn't the End of the Bull Market
Mike Wilson, Morgan Stanley's CIO, presents a 2027 equity outlook raising the S&P 500 target to 8,700, characterizing the current correction as a mid-cycle transition that resets valuations rather than breaks the bull market. He recommends rotating from defensive quality to quality cyclicals, with industrials as the top sector pick, while maintaining AI as a central theme focused on adoption rather than infrastructure.
2027 Global Outlook: The Case for a Stronger Dollar, Longer AI Cycle
Morgan Stanley's 2027 outlook recommends embracing risk through maximum overweights in global equities while remaining neutral on investment-grade corporate credit, citing an intact AI capex cycle, constructive growth prospects, and attractive valuations despite geopolitical uncertainties. The firm maintains a conviction view on a stronger dollar driven by relative U.S. growth outperformance and is constructive on duration in UK gilts based on belief that rate hikes are overpriced.
2027 Global Outlook: Powered by AI, Tested by Oil
Morgan Stanley's 2027 Global Outlook forecasts resilient global growth of 3.3% next year, powered by ongoing AI CapEx investment but tested by oil price shocks and elevated inflation. The base case expects the Fed to deliver two more rate hikes (December and March) before pausing, contingent on inflation peaking in Q1 and declining thereafter.