#357 Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered”
Payne Lindsey, creator of the viral true crime podcast Up and Vanished, discusses his decade-long investigation into the Tara Grinstead disappearance, his encounters with dangerous suspects across multiple cases, and his spiritual awakening experience in Sedona that redirected him toward Christianity and away from political cynicism.
Summary
Payne Lindsey founded Up and Vanished in 2016 with no investigative background, using a $100 microphone and pure storytelling instinct. The podcast reopened the 11-year-old Tara Grinstead case in rural Georgia, generating 800 million downloads and leading to arrests within six months. However, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation's subsequent prosecution of Ryan Duke appeared flawed—Duke confessed while heavily medicated on morphine, and the evidence was circumstantial. Meanwhile, Bo Dukes, who actually admitted to burning Tara's body and later committed rape with a shotgun, received a lighter sentence. The GBI's pride prevented them from admitting their investigative error, and Ryan Duke was eventually acquitted.
Lindsey expanded his investigations to Crystal Reisinger's disappearance in Colorado (where suspect Catfish John threatened and attacked him), Ashley Loring Heavy Runner's case on the Blackfeet Reservation in Montana (revealing systemic failures in jurisdictional responsibility for murdered and missing Indigenous women), and Florence Akpiluk's disappearance in Nome, Alaska. For the Alaska case, Lindsey catfished a primary suspect using a fake Facebook account, posing as an interested seaman to gain trust, eventually meeting him in person and administering a polygraph test where the suspect failed and admitted to withholding information from police.
Lindsey discussed his fascination with UFOs and paranormal phenomena, distinguishing between traditional aliens and spiritual entities. He referenced Travis Walton's 1975 abduction, seraphim angels (described in biblical texts as disc-shaped beings with multiple eyes, visually similar to modern UFO descriptions), and credible military pilots' accounts of anomalous craft. He emphasized that the credibility of multiple witnesses across different backgrounds and time periods makes dismissing these phenomena entirely less rational than acknowledging something unexplained occurs.
Most significantly, Lindsey recounted a transformative spiritual experience in Sedona, Arizona. While searching for answers through crystal energy and psychedelics, he encountered a stranger who read his mind regarding internal struggles about gender ideology in children and concerns about China. Hours later, the friend he was traveling with told him 'God's always trying to talk to you, you just don't make room for him.' That same evening, a friend named Dan Cerillo's daughter—whom Lindsey had never met—texted him from her deceased father's phone, saying Dan called Lindsey his best friend and wanted her to reach out. Additionally, Lindsey kept seeing a doppelgänger of his deceased friend Gabe throughout the week. These convergent events convinced him of divine intervention, leading him to attend daily mass and embrace Christianity, abandoning his previous pursuit of spiritual answers through alternative means.
About this episode
Payne Lindsey is a filmmaker, podcast host, and co-founder of Tenderfoot TV, best known for co-creating and hosting the true-crime podcast Up and Vanished. His investigation into the disappearance of Georgia teacher Tara Grinstead brought renewed attention to the long-unsolved case and launched his career in investigative podcasting. He also hosts Atlanta Monster and Radio Rental, and his work has expanded into television through Oxygen’s Up and Vanished series. Shawn Ryan Show Sponsors: Privacy Isn't Paranoia. It's Protection. Download Glacier - https://theglacierapp.com Try ZipRecruiter for FREE today at https://ziprecruiter.com/SRS to find the right people for your roles, seasonal or otherwise. Become a Defender today and donate to partner with the Tim Tebow Foundation to help rescue children. https://timtebowfoundation.org Protect your family with life insurance from Ethos. Get up to $3 million in coverage in as little as 10 minutes at https://ethos.com/SRS. Application times may vary. Rates may vary. Trustpilot rating as of 8/1/2026. Take advantage of HexClad’s Best Sale of the Year and GET UP TO 52% Off by going to https://hexclad.com/SRS #hexcladpartner Try Gusto today at https://gusto.com/SRS and get three months free when you run your first payroll. Start your free trial at https://shopify.com/srs Payne Lindsey Links: Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/paynelindsey X - https://x.com/paynelindsey Tenderfoot TV - https://tenderfoot.tv Instagram - https://www.instagram.com/tenderfoot.tv Youtube - https://www.youtube.com/@tenderfoottv Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
Key Insights
- Payne Lindsey started Up and Vanished with zero investigative training, only a $100 microphone and storytelling experience, yet the podcast generated 800 million downloads and reopened a cold case leading to arrests within six months.
- The Georgia Bureau of Investigation followed Lindsey's investigative leads in real-time, appearing to react to his podcast discoveries rather than conducting independent investigation, suggesting damage control rather than genuine investigation.
- Despite Bo Dukes admitting to burning Tara Grinstead's body for days and later committing rape with a shotgun, he received a lighter sentence than Ryan Duke, who was eventually acquitted—illustrating how law enforcement's initial suspect choice can override evidence.
- The GBI's pride in their initial arrest of Ryan Duke prevented them from admitting investigative error, even when jury acquittal demonstrated the weakness of their case.
- On the Blackfeet Reservation, the three-way jurisdictional handoff between FBI, tribal police, and local law enforcement creates accountability gaps where everyone assumes someone else has responsibility for missing Indigenous women cases.
- Native women are murdered at 10 times the national rate, with 95% of cases receiving no national coverage, and about half of identified perpetrators are non-native—indicating vulnerability exploitation across tribal boundaries.
- Payne Lindsey used a fake Facebook account to catfish a murder suspect for months, eventually meeting him in person while posing as a interested seaman, blurring journalistic ethics to gather information.
- A suspect in the Nome, Alaska case failed a polygraph test twice and admitted to withholding truth from law enforcement, yet remained unprosecuted due to lack of physical evidence and jurisdictional complications.
- Lindsey encounters with dangerous suspects (Catfish John threatening strangulation, another suspect attempting to hit him with a motorcycle helmet, a third pulling a gun) demonstrated the physical dangers of unprotected investigative work.
- The Marblehead, Massachusetts house Lindsey lived in had a faucet that turned on spontaneously with no mechanical explanation, and multiple residents reported paranormal activity, later confirmed by Airbnb reviews mentioning supernatural phenomena.
- Seraphim angels are described in biblical texts as disc-shaped beings with multiple eyes covering their entire body—visually indistinguishable from modern UFO descriptions, suggesting possible spiritual rather than extraterrestrial explanations for sightings.
- Multiple credible witnesses across different backgrounds and time periods (military pilots, decorated officers, civilians) describe consistent UFO phenomena including craft disappearing instantaneously rather than moving at high speed, suggesting dimensional rather than technological explanation.
- Sean Ryan experienced a gate guard in Sedona who articulated his unexpressed internal thoughts about gender ideology and China without prior conversation, occurring moments before receiving a text from a deceased friend's daughter he'd never met.
- Payne Lindsey's spiritual awakening occurred not through seeking Christianity but through exhausting alternative spiritual pursuits (crystals, energy vortexes, psychedelics), after which divine signs appeared in rapid succession.
- Both investigators emphasize that their paranormal and spiritual experiences arrived during moments of genuine searching and vulnerability, not through skepticism or casual inquiry, suggesting receptivity precedes revelation.
Topics
Transcript
October is when routines start getting tested. Schedule changes, mornings get darker, travel picks up, training can start slipping, and it gets easy to feel like your body is just trying to keep up instead of staying ahead of it. That's why I use AG1 Pro. AG1 Pro is built on the same foundation as AG1 Next Gen, but it does more. One pack, cold water, every morning before anything else. That's important to me because I don't want a countertop full of different products. I want something simple that I can stay consistent with. AG1 Pro brings together 80 plus vitamins and minerals, gut health support, whole food sourced ingredients, and creatine all in one daily drink. It's formulated…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Shawn Ryan Show
#358 Ed Barnhart - Inside America’s Forgotten Pyramid Civilization
Dr. Ed Barnhart discusses the Mississippian civilization, a sophisticated pre-Columbian culture of millions of people who built pyramid cities across eastern North America from 900 CE until European contact. The civilization was eventually decimated by disease introduced by Spanish explorers like DeSoto, with 90% of the population dying within the first century of contact.
#356 Joe Kent - Susie Wiles, Stephen Miller, Midterms and the AIPAC Problem
Joe Kent, a former Trump administration national security official who resigned over the Iran war, discusses the midterm election results as a historic rejection of the administration's foreign policy betrayals, particularly the Iran conflict orchestrated by AIPAC influence. He argues that voter anger stemmed from broken promises on avoiding new Middle East wars, economic hardship from disrupted oil supplies, and the administration's prioritization of donor interests over constituent concerns.
#355 Captain Royce Williams - 100-Year-Old WWII Veteran & Medal of Honor Recipient
Captain Royce Williams, a 100-year-old WWII and Korean War veteran, recounts his legendary 35-minute dogfight against Soviet MiG-15s on November 18, 1952—the longest aerial combat in U.S. military history—where he engaged six enemy aircraft solo and was awarded the Medal of Honor in 2026 after decades of classification. The interview spans his entire military career from the Great Depression through Vietnam, his influence on naval aviation policy, and his personal faith journey.
#354 Reckless Ben - The Internet's Most Controversial Investigative YouTuber
Reckless Ben, an investigative YouTuber, discusses his infiltrations of various organizations including Scientology, the 12 Tribes cult, Provo Canyon School, and most recently Ideal Living and Bricks and Minifigs. He describes his methods for exposing abuse, human trafficking allegations, and corporate fraud while navigating legal threats and lawsuits.
#353 Dr. Thomas Madden - Rome Historian Reveals the 7 Warning Signs of a Dying Republic
Dr. Thomas Madden discusses the historical patterns that led to the fall of the Roman Republic and compares them to potential warning signs in modern America. He explains how Rome's loss of existential enemies after defeating Carthage in 146 BC led to hyper-partisanship, wealth inequality, and eventual political violence that ultimately destroyed the republic, while arguing that America's constitutional safeguards—designed by founders who studied these historical lessons—have so far held up despite similar strains.