DiscussionOpinion

The Land Investing Fundamentals That Still Work w/ Joe McCall

Joe McCall discusses land investing fundamentals, the evolution of his business from active wholesaling to education and coaching, and how to navigate criticism while maintaining integrity. He emphasizes that success in real estate comes from consistent execution of basic principles—particularly direct mail marketing, talking to sellers, sending offers to everyone, and persistent follow-up—rather than complex tactics or chasing trendy strategies.

Summary

In this podcast conversation between Seth Williams and Joe McCall, they explore the land investing business as it exists today, discussing how the industry has changed and how McCall's own business has evolved. McCall shares that approximately 90% of his current revenue comes from software, services, coaching, and education rather than from deals, though he still invests in select properties and his students' deals.

The conversation begins with a discussion about dealing with internet criticism and haters. McCall notes that when you put yourself out there—whether doing deals or teaching—you put a target on your back. He uses the metaphor that if you haven't made somebody angry by noon, you're probably not doing enough offers or marketing. However, he emphasizes the importance of discerning between legitimate criticism that deserves attention and dismissive hate. McCall explains he vets criticism by running it past his wife and staying open to feedback, particularly from people who know him well or make substantive points, while not letting unfounded criticism derail his efforts.

McCall defines what separates "good gurus" from "bad gurus." He shares a cautionary tale about his first coaching program in 2007-2008, where he was charged exactly the amount he had available on his credit cards ($13,000) for a program that contained elementary information available in free books. Though the program had basic value through accountability groups, he didn't implement the advice and blamed the program rather than taking responsibility. In contrast, McCall describes his approach to education through his "Dirt Flippers" program and business completion challenge, where he refunds students' money if they complete the program (watching videos, attending calls, making 100 offers in six months) without doing a deal. He frames this as an investment in creating raving fans and getting access to their deals.

Regarding the current state of land investing, McCall reports seeing higher response rates on direct mail and less competition than a year ago, contradicting some perceptions of market saturation. He attributes this partly to many investors abandoning the space. He maintains strong conviction in the fundamentals: sending consistent direct mail with neutral postcards (ugly, no logos, no fancy graphics), driving people to a 24-hour recorded voicemail system, calling back all respondents, sending offers to everyone who expresses interest, and following up every 30 days without exception.

McCall and Williams discuss the evolution of tactics in land investing. Williams points out that strategies like blind offers and certain market evaluation methods that worked five years ago don't work as effectively now due to increased competition. McCall acknowledges the competitive landscape has intensified but argues that fundamentals remain constant: the business is about marketing and making offers, not about location. He emphasizes that 80-90% of success is mindset while only 10-20% is tactics, though Williams counters that tactics matter considerably, especially when they become outdated.

McCall shares a story about a student named Grant who does 3-4 deals per month using extremely simple, consistent methods: sending neutral letters to filtered lists in high-activity counties, calling back all voicemails, sending offers to everyone, and following up every 30 days with multiple channels (text, email, ringless voicemail). Grant achieves approximately one deal per 600 letters sent and one accepted offer per 13 sent. McCall uses this as proof that consistency with basics beats perfection.

The two discuss what makes someone unsuitable for land investing: those who chase shiny objects and constantly switch strategies, those unwilling to commit for at least 3-6 months before expecting results, and professional students who buy multiple courses and try to frankensteinkenstein different approaches together. McCall advocates for picking one proven strategy from a trusted source and executing it for six months without deviation.

On the tension between marketing land investing compellingly and presenting realistic difficulty, McCall defends his extensive advertising presence while maintaining he provides substantial free content (YouTube videos, free book with shipping costs, weekly free five-day challenges). He separates the educational portion of challenges from sales pitches, allowing attendees to opt into sales conversations separately. He also addresses the valid criticism that many people who purchase courses never implement them, arguing his role is to provide resources and build belief, but acknowledging he can't control whether people take action.

McCall positions himself as having evolved from operator to educator-investor hybrid. He draws an analogy to NFL coaches like Bill Belichick and Andy Reid who are better coaches than players, arguing some people are better educators than operators. He still does deals—about one every 2-3 months from his own marketing, plus partnerships and investments in student deals and owner-financed properties—but is transparent that his primary focus and revenue now comes from the education and software side.

About this episode

288: In this episode, I sit down with Joe McCall to talk about why some of the simplest real estate strategies are still the hardest to execute consistently. (Show Notes: REtipster.com/288) Joe has been investing in real estate, teaching, coaching, and marketing for years. We cover his experience with internet critics, the good and bad sides of the “guru” business, and an expensive coaching program that taught him an unexpected lesson about taking responsibility and doing the work. Then we di...

Key Insights

  • McCall argues that making people angry through high-volume marketing activity (offers and outreach) can actually signal you're doing something right, since most competitors aren't making enough contact attempts.
  • McCall claims that 90% of his revenue now comes from education, software, services, and coaching rather than from land deals themselves, marking a significant shift from his earlier wholesale-focused model.
  • McCall contends that bad gurus are characterized by high-pressure sales tactics, pricing programs based on what a customer can afford rather than inherent value, and providing support only during the program period with no ongoing assistance.
  • McCall asserts that direct mail response rates for land are 3-5% compared to 0.5-1% for houses, and that he recently achieved 13% response rates in certain Michigan markets through careful list filtering and targeting.
  • McCall claims that of 58 deals his company did in one year, only 4 came from first contact and 54 came from follow-up, with an average of 7-8 touches over 2-3 months, demonstrating the critical importance of persistence.
  • McCall argues that direct mail in writing creates better recall and seller engagement than email or text because 80% of direct mail gets opened while only 20% of emails do, and physical mail stands out in an increasingly digital world.
  • McCall states that neutral, ugly postcards driving people to a voicemail system actually generate more calls than answering phones directly because people are curious about the voicemail and know they won't reach a person.
  • McCall contends that blind offers are more expensive per deal ($3,000-$5,000 in marketing costs) but create higher-quality leads requiring less follow-up, whereas neutral letters cost $500-$1,500 per deal but require more seller engagement work.
  • McCall claims he only sends offers on certain disqualifying properties (like extremely thin cigarette lots) but will send even low offers ($100-$500) on marginal properties because he doesn't know what future buyers might want them for.
  • McCall argues that 80% of real estate investing success is mindset (belief that you can do it) while only 10-20% is tactics, positioning seller psychology and personal confidence as more important than specific techniques.
  • McCall asserts that he refuses to coach anyone who complains about previous gurus and blames them for failures, claiming such blame-shifting indicates the person will likely struggle with his coaching too and will blame him for their lack of results.
  • McCall suggests that good educators might not currently be active operators (comparing himself to NFL coaches who don't play), but claims this is only valid if the educator remains transparent about their current level of active deal activity.

Topics

Land investing fundamentals and strategyDirect mail marketing effectivenessThe role of mindset vs. tactics in real estate successHow to respond to criticism and online hatersGood vs. bad gurus and coaching program characteristicsEvolution of Joe McCall's business from wholesaling to educationHow competitive the land market is today vs. five years agoThe importance of follow-up and consistency in dealsBlind offers vs. neutral letter marketing approachesWhat disqualifies someone from succeeding in land investingBalancing marketing claims with realistic expectationsMasterminds and peer learning in real estate

Transcript

SPEAKER_00: Hey everybody, how's it going? This is Seth Williams. You're listening to the RE Tipster Podcast. Today I'm talking with Joe McCall. So Joe has been around the real estate investing and education world for a long time. Over the years, his focus has evolved quite a bit. Today he operates in a few different worlds at once. He's a land investor, an educator, and a very experienced internet marketer. That combination gives him an interesting perspective because he's not just thinking about how to do deals, he's also thinking about how to taste the business, communicate it clearly, and how to help people understand whether it's a good fit for them. So today I want to talk with…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The REtipster Podcast | Land Investing & Real Estate Strategies

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.