652. London’s Golden Age: The Ghosts of Culloden (Part 3)
This episode covers Samuel Johnson and James Boswell's historic 1773 journey to the Scottish Hebrides, exploring their experiences from Edinburgh to the Western Isles. The hosts analyze how Johnson and Boswell documented their encounters with Highland culture, which they found was already in decline following the Battle of Culloden and Scotland's union with England.
Summary
The episode begins with Johnson's arrival in Edinburgh on August 14, 1773, where he's received as a celebrity despite his anti-Scottish reputation. The hosts detail how both Johnson and Boswell harbor romantic Jacobite sympathies and are drawn to follow the route taken by Bonnie Prince Charlie after his defeat at Culloden. Their journey takes them through St. Andrews, Aberdeen, and along Loch Ness, where they encounter both the wildness Johnson sought and evidence of Highland depopulation. The episode explores their disappointing stay with Sir Alexander MacDonald on Skye, who represents the decline of traditional clan culture, contrasting with their wonderful reception at Raasay and their moving encounter with Flora MacDonald, who had helped Bonnie Prince Charlie escape. Johnson finds the Highlands fascinating but laments that commercialization and British repression following Culloden have destroyed the traditional clan system. The journey concludes with visits to the holy island of Iona and a disastrous political argument between Johnson and Boswell's father Lord Auchinleck over Charles I. Throughout, Boswell acts as a kind of documentary filmmaker, gathering material for his future biography of Johnson.
Key Insights
- Johnson arrived in Edinburgh as a literary celebrity known as 'the Great Cham' but came armed with pistols due to misconceptions about Highland violence
- Both Johnson and Boswell harbored romantic Jacobite sympathies despite Johnson receiving a pension from the Hanoverian government
- The travelers deliberately chose a route following Bonnie Prince Charlie's path rather than taking the direct western route to the Hebrides
- Johnson observed that Highland clan culture was being destroyed not primarily by military defeat but by 'the corrosion of less visible evils' of commercialization
- The Act of Union of 1707 had enriched Scotland's lowlands while contributing to the decline of traditional Highland society
- Johnson found that clan chiefs had 'degenerated from patriarchal rulers to rapacious landlords' and many had migrated south for education and opportunities
- The hosts argue that Highland emigration to America paralleled the later displacement of Plains Indians through similar processes of modernization and repression
- Johnson's visit to Iona produced one of his most famous lines about how religious feeling grows 'warmer among the ruins of Iona'
- Boswell consistently acted as a 'documentary director' throughout the journey, framing Johnson in dramatic Highland settings for future literary use
- The journey provided both men with material for their respective books, with Boswell already planning his future biography of Johnson
- Johnson concluded that they had arrived 'too late to see what we expected' in terms of authentic Highland culture
- The episode reveals how 18th-century English travelers viewed the Scottish Highlands as equivalent to exotic foreign destinations like Borneo or Sumatra
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access