The Manipulation Expert: How to Spot Hidden Manipulators & Take Your Power Back
Dr. Leanne Tenbrink discusses the four dark personality traits—psychopathy, narcissism, Machiavellianism, and sadism—explaining how to identify them in everyday life and how to strategically manage relationships with people who display these traits. She emphasizes that these personalities exist on a continuum, are consistent patterns of behavior, and are unlikely to change without sustained commitment to treatment.
Summary
Mel Robbins hosts Dr. Leanne Tenbrink, a forensic psychology professor who has spent two decades studying manipulators, chronic liars, and dark personalities. The episode addresses the overuse of labels like 'toxic' and 'narcissist' by defining dark personality traits as a specific constellation of callousness (not caring about impact on others), manipulativeness (using others for personal ends), and hostility.
Dr. Tenbrink introduces the 'dark tetrad'—four overlapping personality types: psychopathy, narcissism, Machiavellianism, and sadism. Psychopathy is characterized by superficial charm masking callousness, manipulativeness, impulsivity, and antisocial behavior. People with psychopathic traits often present a 'mask of sanity' and may display incongruent emotions (smiling while saying hostile things). Early warning signs include inappropriate emotional expressions, superficial charm without substance, boundary-pushing, and domineering conversation styles.
Machiavellianism is defined as a desire for status and control through amoral means—willing to manipulate, lie, or spread rumors to climb social hierarchies. These individuals are strategic planners who may be different people in different contexts and often appear power-hungry to observers. Narcissism manifests in two forms: grandiose narcissism (an inflatable ego that cannot be deflated) and vulnerable narcissism (a fragile ego seeking admiration). Grandiose narcissists react with anger to failure, while vulnerable narcissists react strongly to rejection. Both exploit others with a sense of entitlement. Sadism involves finding pleasure in others' pain, ranging from extreme cases to everyday versions like enjoying violent sports, violent media, or schadenfreude (taking joy in others' misfortune).
Dr. Tenbrink explains that these traits exist on continuums rather than as binary labels. A personality is a consistent pattern of thinking, feeling, and behaving that persists across contexts and time. Research shows that untrained people can identify psychopathic traits from just 5-10 seconds of behavior, particularly by noticing hostile statements paired with broad smiling, interrupting without allowing interruption, and ignoring boundaries.
Regarding gaslighting, she clarifies it is not mere disagreement but psychological abuse designed to make someone doubt their own mind and reality. People with dark personality traits endorse gaslighting behaviors in relationships. Dark personalities are overrepresented in leadership positions partly because they actively seek power and partly because their confidence is often confused with competence.
On change, Dr. Tenbrink notes that personalities remain relatively stable over time, and people with dark traits typically lack motivation to change since they see their behavior as justified. Some research on incarcerated men shows that sustained therapy can reduce harmful behaviors (harm reduction), but this does not represent a fundamental personality change. She emphasizes that one's hope or desire for another person to change has no bearing on their actual capacity or willingness to do so.
Dr. Tenbrink recommends three actions: slow down to recognize patterns before committing to relationships, avoid making single-behavior judgments, and maintain a supportive social network to help identify problematic personalities and provide support. She concludes by noting that approximately 1% of the population meets clinical criteria for psychopathy and roughly 10% score high on self-report measures of dark traits, meaning 90% of people are honest, kind, and helpful.
About this episode
In today’s episode, you’ll learn the hidden signs of a manipulative, toxic person from the #1 researcher in the world on dark personalities, Dr. Leanne ten Brinke, PhD. She is here to teach you how to spot the poisonous people that are hidden in plain sight around you – in your family, your community, and at work. And, she’s giving you the science-backed guide to understand poisonous people: how they operate, how to spot the patterns early, and what to do when you realize you’re dealing with one. Dr. ten Brinke is a professor at the University of British Columbia, where she directs the Truth and Trust Lab and has spent nearly two decades studying trust, deception, manipulation, and dark personality traits. She wants to make one thing perfectly clear: most people are good. But one poisonous person can create an enormous amount of stress, confusion, and pain. This episode will help you recognize the pattern, trust what you’re seeing, neutralize their behavior, and know exactly what to do when you’re around them. In this episode, you’ll learn: -How to spot dark personality traits of narcissism, psychopathy, Machiavellianism, and sadism in daily life -The #1 sign you’re being manipulated -What gaslighting is, what it is not, and what to do when you’re being gaslit -Why many toxic people seem charming at first -How gossip can reveal a manipulative personality at work -The simple ways to become more strategic instead of more emotional when dealing with difficult people After listening, you will know exactly what to do to spot toxic behavior, handle manipulative people, and take back your peace and power. For more resources related to today’s episode, click here for the podcast episode page. If you liked the episode, check out this one next: 4 Signs of Emotionally Immature Parents & How to Heal Connect with Mel: Order Mel’s new product, Pure Genius Protein Get Mel’s newsletter, packed with tools, coaching, and inspiration. Get Mel’s #1 bestselling book, The Let Them Theory Watch the episodes on YouTube Follow Mel on Instagram The Mel Robbins Podcast Instagram Mel's TikTok Subscribe to SiriusXM Podcasts+ to listen to new episodes ad-free Disclaimer
Key Insights
- Dark personalities are defined by the overlap of callousness (not caring about impact), manipulativeness (using others for personal ends), and hostility—these traits exist on a continuum rather than as fixed categories.
- Psychopathy involves a 'mask of sanity' where superficial charm masks underlying hostility, and people with psychopathic traits often display incongruent emotions like smiling while saying cruel things.
- Psychopathy consists of four interconnected traits: callousness, manipulativeness, impulsivity, and antisocial behavior, rather than a single characteristic.
- Machiavellianism is characterized by strategic, long-term planning to gain power and status, distinguishing it from the more impulsive nature of psychopathy.
- Narcissism has two distinct manifestations—grandiose narcissism (anger at failure) and vulnerable narcissism (strong reaction to rejection)—but both involve entitlement and exploitation.
- Research demonstrates that untrained people can identify psychopathic traits from as little as 5-10 seconds of observation by noting hostile statements paired with genuine smiling and boundary violations.
- Gaslighting is not disagreement but a specific form of psychological abuse aimed at making someone doubt their own reality and memory, creating dependence on the abuser's interpretation of events.
- People with dark personality traits actively seek leadership positions partly because they believe they are 'born leaders,' and partly because their unwarranted confidence is often mistaken for competence by observers.
- Personality is defined as a consistent way of thinking, feeling, and behaving across time and contexts, meaning one person's hope or desire for another to change does not influence whether that change will occur.
- Research on incarcerated individuals shows that sustained therapy can reduce some harmful behaviors in people with dark traits, but this represents 'harm reduction' rather than fundamental personality change.
- Approximately 90% of the general population score low on dark personality traits, meaning they are honest and kind, but disproportionate exposure to the 10% can create a distorted perception that most people are manipulative.
- Time and multiple observations across different contexts are necessary to distinguish between someone having a temporary bad day and someone displaying consistent dark personality traits.
Topics
Transcript
Hey, it's your friend Mel, and welcome to the Mel Robbins Podcast. Have you noticed that nowadays people just throw words around like, oh, this person's toxic, that person's a narcissist, this person's a psychopath, as if it's nothing. But these words do mean something very specific. And our expert today is going to take you and me into the world of dark personalities. Because what she calls poisonous people aren't just the subjects of true crime investigation or sitting in jails. They're in boardrooms. They're in public office. You might encounter them in your living room or at work. Dr. Leanne Tenbrink is here in our Boston studios. She runs the Truth and Trust Lab at the University of…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Mel Robbins Podcast
How to Increase Your Emotional Intelligence & Never Get Angry or Bothered by Anyone
Dr. Mark Brackett, founding director of Yale Center for Emotional Intelligence, explains that emotional intelligence is a learnable skill set (RULER: Recognize, Understand, Label, Express, Regulate) that enables people to use emotions wisely rather than be controlled by them. He shares research showing that emotions drive attention, judgment, relationships, health, and performance, and demonstrates practical strategies for managing emotions effectively.
Find Your Purpose & Live a Meaningful Life Today with the #1 Happiness Expert
Dr. Dacher Keltner, a leading happiness researcher, discusses how to find purpose and live meaningfully even during challenging times. He presents eight sources of awe and demonstrates a simple one-minute daily practice that reduces depression and anxiety while increasing purposefulness.
How to Build a Better Future: 2 Simple Questions That Uplevel Your Life Immediately
Seth Godin teaches two foundational questions—"Who's it for?" and "What's it for?"—that clarify business purpose and help entrepreneurs avoid the trap of trying to serve everyone. He distinguishes between freelancing and entrepreneurship, warns against perfectionism and vanity metrics, and emphasizes making decisions based on available data rather than desired outcomes.
8 Things You Need to Hear Right Now (That Make a Surprisingly Huge Difference)
Mel Robbins shares eight simple reminders designed to reduce exhaustion and stress: appreciating the present moment, pausing before reacting, not taking things personally, acting despite anxiety, taking personal responsibility, changing what comes next, setting boundaries with others, and intentionally creating good days.
How to Master Any Conversation, Communicate With Confidence, and Deal With Difficult People
Oz Perlman, an Emmy-winning mentalist with 30 years of experience, shares techniques for reading people, building confidence, and creating memorable interactions. He teaches practical strategies like the five-second rule for overcoming dread, the "listen, repeat, reply" method for remembering names, and how to make strong first impressions in the crucial first 10 seconds of meeting someone.