DiscussionStory

The Massive Shift Coming to Sports Card Shows

The Geoff Wilson Show

Jonathan Deodica, founder of Got Soul, discusses how he transformed a sneaker convention into a multi-category culture festival featuring trading cards, streetwear, vintage, luxury, and sneakers across 14 global cities. The interview explores Got Soul's unique event format, their content-first strategy that prioritizes community engagement over transactional messaging, and how collectibles serve as a unifying force in an increasingly digital world.

Summary

Jonathan Deodica shares the evolution of Got Soul from a single sneaker event in a Boston church in 2013 to a global culture festival operating in 14 cities worldwide. The key innovation is combining five primary collectible categories—trading cards, sneakers, streetwear, vintage, and luxury items—under one roof, creating a family-friendly experience that appeals to generalists rather than category specialists. This multi-category approach addresses a market gap: while specialty events like the National Sports Card Convention or individual sneaker conventions serve enthusiasts, Got Soul targets the average consumer interested in multiple collecting categories.

The interview emphasizes Got Soul's strategic focus on content and community building as the primary business driver, with physical events serving as content creation opportunities. Deodica explains that Got Soul measures success through audience engagement and care rather than transaction volume. The company maintains 4+ million social media followers across platforms (1M+ Instagram, 1M+ TikTok, nearly 1M Facebook) by posting engaging, non-transactional content that appeals to non-followers. This approach contrasts sharply with traditional event promotion, which typically posts basic promotional content about ticket sales and event dates.

A significant discussion centers on content strategy and algorithmic reach. Deodica and Jeff Wilson discuss how modern social algorithms prioritize non-follower engagement and individual post performance over overall account following. They explain the importance of "top-of-funnel" content that entertains or informs general audiences, gradually narrowing to event-specific details. Examples include Topps' transformation from product-alert posts to storytelling-focused content, and Red Bull's lifestyle marketing approach.

The conversation addresses the multi-category collector reality, with data showing 20%+ of Cards HQ customers purchase across both sports and TCG categories within a year. Got Soul's dealers increasingly operate across multiple sections, and the company observes that many people collect across categories, from sneakers to cards to luxury items.

Deodica discusses Got Soul's expansion philosophy: rather than maximizing show quantity, the focus is on quality and scale of individual events. He emphasizes that Got Soul operates as a dynamic brand that adapts to local cultures and trends—Tokyo shows emphasize TCG, Chicago emphasizes sports nostalgia, reflecting collectible preferences by geography and time period.

The interview concludes with Deodica's origin story: at age 12, after his family lost their home in a fire, he began as a sneaker entrepreneur, eventually launching Got Soul at age 14 with his brother using $2,500 borrowed money and homemade flyers. The first event attracted 200 people; subsequent growth was organic until COVID-19 accelerated their social media presence from 20,000 to 80,000 followers, positioning them for their current global expansion.

Key Insights

  • Got Soul observes that the average consumer is a generalist interested in multiple collecting categories rather than a specialist, challenging the traditional specialty-show model focused on single categories
  • Modern social media algorithms prioritize engagement from non-followers over total follower count, making general-audience content more valuable than follower-targeted content for reach and visibility
  • Got Soul's events function primarily as content creation opportunities with a 363-day content strategy, where the 12 annual show days serve as sets for month-long content rollouts rather than events being the business focus
  • Collectibles serve as a powerful force bringing together people of diverse backgrounds in physical spaces, countering algorithmic fragmentation and AI-driven isolation in increasingly digital society
  • Got Soul intentionally avoids maximizing show quantity in favor of scaling individual events larger and more elaborate, with success measured by audience care and engagement rather than show frequency

Topics

Multi-category collectible events and market positioningContent strategy and social media algorithm optimizationCommunity building versus transactional marketingCross-category collector behavior and dataEvent format innovation and audience experience designBrand building in collectibles industryGeographic and temporal adaptation of event strategyFounder origin story and entrepreneurial journey

Transcript

[0:00] Do you want to know what the future of sports card shows might look like? Then you're going to want to hear this interview because today I have Jonathan Deodica coming into the studio here at Cards HQ. He's the founder of Got Soul. And Got Soul was a sneaker show for many years, but now it's a lot more than that. He's expanded into sports and trading cards, and that's become a big part of their shows. But that's not all. He's put together a really unique format [0:32] for card shows and collectible shows that has really taken off in popularity and it's fascinating to learn about what he's doing and seeing a glimpse into what is…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The Geoff Wilson Show

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.