Is Any Young Quarterback Card Safe Right Now?
Young quarterback football cards have dropped 15% or more in value, making it extremely difficult for collectors to choose which players to invest in. The speaker expresses skepticism about trusting any young QB cards, noting that even when collectors pick the right player, the value may not hold as promising players from previous years (Drake May, Jayden Daniels, C.J. Stroud) have experienced declining appeal.
Summary
The transcript discusses the current state of young quarterback football card collecting and investment. All young quarterback cards have experienced significant price declines of at least 15%. When asked whether any football cards can be trusted right now, the speaker responds with a definitive "no." The speaker acknowledges that while there is a possibility that one of these young quarterbacks will emerge as a successful professional player and reward collectors who held their cards, choosing the right player is essentially a form of gambling. The difficulty lies not just in predicting which quarterback will succeed, but also in the timing of when to sell. The speaker illustrates this point by referencing recent history: Drake May was the popular pick last year, but collectors needed to sell quickly because his promise faded in the following year. This same pattern has repeated with previous years' prospects like Jayden Daniels and C.J. Stroud, suggesting a cyclical trend where young QB cards lose value as real-world performance fails to meet initial expectations or as the next wave of rookie quarterbacks captures collector interest.
Key Insights
- The speaker asserts that all young quarterback cards have experienced price drops of 15% or more in the current market
- The speaker claims that choosing the right young quarterback card to invest in is essentially equivalent to gambling due to the high difficulty involved
- The speaker argues that even successfully picking the right player, as collectors did with Drake May, requires immediate selling because the player's promise diminishes in subsequent years
- The speaker identifies a recurring pattern where young QB cards lose value year-over-year, citing examples from Drake May, Jayden Daniels, and C.J. Stroud across consecutive years
- The speaker expresses complete lack of confidence in the safety of any young quarterback cards as an investment at the current time
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] All of their cards have dropped in price by 15% or more . Is there any football card you trust right now ? I? No. Actually, no. There's a good chance one of these guys will show up, and those who collect their cards will be rewarded. It's just like gambling. It is very difficult to choose the right option. And if you do pick the right player, like people did last year with Drake May, you'd better sell, because next year he might not be as promising. We saw the same trend a year ago with Jayden Daniels, and the same trend the year before that with C.J. Stroud.
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Geoff Wilson Show
'86 Fleer vs '84 Star: Which Michael Jordan Card Should You Buy?
A comparison of two Michael Jordan rookie cards evaluates the 1986 Fleer and 1984 Star cards as investments. The speaker recommends avoiding the Fleer card due to oversupply (51,000 graded copies) and its devastating 50% value crash in 2021, instead favoring the much rarer 1984 Star card (fewer than 2,000 graded copies).
Stop Trying to Ban Trading at Card Shows 🗣️
The speaker defends trading at card shows, arguing that trade nights are a vital part of the hobby community experience. They counter the argument that trading should only happen after shows, emphasizing that informal trades between collectors in hallways are as important as dealer table activities.
10 Sports Cards I Would NEVER Buy at Today’s Prices
A sports card investor advises against buying 10 popular high-priced cards despite their iconic status, arguing that their large populations make them vulnerable to market corrections. Instead, he recommends investing in rarer alternatives by the same players that offer better durability and long-term value.
Card Shops are UNDER ATTACK 😨
Fanatics' new flagship sports card store in London was robbed shortly after opening, with thieves breaking glass and stealing high-value trading cards. The incident highlights the vulnerability of card shops to theft due to the small, portable, and valuable nature of sports cards.
ARE FOOTBALL CARDS ABOUT TO GO NUCLEAR? 📈
A collector reports that football cards, particularly Jackson Dart and Trevor Lawrence, experienced a significant price recovery over the past week after a sluggish opening weekend at a Dallas Card Show. Jackson Dart cards rose 7% after dropping 40% in the offseason, suggesting potential for continued price appreciation if player performance remains strong.