Pulitzer Prize Historian: You Won't Notice Until It's Too Late!
Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Anne Applebaum discusses the decline of democracy in the United States and globally, explaining five core tactics autocratic leaders use to dismantle democratic systems. She draws parallels between historical authoritarian regimes and current political developments under the Trump administration, while warning against historical inevitability and urging civic engagement.
Summary
The interview features historian and author Anne Applebaum, who began her career studying the Soviet Union and has spent recent decades documenting what she sees as a global resurgence of authoritarian instincts. She argues that modern democracies don't end with coups or tanks in the street, but rather through the gradual dismantling of neutral institutions by legitimately elected leaders — a pattern she has observed in Hungary under Viktor Orban, Russia under Putin, and increasingly in the United States under Trump.
Applebaum outlines five core tactics autocratic leaders use to undermine democracy: corruption (using state power to enrich the ruling class and reward loyalty), attacking elections (gerrymandering, voter ID laws, challenging results), capturing the civil service (replacing merit-based appointments with loyalists), controlling information (shaping media ownership and restricting free speech), and militarizing enforcement bodies (creating paramilitary forces like ICE that operate outside normal legal constraints).
On Trump specifically, Applebaum notes that his second term differs fundamentally from his first because he is now surrounded by people actively helping him dismantle democratic constraints, rather than being restrained by the system. She highlights Trump's dramatic net worth increase from $2.3 billion to $6.5 billion during his presidency as evidence of unprecedented presidential corruption, citing Saudi investments in Jared Kushner's fund and Trump family business dealings with foreign governments as examples of decisions being made for personal enrichment rather than American interests.
Applebaum discusses the global repercussions of American democratic decline, noting that the rest of the world is 'hedging' — forming new alliances, trade agreements, and security arrangements that bypass the US. The potential invasion of Greenland was cited as a turning point that forced even historically pro-American allies like Denmark to begin planning for conflict with the United States. She argues this undermines decades of American prosperity built on global trade dominance and strategic military positioning.
The conversation also covers the Iran war, which Applebaum suggests Trump misestimated due to the absence of advisors willing to give him frank negative assessments — a hallmark of autocratic leadership styles. She also addresses the complicity of tech oligarchs like Sam Altman, arguing they have capitulated to Trump out of status anxiety and short-term business interests, despite the long-term risks to the democratic system that underpins their wealth.
Applebaum pushes back strongly against historical determinism, rejecting the idea that democratic decline is inevitable. She argues that human agency, civic participation, and informed voting can reverse these trends, and that complacency — the belief that democracy is self-sustaining — is itself one of the greatest threats. She concludes by urging audiences to understand what democracy actually provides, imagine what its loss would feel like in practical terms, and remain engaged in political life.
Key Insights
- Applebaum argues that modern democracies rarely end through coups but instead through legitimately elected leaders gradually dismantling the neutral institutions — independent courts, electoral commissions, and meritocratic bureaucracies — that make fair elections possible.
- Applebaum contends that Trump's second term is fundamentally different from his first because he is now surrounded by people actively helping him avoid democratic constraints, whereas in his first term the system itself still restrained him.
- Applebaum identifies Trump's net worth growth from $2.3 billion to $6.5 billion during his presidency as historically unprecedented, arguing no previous US president has run businesses while in office in a way that directly benefits from their political decisions.
- Applebaum claims the Saudi government's $2 billion investment in Jared Kushner's fund was not based on Kushner's business merits but on his status as Trump's son-in-law, and that Kushner now negotiates with his own business partners as a Middle East envoy.
- Applebaum argues that ICE, while nominally an immigration enforcement body, now functions as a de facto paramilitary — masked, uniformed, driving unmarked vehicles, unaccountable to local authorities, and operating with impunity — which is a hallmark of autocratic enforcement.
- Applebaum explains that autocracies typically control media not through direct censorship but by helping loyalist business people acquire media properties, which is what she argues Trump is attempting with TikTok, CBS, and CNN.
- Applebaum asserts that the Trump administration's attempt to dictate which courses could be taught at Harvard represents an unprecedented level of government interference in academic institutions with no historical precedent in American history.
- Applebaum argues that tech CEOs like Sam Altman have capitulated to Trump primarily out of status anxiety — fear of losing competitive standing among peers — rather than purely financial calculation, even though they previously described him in the harshest terms.
- Applebaum contends that the potential US invasion of Greenland was a geopolitical turning point that forced historically pro-American allies like Denmark to begin planning military responses against the US, accelerating a global realignment away from American leadership.
- Applebaum argues that proposed voter ID laws requiring passports or birth certificates would disproportionately disenfranchise young voters, minority citizens, low-income Americans, and the 69 million women whose birth certificates don't match their married names — and that this outcome is calculated rather than incidental.
- Applebaum claims that autocracies last far longer than democracies historically, noting that most human societies across history have been governed by monarchies, warlords, or authoritarian rulers, and that even the American Founders knew democracy was fragile and could repeat the fate of the Roman Republic.
- Applebaum argues that the Iran war reflects a core feature of autocratic governance — that no one around Trump was willing to definitively tell him the operation was a bad idea, leading to a severe miscalculation about Iran's decentralized leadership structure and regional proxy networks.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access