DiscussionOpinion

Ask Imran Anything: Vanity Metrics, Creativity and Commerce, Gucci’s Future

The Business of Fashion Podcast32m 33s

In this third installment of "Ask Me Anything," Imran Ahmed addresses 75+ listener questions covering Gucci's strategic direction, the validity of vanity metrics like EMV, the balance between creativity and commerce in luxury fashion, AI's role in creative industries, and opportunities in emerging markets like Latin America and India.

Summary

Imran Ahmed, founder and CEO of the Business of Fashion, responds to numerous questions from global listeners about contemporary fashion business issues. On Gucci's future, Ahmed notes that the brand's recent Milan collection under creative director Demna showed the clearest vision yet with accessible preppy and bourgeois aesthetics, though questions remain about whether this momentum is sufficient in a challenging luxury market where consumers demand greater value and emotional connection. Regarding the tension between creativity and commerciality, Ahmed emphasizes that successful brands like Chanel work because leadership across design, merchandising, marketing, and business strategy are aligned on a single vision, not because of designer changes alone. He critiques vanity metrics like Earned Media Value (EMV) and Media Impact Value (MIV), arguing these are largely invented numbers designed to justify marketing budgets rather than genuine measures of brand health or commercial performance, and that actual business metrics—revenue, profit, and long-term brand health—matter far more. On artificial intelligence, Ahmed disputes the premise that AI can independently create beautiful campaigns or strategies, asserting that human judgment, taste, and experience remain fundamental to creative work, with AI functioning as an iterative thought partner rather than a replacement. He emphasizes the importance of Latin America as a fast-growing fashion market and expresses commitment to deeper engagement with the region. On the use of Indian heritage and artisanal techniques by Western luxury houses, Ahmed distinguishes between proper collaboration (like Maria Grazia Curie's long-term work with Indian ateliers at Fendi) versus appropriation (like Prada's initial presentation of Kolhapuri sandals without cultural credit), advocating for proper attribution and compensation. Finally, Ahmed reflects on his personal career journey, explaining how he deliberately combined analytical business skills with creative interests to found BOF, and identifies writing as the concrete practice he has maintained since childhood.

About this episode

<p>This week, by popular demand, we are back for the third installment of Ask Me Anything, where listeners from around the world send in their most pressing questions about what is happening in the fashion business.</p><br /><p>This time, the conversation jumps off from the latest season of shows, specifically what’s actually happening at Gucci, whether metrics like Earned Media Value (EMV) and Media Impact Value (MIV) are worth anything at all, how brands can strike the right balance between creativity and commerce, and where human judgement still remains integral, even as AI becomes part of everyday creative work.</p><br /><p><strong>Key Insights:</strong></p><ul><li><strong>Gucci’s creative direction has sharpened, but the business case hasn’t.</strong> After several collections that felt disjointed, Amed sees Demna’s most recent Milan show as the clearest statement yet of his vision for the house. “This most recent show, The Store, just kind of clicked.” But Amed is not ready to call it a fix: “The remaining question I have is, is it enough in this very challenging market where the luxury industry is not growing?”</li></ul><p><br /></p><ul><li><strong>Brand-measurement metrics deserve scepticism:</strong> Asked whether scores like Earned Media Value (EMV) and Media Impact Value (MIV) actually mean anything, Amed argues they’re built to serve a different purpose than the one marketed. “Honestly, these are vanity metrics,” he says, noting they’re often “designed for marketing teams to ask for money from finance people.” His test for any brand: “Long-term brand health and commercial performance, that matters.”</li></ul><p><br /></p><ul><li><strong>Creative success depends on alignment between designer and business:</strong> Comparing the current moment at Balenciaga and Chanel, Amed suggests the difference isn’t talent but clarity of the brief. On Balenciaga: “I get the sense that the brief was a bit disjointed ... can you mine the heritage of Cristóbal Balenciaga ... and then can you also keep the customers that Demna managed to attract ... Are those things even compatible?” At Chanel, by contrast: “They’re all singing from the same hymn sheet about what Chanel is trying to do now ... When it works like it’s working at Chanel, it does feel like magic.”</li></ul><p><br /></p><ul><li><strong>AI changes how humans create, not whether they’re needed.</strong> Amed pushes back on the idea that AI can generate campaigns or strategy on its own. “I don’t think AI on its own can generate beautiful campaigns ... it still requires a human to work with it.” His advice to anyone starting out: build real-world taste and judgement, “because that’s going to be priceless in the age of AI.”</li></ul><p><br /></p><ul><li><strong>Crediting artisans is what separates collaboration from appropriation.</strong> Weighing the recent Prada and Fendi controversies over Indian craftsmanship, Amed draws a clear line between the two. On Fendi’s long relationship with Mumbai atelier Chanakya: “Maria Grazia is investing in and spending time with the artisans ... that for me is an example of how these things should work.” On Prada’s uncredited Kolhapuri sandals: “That felt like a real case of appropriation.” His broader principle: “If you’re going to take something from a culture, credit the people, make sure they’re properly compensated.”</li></ul><p><br /></p><p><strong>Additional Resources:</strong></p><ul><li><strong><u><a href="https://www.businessoffashion.com/reviews/fashion-week/demna-gucci-spring-summer-2027/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Has Demna Solved Gucci’s Identity Crisis? | BoF</a></u></strong></li><li><strong><u><a href="https://www.businessoffashion.com/case-studies/luxury/how-chanel-returned-to-growth-luxury-downturn-matthieu-blazy-leena-nair/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Chanel: The Designer Revamp That Worked | BoF</a></u></strong></li><li><strong><u><a href="https://www.businessoffashion.com/articles/global-markets/fendi-baguette-cultural-appropriation-chiuri-swali-chanakya/" rel="noopener noreferrer" target="_blank">Did Fendi Commit Cultural Appropriation in India? It’s Not That Simple | BoF</a></u></strong></li></ul><hr /><p style="color: grey; font-size: 0.75em;"> Hosted on Acast. See <a href="https://acast.com/privacy" rel="noopener noreferrer" style="color: grey;" target="_blank">acast.com/privacy</a> for more information.</p>

Key Insights

  • Ahmed argues that Gucci's recent Milan collection showed the sharpest and most focused expression of Demna's vision yet, but questions remain about whether this momentum is sufficient given the luxury market's current challenges and consumer demands for greater value and emotional connection.
  • Ahmed claims that successful brand transformations depend not primarily on designer changes alone, but on alignment across all organizational functions—design, merchandising, marketing, and business strategy—around a single explicit strategic vision.
  • Ahmed contends that EMV, MIV, and similar metrics are largely invented measurements designed to help marketing departments justify budgets to finance teams, and that their dollar valuations lack scientific basis and do not correlate reliably with actual commercial performance.
  • Ahmed argues that AI cannot independently generate beautiful imagery, campaigns, or strategies, and that human taste, judgment, and experience remain fundamentally necessary to create effective creative work, with AI functioning as an iterative partner rather than a standalone tool.
  • Ahmed distinguishes between appropriate cultural borrowing (long-term collaborative relationships with artisans, proper credit and compensation) and cultural appropriation (taking heritage techniques without attribution or relationship), using Fendi and Prada examples to illustrate the difference.
  • Ahmed asserts that human judgment and experience are priceless in the age of AI, and advises professionals to invest in real experiences, physical culture, and taste-building as foundational to thriving in AI-augmented creative fields.
  • Ahmed identifies a pattern in luxury market leadership where top-performing brands like Chanel do not necessarily rank highest on EMV metrics, suggesting these attention-based measures fail to predict genuine market success or consumer preference.
  • Ahmed frames the founding of BOF as solving the problem of bridging the creative and business sides of fashion, which he identified as underserved, and credits the intersection of analytical and creative thinking as a primary source of the organization's value creation.

Topics

Gucci's strategic direction and future under DemnaCreativity versus commerciality in luxury brand strategyVanity metrics (EMV, MIV) and their actual business valueAI's role in creative industries and designLatin American fashion market opportunitiesIndian artisanal heritage and cultural appropriation in luxuryBalancing analytical and creative thinking in career developmentLong-term brand health metrics versus attention metrics

Transcript

With the Spark Cash Plus card from Capital One, you earn unlimited 2% cash back on every purchase, and you get big purchasing power, so your business can spend more and earn more. Stephen, Brandon, and Bruno, the business owners of SandCloud, reinvested their 2% cash back to help build the company's retail presence. Capital One, what's in your wallet? Find out more at CapitalOne.com slash Spark Cash Plus. Terms apply. Find out more at CapitalOne.com slash SparkCashPlus. Terms apply. wardrobe reset and more like a cheat sheet for a few things you might want to try. For autumn, it's all about richer colours and textures. Think chocolate brown, deep greens, grey and stone, with suede coming through in everything…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from The Business of Fashion Podcast

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.