Product Innovation: Better, Or Just New?
A BBC podcast examining how companies across different sectors approach product innovation, featuring executives from P&G, Mars, and Amazon Ring discussing their strategies for continuously improving products. The discussion explores whether constant innovation truly benefits consumers or creates unnecessary product cycling driven by psychological obsolescence.
Summary
This BBC Bottom Line podcast episode explores product innovation across three major consumer sectors through interviews with executives from Procter & Gamble, Mars, and Amazon Ring. Host Evan Davis begins by referencing Alfred Sloan's introduction of annual model changes at General Motors, establishing the historical context for planned obsolescence and continuous product updates. Tom Moody from P&G discusses how washing detergent innovation responds to changing consumer habits like larger washing drums, shorter cycle times, and synthetic gym fabrics. He emphasizes P&G's obsessive consumer research, including daily shaving observations at their Reading facility that led to discovering men miss spots under their noses, not jawlines. Gary Moppet from Mars explains their 90-year innovation journey with Maltesers, including seasonal products like the Billy bunny and recent white Maltesers relaunch. He describes their five-year innovation pipelines focused on desirability, viability, and feasibility. Dave Ward from Amazon Ring recounts how founder Jamie's garage problem of missing deliveries evolved into a security-focused company, and discusses their controversial AI-powered missing pet detection service. All three executives acknowledge innovation failures - P&G's COVID-era Microban cleaner, Mars's misbranded Mars Delight, and Ring's floodlight installation issues. The discussion reveals that companies invest billions in R&D, conduct continuous consumer research, and view innovation as essential for brand survival. Davis challenges whether this creates a 'rat race' of psychological obsolescence, but the executives maintain that genuine consumer needs drive their innovation cycles, not artificial product cycling.
About this episode
<p>From smartphones to trainers, confectionary and cleaning products, we live in a culture of constant updates. Companies reformulate, redesign and refresh their products in a continuous race to stay ahead. But how are those decisions made? What counts as meaningful improvement and how much is designed to make last year’s version feel old? Evan Davis and guests discuss how products evolve and why standing still is the fastest way to fall behind.</p><p>Guests: Tom Moody, Senior Vice President and Managing Director, P&G (Proctor & Gamble) Northern Europe Dr Garry Moppett, Senior Director of Research & Development at Mars Dave Ward, UK and International Managing Director, Amazon Ring. </p><p>Production team: Presenter: Evan Davis Producer: Sally Abrahams Sound engineers: Lee Wilson and Donald MacDonald Production co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Editor: Matt Willis </p><p>The Bottom Line is produced in partnership with The Open University</p>
Key Insights
- Alfred Sloan at General Motors pioneered the concept of annual model changes to create psychological obsolescence in older car models
- P&G discovered through daily shaving research that men most commonly miss spots under their noses, not along jawlines as assumed
- Mars operates on five-year innovation pipelines evaluating products on three criteria: desirability, viability, and feasibility
- Amazon Ring's founder still personally answers customer emails sent to his address printed on every product box
- Companies use 'deprivation studies' where they give consumers products then take them away to measure genuine attachment versus politeness
- Modern 16-year-olds in the UK are more likely to start with body shaving than facial hair shaving, driving razor innovation
- Mars maintains 90-year-old brands like Maltesers through continuous innovation while keeping core products essentially unchanged
- P&G sells 23 items per second in the UK, creating constant real-time feedback on product acceptance or rejection
Topics
Transcript
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. LinkedIn has a word for that. Bullspend. Now you can invest in what looks good to your CFO. LinkedIn Ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. You'll reach the right buyers because you can target by company, industry, job title and more. So cut the bullspend. Advertise on LinkedIn. The network that works for you. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get a $250 discount. Get $250 credit for the next one. Just go to linkedin.com slash broadcast. That's linkedin.com slash broadcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hey sweetie, your mother showed me this Carvana thing for selling the car. I'm going to give…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Bottom Line
Imposter Syndrome
This BBC podcast episode explores imposter syndrome through discussions with three guests: Andy Ransom (former CEO of Rentokil Initial), Katie Leeson (founder of Courageous consulting), and Dr. Valerie Young (imposter syndrome expert). The conversation examines how successful people experience persistent self-doubt despite concrete evidence of their accomplishments, and explores coping strategies and whether these feelings can be productive.
The Costs and Benefits of Business Regulation
A BBC podcast discussing how excessive and poorly-coordinated regulation in the UK hampers business growth and infrastructure development. Three experts examine regulatory problems across sectors—from nuclear power to small businesses—and debate how governments can balance necessary protections with economic efficiency.
How the oil industry works
A BBC Bottom Line podcast episode exploring how the oil industry works, featuring experts in upstream exploration, downstream refining, and oil market analysis. The discussion covers the full production chain from geological exploration to consumer products, current market disruptions from the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, and long-term questions about oil's future role in the global economy.
Entrepreneurs: Your Questions Answered
Three successful entrepreneurs discuss the challenges of starting and running businesses in a BBC Q&A format, addressing listener questions about funding, marketing, networking, and risk-taking. The panel emphasizes that entrepreneurship requires resilience, calculated risk-taking, and the ability to bootstrap before seeking investment.
How Do You Deal with a Workplace Bully?
A BBC podcast discussion examining workplace bullying with experts on organizational psychology, dispute resolution, and business management. The conversation explores definitions of bullying, its prevalence, company obligations, and strategies for addressing it at both organizational and individual levels.