How Do You Deal with a Workplace Bully?
A BBC podcast discussion examining workplace bullying with experts on organizational psychology, dispute resolution, and business management. The conversation explores definitions of bullying, its prevalence, company obligations, and strategies for addressing it at both organizational and individual levels.
Summary
This BBC Bottom Line podcast episode focuses on workplace bullying, featuring three guests: Jason Warner (Managing Director at SBS digital agency), Professor Cara Ng (organizational psychologist at University of Manchester), and Kevin Rhone (Director of Dispute Resolution at ACAS). The discussion begins by establishing that 44% of employees experienced workplace conflict in the past year, with 25% experiencing some form of bullying. Jason shares his personal experience of working in a toxic environment where a managing director created a culture of public shaming and naming employees in group chats, leading to a clique of followers who perpetuated the bullying behavior even when the leader wasn't present. The conversation explores whether bullying tendencies are inherent or environmentally driven, with Professor Ng arguing that while some may be predisposed to bullying, the work environment and social pressures are primary factors that can cause anyone to engage in negative behaviors under the right circumstances. The guests discuss the potential influence of 'strongman leadership' exemplified by figures like Trump, though they're divided on whether this directly impacts workplace behavior. Kevin Rhone explains that bullying constitutes any unwanted behavior that is offensive, malicious, or harmful, leading to emotional or physical harm. The academic definition requires sustained, repeated behavior over time, distinguishing it from one-off incidents. Examples of bullying include persistent criticism, social exclusion, unreasonable workloads, physical isolation, and targeting based on personal characteristics like football team allegiances or dietary choices. The legal framework distinguishes between bullying (not illegal but harmful) and harassment (illegal when related to protected characteristics like race or religion). Companies have duties to protect workers from harm and should implement zero-tolerance policies, proper complaint processes, and cultural changes. The discussion addresses the challenge of distinguishing between legitimate performance management and bullying behavior, emphasizing the importance of delivery method and workplace culture. Bystander intervention emerges as a crucial topic, with acknowledgment that witnessing bullying creates uncomfortable situations where junior employees may feel unable to speak up due to power dynamics.
About this episode
<p>Across our professional careers, many of us will come into contact with a difficult colleague or hard-to-please superior. But what happens when difficult behaviour crosses over into bullying at work? What effect does this have, not only on our wellbeing, but on our workplace as a whole? </p><p>Evidence suggests that bullying may be on the rise in the UK. A 2025 survey of British workers conducted by ACAS (Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service) found that 44% of respondents had experienced conflict at work in the last 12 months. And on the global stage, the resurgence of ‘strong man’ leadership has reignited a debate: does bullying behaviour get you what you want? </p><p>Evan and the panel look at what workplace bullying is, when and why bullying can occur, and the steps individuals and organisations can take to tackle this behaviour in the workplace. </p><p>Guests: Jason Warner, Managing Director (UK and EMEA) at SBS Kevin Rowan, Director of Dispute Resolution at ACAS Kara Ng, Senior Lecturer in Organisational Psychology at Alliance Manchester Business School, University of Manchester </p><p>Production team: Presenter: Evan Davis Producer: Mhairi MacKenzie Production Co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound engineers: James Beard and Neil Churchill Editor: Matt Willis </p><p>The Bottom Line is produced in partnership with The Open University</p>
Key Insights
- Professor Ng argues that environmental factors and workplace stress are more influential than inherent personality traits in determining who becomes a workplace bully
- Jason Warner describes how bullying cultures can create 'everyday scaries' where employees dread coming to work due to sustained toxic behavior from leadership
- Kevin Rhone explains that 25% of the workforce experiences some form of bullying at any given time, with underreporting being a significant issue
- The academic definition of workplace bullying requires sustained, repeated behavior over time, distinguishing it from one-off aggressive incidents
- Cara Ng identifies that bullying often involves creating 'outsiders' from group norms, such as isolating vegetarians among meat-eaters or supporters of rival football teams
- Kevin Rhone clarifies that while bullying itself is not illegal in the UK, harassment related to protected characteristics is, and employers have duties to protect workers from harm
- The discussion reveals that upward bullying from juniors to seniors can occur through persistent negativity, sarcasm, and making supervisors uncomfortable about giving direction
- Jason Warner emphasizes that effective bystander intervention requires proper organizational systems and culture that protect employees who speak up against unacceptable behavior
Topics
Transcript
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. LinkedIn has a word for that. Bullspend. Now you can invest in what looks good to your CFO. LinkedIn ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. You'll reach the right buyers because you can target by company, industry, job title and more. So cut the bullspend. Advertise on LinkedIn. The network that works for you. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get a $250 discount. Get $250 credit for the next one. Just go to linkedin.com slash broadcast. That's linkedin.com slash broadcast. Terms and conditions apply. Are you really buying a car online on Autotrader right now? Really? I can get super specific…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Bottom Line
Imposter Syndrome
This BBC podcast episode explores imposter syndrome through discussions with three guests: Andy Ransom (former CEO of Rentokil Initial), Katie Leeson (founder of Courageous consulting), and Dr. Valerie Young (imposter syndrome expert). The conversation examines how successful people experience persistent self-doubt despite concrete evidence of their accomplishments, and explores coping strategies and whether these feelings can be productive.
The Costs and Benefits of Business Regulation
A BBC podcast discussing how excessive and poorly-coordinated regulation in the UK hampers business growth and infrastructure development. Three experts examine regulatory problems across sectors—from nuclear power to small businesses—and debate how governments can balance necessary protections with economic efficiency.
How the oil industry works
A BBC Bottom Line podcast episode exploring how the oil industry works, featuring experts in upstream exploration, downstream refining, and oil market analysis. The discussion covers the full production chain from geological exploration to consumer products, current market disruptions from the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, and long-term questions about oil's future role in the global economy.
Entrepreneurs: Your Questions Answered
Three successful entrepreneurs discuss the challenges of starting and running businesses in a BBC Q&A format, addressing listener questions about funding, marketing, networking, and risk-taking. The panel emphasizes that entrepreneurship requires resilience, calculated risk-taking, and the ability to bootstrap before seeking investment.
Product Innovation: Better, Or Just New?
A BBC podcast examining how companies across different sectors approach product innovation, featuring executives from P&G, Mars, and Amazon Ring discussing their strategies for continuously improving products. The discussion explores whether constant innovation truly benefits consumers or creates unnecessary product cycling driven by psychological obsolescence.