Dynamic Pricing: Who Profits?
This BBC podcast explores dynamic pricing across industries, examining how businesses vary prices based on time and demand. The discussion covers ticketing, energy, and other sectors, addressing both the business rationale and consumer concerns about these pricing strategies.
Summary
The podcast examines dynamic pricing as an increasingly prevalent business practice enabled by technology. Host Evan Davis interviews three experts: Richard Howell from ticketing consultancy RH Insights, Zoe Sir Northbond from Octopus Energy for Business, and marketing professor Marco Bertini from Essade Business School. The discussion begins by clarifying terminology, distinguishing between dynamic pricing (prices changing over time based on supply/demand), personalized pricing (different prices for different customers), and time-of-use pricing (preset price variations). Marco traces the historical arc from haggling in bazaars to fixed department store prices, and back to variable pricing through technology. The energy sector emerges as a clear success story, with Octopus Energy's customers typically saving 25% through dynamic tariffs that reflect wholesale price fluctuations throughout the day. Richard explains how live entertainment pricing works differently due to perishable inventory and emotional purchasing decisions, noting that 95-97% of his price changes over 25 years have been downward. The Oasis ticket controversy is clarified as involving preset price tiers rather than true dynamic pricing, though consumers perceived it as price manipulation. Consumer psychology plays a major role, with people typically noticing price increases more than decreases and assuming companies are trying to exploit them. The experts argue that transparency and clear communication about pricing rationale are essential for consumer acceptance. The business case centers on maximizing revenue from fixed assets while offering lower prices during off-peak periods, benefiting both businesses and price-sensitive consumers.
About this episode
<p>Everyone wants to get the best price they can when they buy, whether that’s a product, a service or an experience. But the ‘best price’ can look different for different people, and at different times. </p><p>Surge pricing, tiered prices, off-peak discounts, time-of-use pricing- technology has enabled more industries to employ dynamic pricing to get the best prices for their products by altering them depending on a range of sophisticated considerations. </p><p>But this has made pricing less predictable and left customers feeling like the prices are often stacked against them; most notably after the Oasis reunion tour ticket sales in 2024. </p><p>Is dynamic pricing really as bad as we all think? Evan and guests look at the psychology behind consumer perceptions of dynamic pricing, and ask how different industries can utilise the pricing model to benefit themselves and their customers. </p><p>Guests: Richard Howle, founder of RH Insights Zoisa North-Bond, CEO of Octopus Energy for Business Marco Bertini, Professor of Marketing at Esade Business School</p><p>Production team: Presenter: Evan Davis Producer: Mhairi MacKenzie Production Co-ordinator: Katie Morrison Sound engineers: Daniel Fox and Steve Greenwood Editor: Matt Willis </p><p>The Bottom Line is produced in partnership with The Open University</p>
Key Insights
- Marco Bertini argues that dynamic pricing represents a return to historical bazaar-style haggling, enabled by modern technology after a period of fixed department store pricing
- Zoe Sir Northbond claims that three-quarters of Octopus Energy business customers save money on dynamic tariffs, with typical savings of 25% simply by signing up
- Richard Howell reveals that 95-97% of his ticket price changes over 25 years have been downward rather than upward, contrary to consumer perception
- Marco states that consumers are inherently pessimistic about pricing changes and tend to notice surge pricing more than plunge pricing
- Richard explains that the Oasis ticket controversy involved preset price tiers rather than true dynamic pricing, but consumers perceived the experience as price manipulation
- Marco contends that businesses should be transparent about pricing strategies because hiding prices suggests questionable practices
- Zoe describes how negative electricity prices can occur when there's excess supply, allowing customers to benefit from grid surplus
- Richard argues that emotional purchasing decisions in live entertainment make consumers particularly sensitive to perceived price exploitation during high-demand ticket sales
Topics
Transcript
This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. LinkedIn has a word for that. Bullspend. Now you can invest in what looks good to your CFO. LinkedIn ads generates the highest ROAS of all major ad networks. You'll reach the right buyers because you can target by company, industry, job title and more. So cut the bullspend. Advertise on LinkedIn. The network that works for you. Spend $250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get a $250 discount. Get $250 credit for the next one. Just go to linkedin.com slash broadcast. That's linkedin.com slash broadcast. Terms and conditions apply. It all starts with a subscription to BBC.com and a BBC app. Find out more at bbc.com…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from The Bottom Line
Imposter Syndrome
This BBC podcast episode explores imposter syndrome through discussions with three guests: Andy Ransom (former CEO of Rentokil Initial), Katie Leeson (founder of Courageous consulting), and Dr. Valerie Young (imposter syndrome expert). The conversation examines how successful people experience persistent self-doubt despite concrete evidence of their accomplishments, and explores coping strategies and whether these feelings can be productive.
The Costs and Benefits of Business Regulation
A BBC podcast discussing how excessive and poorly-coordinated regulation in the UK hampers business growth and infrastructure development. Three experts examine regulatory problems across sectors—from nuclear power to small businesses—and debate how governments can balance necessary protections with economic efficiency.
How the oil industry works
A BBC Bottom Line podcast episode exploring how the oil industry works, featuring experts in upstream exploration, downstream refining, and oil market analysis. The discussion covers the full production chain from geological exploration to consumer products, current market disruptions from the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, and long-term questions about oil's future role in the global economy.
Entrepreneurs: Your Questions Answered
Three successful entrepreneurs discuss the challenges of starting and running businesses in a BBC Q&A format, addressing listener questions about funding, marketing, networking, and risk-taking. The panel emphasizes that entrepreneurship requires resilience, calculated risk-taking, and the ability to bootstrap before seeking investment.
Product Innovation: Better, Or Just New?
A BBC podcast examining how companies across different sectors approach product innovation, featuring executives from P&G, Mars, and Amazon Ring discussing their strategies for continuously improving products. The discussion explores whether constant innovation truly benefits consumers or creates unnecessary product cycling driven by psychological obsolescence.