‘How do I heal?’: the long wait for justice after a black man dies in police custody
An investigation into deaths of Black men in police custody in Britain reveals that Black people are seven times more likely to die than white people when police restraint is applied, yet accountability mechanisms consistently fail to address racial discrimination or hold officers responsible.
Summary
This investigation examines the systemic failures in addressing deaths of Black men in British police custody, focusing on cases like Osai, Cain Fletcher, Adrian McDonald, and others who died after police contact. The author, working for the charity Inquest, uncovered that Black people are seven times more likely to die than white people when police restraint is involved - a statistic that has been hidden from public view. Despite this disproportionality, the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) has never found a police officer guilty of racial discrimination in cases where Black people died following police contact. The investigation reveals a pattern where Black men experiencing mental health crises are treated as threats rather than victims needing help, with officers routinely using racial stereotypes about their strength and dangerousness to justify excessive force. The accountability system - including police watchdog investigations, coroner inquests, and disciplinary proceedings - consistently fails bereaved families, with processes designed to protect officers rather than deliver justice. Even when inquests conclude that unlawful or excessive force was used, officers typically keep their jobs and face no meaningful consequences. The report documents how racial considerations are systematically excluded from investigations and inquests, creating a cycle where discriminatory patterns repeat without acknowledgment or reform.
Key Insights
- Official data shows that Black people are seven times more likely to die than white people when police restraint is applied, but this statistic has been deliberately hidden from public view by authorities
- In the past 35 years, only one police officer in England and Wales has been convicted of manslaughter following a death in police custody, and that was in the case of Black former footballer Dalian Atkinson
- Between 2015 and 2021, not a single officer was found to have a case to answer for racial discrimination in cases where Black people died after police force was used, despite 22 such deaths occurring
- Police routinely justify excessive force against Black men by invoking racial stereotypes about their physical strength and perceived dangerousness, with officers commonly stating 'he was so strong' and 'I feared for my life'
- The IPCC/IOPC investigation system systematically fails to examine racial discrimination unless racism is expressed overtly through verbal abuse or social media posts, treating each death as an isolated incident
- Coroners actively resist allowing questions about racial discrimination into their courtrooms, viewing such inquiries as inappropriate or offensive rather than necessary for justice
- Police forces often refuse to present evidence against their own officers in disciplinary hearings, causing proceedings to collapse even when the watchdog recommends gross misconduct charges
- The state portrays each new death as an isolated accident while refusing to acknowledge the clear patterns that emerge when cases are examined collectively, representing a deliberate political decision to avoid accountability
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access