StoryOpinion

Finally! My Massive 78 Card PSA Submission Blind Reveal!

Stryker Breaks

A collector reveals 78 PSA-graded trading cards submitted 226 days prior, achieving a 70% gem rate (54 PSA 10s) with mostly 2024 Topps baseball and basketball cards. Despite expecting a 50% gem rate due to PSA standard changes, the actual results matched his historical 70-80% performance, featuring notable pulls like a black gold Paul Skins gem and low-pop rookie cards.

Summary

The video documents a blind reveal of 78 trading cards graded by PSA after a 226-day wait period. The collector had paid upcharges on multiple cards and deliberately avoided looking at any results beforehand. Starting with an orange Jackson Holiday crackle foil PSA 10, the early cards produced an unexpected run of gems, with the first several cards all grading as PSA 10s. The collection heavily features 2024 Topps Update baseball cards, including multiple Jackson Holiday parallels (Aqua, Green, Aqua X-Fractor versions) and several rookie debuts. Basketball cards are also well-represented, particularly Trey Cooper cards from various insert sets like Generation Now, Clutch City, and Power Players, with the Cooper cards consistently gemming at high rates. Notable high-end hits include a Paul Skins black gold PSA 10 (described as the first he's ever gemmed), a Canipple gold parallel numbered to 50, a Ryan Howard autograph (16 of 25, potentially a one-pop), and a rare three-of-five on-card autograph Canipple NBA debut that graded PSA 9. The collector discusses his grading methodology, noting that centering issues combined with any other flaw—even microscopic ones like surface dimples or white specks—will result in a 9 rather than a 10. He explains his submission strategy involves carefully selecting only the best specimens from large pools of cards he's pulled. The final tally shows 54 PSA 10s and 24 cards grading lower (mostly 9s, with two 8s and one noted lower grade), resulting in a 70% gem rate that matches his historical submission patterns despite his concern about tighter PSA standards. Most cards are planned for either his eBay store or personal vault.

Key Insights

  • The collector expected a 50% gem rate due to PSA standard changes since his last submission, but actually achieved 70% (54 of 78 PSA 10s), which matches his historical 70-80% gem rate and suggests the standards change had minimal impact on his submission quality.
  • A general rule for PSA submissions is that 60/40 centering with no other flaws can achieve a gem grade, but the same centering combined with even microscopic flaws like surface dimples or white specks will result in a PSA 9 instead of a 10.
  • When submitting cards, the collector typically selects only about 50 cards from a pool of 500 potential candidates, taking only the best specimens and being selective about which parallels and inserts are worth submitting.
  • X-Fractor cards are notorious for roller lines or print lines that run up and down them, and the collector typically avoids submitting these unless there are no visible lines, which contributed to certain X-Fractor cards gemming despite centering issues.
  • Diamonte cards are particularly difficult to grade gems because the foil can curl up on the edges from the manufacturer, and even combining slight foil curl with tiny surface specks results in PSA 9 grades instead of 10s.

Topics

PSA grading and gem rates2024 Topps Update baseball cardsTrading card condition and centeringJackson Holiday rookie cards and parallelsTrey Cooper basketball cardsCard selection and submission strategyRare and low-pop graded cardsTrading card market and collectibility

Transcript

[0:00] Hello, my friends. Today I've got a blind PSA reveal. 78 cards. It's been 226 days since I sent these things off and they're finally here today. I've not looked at these cards. I've not looked at the grades. I have no idea what to expect. All I know is that I did get an upcharge. I got multiple upcharges and I paid the fee and here we have them. So, without further ado, card number one. I've got them all flipped upside down. No clue. I'm hoping expecting about a 50% gem rate. Hopefully. Let's go. [0:32] And the very first card is an orange Jackson Holiday crackle foil board PSA 10. It's a great way to start.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Stryker Breaks

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.