StoryDiscussion

I Almost Sold My Card for $1,000 LESS 😳

Sports Card Investor

A card seller discovers their Kobe card was priced too low due to improper sticker placement and accepts a $3,300 offer from a gracious buyer who pointed out the error. Despite losing some potential profit, the seller appreciates the buyer's honesty and accepts the below-market offer as fair compensation for the mistake.

Summary

In this transcript, a card collector/seller is examining a valuable card (appears to be a Kobe card based on context) when they notice an issue with the price sticker placement. A buyer or associate points out that the sticker is positioned quite low on the card. The seller acknowledges this mistake and recognizes that the improper sticker placement has negatively impacted the card's value or appeal. Rather than holding firm to their original asking price, the seller decides to reduce the price and accepts a $3,300 offer from the buyer. The seller justifies this decision by explaining that they feel obligated to discount the price given their error with the sticker placement. The seller describes the buyer as very gracious and nice for alerting them to the problem. Despite giving up profit on what appears to be a valuable Kobe card, the seller frames the $3,300 discounted offer as a fair resolution that acknowledges their mistake while still landing below recent comparable sales prices for similar cards. The interaction demonstrates the buyer's integrity in pointing out the issue rather than taking advantage of the mispriced listing.

Key Insights

  • The seller recognizes that improper sticker placement on a card significantly affects its marketability and accepts a $3,300 discount as appropriate compensation for this error
  • The buyer proactively alerts the seller to the sticker placement issue rather than exploiting the mispricing, demonstrating honesty in the transaction
  • The seller is willing to accept below recent comparable sales prices as a fair outcome when they have made a presentation error, even though this means less profit
  • Sticker placement quality is considered significant enough in card collecting to justify substantial price reductions when poorly positioned
  • The seller explicitly acknowledges feeling indebted to the buyer for the courtesy of pointing out the mistake, viewing this as motivation to accept the reduced offer graciously

Topics

Card pricing and valuationSticker placement impact on card conditionNegotiation and deal acceptanceBuyer-seller ethicsKobe card market

Transcript

[0:00] Is my sticker low on that? >> Yes, yes. I think it's quite low, actually. >> Quite low? Am I quite low on that? Oh, yeah, look at that. You're right. He's very, very nice. He just alerted me, right? So, I'll go a little bit below the last sale because I feel bad that I've got it stickered where I do. >> What about I escape you $3,300 off? >> Even though I'm giving up a little bit there on the Kobe, I will graciously accept your $3,300 offer. That gets you below recent comps, but it still atones for my mistake, and he was very, very gracious and nice for letting me know that I had that…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Sports Card Investor

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.