Are Card Grading Companies CONSISTENT? ๐
A video experiment tests the consistency of card grading companies by submitting the same card to multiple graders (BGS, CGC, and PSA). The card receives ratings of 8.5, 8.5, and 8-9 respectively, demonstrating relatively consistent grading across different companies.
Summary
The transcript documents an experiment examining whether major card grading companies (BGS, CGC, and PSA) grade cards consistently. The same card was submitted to three different grading companies with the following results: BGS assigned an 8.5 grade, CGC also assigned an 8.5 grade, and PSA assigned either an 8 or 9 (the transcript indicates both possibilities are mentioned). The host acknowledges that there is ongoing debate in the collecting community about the inconsistency of these valuation companies. The results shown in this particular experiment appear to validate the grading companies' consistency, as all three provided very similar ratings within a narrow range. The host expresses some satisfaction with the sequence of grades received, suggesting this outcome was relatively positive compared to expectations of potential inconsistency.
About this episode
Are sports card grading companies consistent, or can the same card receive different grades depending on who evaluates it? Card grading involves examining factors like centering, corners, edges and surface, but there can still be subjectivity in the process. This raises one of the hobbyโs biggest questions: how repeatable are grades from companies like PSA, BGS and CGC? What has your experience been with grading consistency? #CardGrading #SportsCards #PSA #BGS #CGC #SportsCardInvestor #CardCollector #TradingCards #TheHobby
Key Insights
- The speaker demonstrates that the same card received nearly identical grades from three major grading companies (BGS 8.5, CGC 8.5, PSA 8-9), suggesting consistency across the industry despite ongoing debate
- There is significant debate in the collecting community surrounding the inconsistency of card valuation and grading companies
- The grading results in this experiment were positive, with the appraisal companies hitting their target and demonstrating aligned evaluation standards
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] We unboxed it and it received a BGS rating of 8.5. Then we unpacked it again and it got a CGC 8.5. What will he get from PSA? Eight. There is a lot of debate surrounding the inconsistency of valuation companies. The appraisal companies hit the target this time. Let's see if it will be the same here. Nine. OK. Okay, that's a pretty good sequence overall.
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Sports Card Investor
Why Is This Card So CHEAP?! ๐คฏ
The speaker examines a quad autograph card featuring four athletes signed in gold ink with impressive grades (auto grade 10, card grade 8). Despite the card's quality and notability of the signatories, the speaker is surprised by its relatively inexpensive price point.
2026 Topps Update Baseball Is HERE! Everything You Need to Know
A comprehensive review of 2026 Topps Update Baseball, the final flagship baseball release of the year celebrating Topps' 75th anniversary. The video details available box formats, insert sets, and special parallels before opening a jumbo box to showcase the product's contents.
This Box Opening Just Kept Getting CRAZIER ๐ณ
The speaker is unboxing collectible items and showcases a rare laundry tag item from Logan Gilbert of the Seattle baseball team. They mention giving away items this weekend on Whatnot and indicate they're only partway through the unboxing experience.
Did I Make More Money With Football OR Basketball Boxes?
A sports card collector opens a $1,200 box of 2018 basketball cards and a $1,200 box of 2026 football cards to compare their value returns. The basketball box yields rookie cards from Mitchell Robinson and Michael Porter Jr., plus an Isaac Banga autograph numbered to 8, while the football box produces multiple rookie autographs and special insert cards.
Giving Away $50,000 in Cards From My BEST Box Break ๐คฏ
A card collector opened an exceptionally valuable box of Topps Transcendent trading cards, pulling two Shohei Ohtani patch autos and hitting multiple super factors. They are giving away all the cards from this box break and inviting viewers to join Cards HQ streams on Whatnot this weekend for a chance to win.