DiscussionInsightful

Trevor's Pirate Obsession | Smosh Mouth 153

SmoshCast

Trevor Evers joins Smosh Mouth to discuss his passion for pirate history, covering the golden age of piracy (1650-1730), famous pirates like Blackbeard and Ann Bonny, the pirate code, and how popular media has romanticized and sometimes fabricated pirate tropes. The conversation explores real historical accounts versus fictional portrayals and the surprisingly democratic nature of pirate crews.

Summary

In this extended episode of Smosh Mouth, Trevor Evers celebrates his birthday by diving deep into pirate history with hosts Shane and Amanda. The discussion begins with an overview of the golden age of piracy, divided into three eras: the buccaneering era (1650-early 1700s), the pirate round period, and the post-Spanish succession period (1710s). Trevor explains how European nations, particularly England, used privateeers with letters of mark to disrupt Spain's dominance in the New World without directly engaging in expensive naval warfare. When peace broke out, these privateeers defaulted back to being pirates, leading to the most famous and romanticized period of piracy. The conversation covers the pirate round period, when pirates operated in the Indian Ocean targeting British East India Company ships and Mughal Empire treasure vessels, with Henry Every famously plundering the emperor's personal treasure ship worth an estimated 150-200 million pounds in modern currency. Trevor discusses famous pirates including Bartholomew Roberts (who captured over 400 ships), Blackbeard (who operated for only two years), and the female pirates Ann Bonny and Mary Reed, who discovered each other's true gender aboard ship and became legendary for their fierceness in battle. A significant portion covers the pirate code, which established surprisingly democratic systems: captains received two shares of plunder alongside quartermasters and bosuns, regular crew members voted on captains and could remove them through democratic process, and injured crew members received workers compensation (800 pieces of eight for lost limbs). The discussion addresses how much of modern pirate lore comes from fictional sources, particularly Robert Louis Stevenson's "Treasure Island," which invented tropes like the pirate accent, X marks the spot treasure maps, and buried treasure itself (historically only William Kidd buried treasure as a bargaining chip). The hosts note that Ching Xi, a Chinese pirate operating 1801-1810, commanded the largest pirate fleet in history with approximately 400 junks and 40,000-70,000 pirates. They discuss the brutal realities of pirate life including disease, storms, shipwrecks, and the surprisingly good conditions compared to naval service. The episode includes discussions of the show Black Sails as an accurate modern portrayal of pirate life, medieval diving techniques using diving bells, and how pirate attacks involved broadside cannon fire followed by boarding with hooks and gangplanks. The conversation concludes with the hosts imagining which historical eras they'd like to observe with protective bubbles, with discussions of ancient Egypt, Greece, and Mesopotamia alongside the pirate era.

Key Insights

  • The golden age of piracy lasted only 80 years (1650-1730) and was driven by European nations using privateers with letters of mark to avoid expensive naval warfare against Spain in the New World without directly engaging in conflict.
  • Pirate ships operated under democratic systems where crews could vote to remove captains, demote them to crew positions, or even kill them if they were incompetent, with the quartermaster serving as representative of crew interests and holding significant power.
  • Only one historically recorded instance exists of a pirate burying treasure—William Kidd buried treasure as a bargaining chip against execution, meaning most pirate treasures were likely spent or lost in shipwrecks rather than hidden on land.
  • Many iconic pirate tropes including the pirate accent, X marks the spot treasure maps, and the concept of buried treasure were invented or heavily embellished by Robert Louis Stevenson in 'Treasure Island' and became accepted as historical fact.
  • Ching Xi, a Chinese female pirate operating from 1801-1810, commanded approximately 400 junks and between 40,000-70,000 pirates, making her fleet the largest pirate force in history, operating during a different era than the famous Caribbean pirates.

Topics

Golden Age of Piracy (1650-1730)Privateers and Letters of MarkPirate Code and Democratic Crew StructureFamous Pirates: Blackbeard, Ann Bonny, Mary Reed, Bartholomew Roberts, Henry EveryFemale Pirates in HistoryPirate Romanticism in Fiction vs Historical RealityNaval Warfare and Ship CombatPirate Life Conditions and MortalityThe Pirate Round and Indian Ocean Trade RoutesModern Piracy Depictions in Media

Transcript

[0:01] Ohoy. Welcome to Smoshmouth. I'm Shane. >> I matey. I'm Amanda. And we have a very special weary traveler on our ship with us today. His name is Trevor Evers. >> What do you mean weary traveler? I be the captain of this ship. >> What? >> You have the most Spongebob uh pirate voice. >> You're not the captain. That's crazy. >> Spongebob me boy. I That's the captain there. >> So what am I? You're the [ __ ] [laughter] >> WHOA. WHOA. NONE OF US. >> HEY, don't act like it's not happening [0:32] on these ships. If a woman is brought on these ships, WHAT'S HAPPENING THERE? SHE'S NOT a captain. I wish >> right.…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from SmoshCast

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.