"Ike Barinholtz"
Ike Barinholtz joins SmartLess to discuss his comedy career journey from Boston University to Second City, MADtv, The Mindy Project, and recent success with The Studio. He covers his improv origins, collaborations with major comedic talents, work-life balance as a father of three, and his new trivia podcast.
Summary
The episode features an extended conversation with actor and comedian Ike Barinholtz. After opening segments with ads and banter about couch positioning and TV watching habits, Ike becomes the featured guest. He recounts growing up in Chicago's Uptown neighborhood near Wrigley Field in what was historically a gay neighborhood. Ike explains that he initially studied political science at Boston University but struggled with the freedom, engaging in excessive drug use and watching films repeatedly before being expelled mid-semester. His parents discovered his academic dismissal through a letter while he was returning from a vacation his father had planned as a reward. Rather than pursue a traditional path, Ike became involved in Chicago's improv scene, studying at Improv Olympic with Del Close and eventually working at Second City as a busboy while watching future stars like Tina Fey and Scott Adsit perform. He moved to Los Angeles with Seth Meyers, Josh Meyers, and others, working as a busboy before being cast on MADtv where he spent five years alongside Jordan Peele and others. He notes that SNL's cast during 2002-2008 was incredibly strong and that MADtv struggled with comparison, leading him to pursue sitcom work after leaving the show. After a three-and-a-half-year dry spell without work, Ike was cast by Danny McBride on Eastbound & Down, which he describes as his first experience working on a show he was a devoted fan of. This led to a long run on The Mindy Project with Mindy Kaling, doing six seasons with 22 episodes yearly. He's since created Running Point with Mindy Kaling and writing partner Dave Stasson, and currently stars in The Studio with Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg, which filmed in Venice with Madonna. Ike has three daughters (ages 8, 10, and soon 13) and discusses the challenges of work-life balance while away filming. He reveals he recently started a trivia podcast called "Funny You Ask" where he writes custom trivia questions for comedy and entertainment guests, then answers questions written by his producer Annabelle. Ike won Celebrity Jeopardy and Who Wants to Be a Millionaire. The hosts quiz him on trivia covering historical events, American car companies, Marx Brothers, Canadian geography, U.S. presidents, Emmy winners, London landmarks, NHL records, and insect terminology. He mentions he slows down through yoga and watching quality television shows like Beef Season 2 with his wife. Throughout the conversation, the hosts express genuine affection for Ike, with Will noting that Ike is always happy to see, consistently shows up on time, is respectful, and is fundamentally a good person—qualities they argue matter more than pure talent in hiring.
About this episode
Keep talking to the hand— it’s our friend Ike Barinholtz. Hustling, trivia, college, bottle-service, true mirrors, and a Southwest flight home. “Hey guys, where did you go?” It’s an all-new SmartLess.
Key Insights
- Ike initially aspired to be a politician through political science at Boston University, but left the program mid-semester after struggling with excessive freedom and engaging in drug use
- The Chicago improv scene of the 1990s produced an exceptional generation of comedians including Amy Poehler, Seth Meyers, and others who studied under Del Close at Improv Olympic
- After leaving MADtv due to restlessness despite being on a successful show, Ike experienced a three-and-a-half-year period without work, demonstrating the unpredictable nature of entertainment careers
- Ike's first major dramatic experience working on a show he loved (Eastbound & Down with Danny McBride) created significant pressure to perform as a supporting actor rather than a lead
- The Mindy Project required producing 22 episodes per year for six seasons, a much more demanding workload than contemporary television production models
- Ike discusses his specific ritual of laying perpendicular on couches while watching television, which he creates in every location including hotel rooms and rental apartments
- Ike attributes his career longevity to being respectful, on time, and fundamentally a good person to work with, rather than solely relying on comedic talent
- The trivia podcast 'Funny You Ask' allows Ike to interview friends and explore their knowledge across diverse subjects, demonstrating his passion for trivia beyond entertainment
Topics
Transcript
Did you ever notice the best deals are just obvious? Like Hotels.com. What do they do, you may ask? Hotels on the internet. And a lot of them, like hundreds of thousands. I don't know why I just turned into Sean Hayes. Plus, if you join for free, you can save up to 20% instantly with member prices, and you earn rewards every time you book so your next trip basically starts paying for itself it's simple and you get more out of every stay sign up for free and book today hotels.com it's all in the name get your home ready inside and out with Lowe's July 4th Deals Event. Save up to 45% off select major appliances, plus…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from SmartLess
"Seth Meyers"
Seth Meyers joins the Smartless podcast to discuss his comedy career journey from Northwestern University through Second City, Saturday Night Live, and ultimately to hosting The Late Show. He reflects on how mentorship from Mike Shoemaker shaped his understanding of comedy writing and performing, and explains how his Update experience prepared him for late-night television.
"Benny Blanco"
Benny Blanco joins the Smartless podcast to discuss his journey from a kid in Virginia cold-calling record labels to becoming one of pop music's most successful producers and songwriters. He credits his success to relentless hustle, networking, and a willingness to learn on the job while working with titans like Dr. Luke and Max Martin, ultimately landing hits for artists like Britney Spears, Rihanna, and Ed Sheeran.
"RE-RELEASE: Matthew Rhys"
Matthew Rhys, a Welsh actor known for The Americans and Perry Mason, joins the Smartless podcast to discuss his career trajectory from theater to television, his relationship with Kerry Russell, and his experience working with Robert Downey Jr. on the Perry Mason reboot. The conversation touches on his Welsh heritage, early theater experiences, and the challenges of balancing family life with demanding acting careers.
"Sharon Horgan"
Sharon Horgan joins the SmartLess podcast to discuss her career trajectory from working in employment services to becoming an acclaimed writer, producer, and performer. She shares insights about the creative process, challenges with auditioning, managing actors' interpretations of her writing, and her upcoming HBO series Youth premiering September 20th.
"Andrew Garfield"
Andrew Garfield joins the SmartLess podcast to discuss his acting career, upcoming projects including The Uprising and playing Sam Altman in an AI film, and shares deeply personal stories about his relationship with his father, grief, and the transformative power of theater and community in his life.