You’re Not a Stoic If You Do This 😳
The speaker clarifies that stoicism is not about suppressing emotions or becoming emotionless, but rather about processing emotions consciously and deciding whether to assent to them. True stoicism involves creating distance between yourself and your thoughts to determine if a reaction is helpful or harmful.
Summary
The speaker begins by sharing a personal experience of bottling up emotions when leaving contracting work, noting that many people mistakenly interpreted this behavior as stoicism. He then corrects this common misconception by explaining what stoicism actually is. The speaker emphasizes that stoicism is fundamentally misunderstood as being robotic or emotionless, when in reality it's about emotional processing rather than emotional suppression. The core of stoicism, according to the speaker, involves creating psychological distance between yourself and your thoughts. He references Marcus Aurelius's Meditations as a philosophical framework, clarifying that it's not a magical formula that instantly eliminates problems upon hearing it. Instead, stoicism is a practice of pausing, thinking through situations, and deliberately choosing whether to assent to or accept your emotional reactions. The speaker frames this as an active, deliberate process of working through emotions rather than either bottling them up or being controlled by them.
Key Insights
- The speaker claims that people commonly mistake bottling up emotions for stoicism when he exhibited emotional suppression early in his career
- The speaker argues that stoicism is widely misconceived as being robotic and emotionless, involving stuffing down feelings, when that's fundamentally not what it is
- The speaker contends that stoicism's core principle is creating distance between oneself and one's thoughts to evaluate emotional responses
- The speaker claims that Marcus Aurelius's Meditations is not a magical formula that prevents problems, but rather a framework for practicing deliberate thought
- The speaker asserts that stoicism requires pausing, thinking through situations, and making a conscious decision whether to assent to an emotional response
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] When I first left contracting [music] for the ages, I bottled everything up. A lot of people thought I was stoic. >> It's not bottling it up. When we go, "Oh, that guy is really stoic." [music] We take that to mean he doesn't feel anything. He's a robot. He stuffs it down. And that's not what it is at all. To me, it's about processing that emotion, asking yourself, "Hey, is losing my about [music] this helping anything, or is it in fact making the situation worse?" Basically, what stoicism is at its core [music] is this kind of distance between you and your thoughts. So, what Marcus Aurelius is doing in the Meditations is not like [0:30]…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Shawn Ryan Show
Bush Got Lucky. Saudi Sandal Throwers Never Miss 😂
The speaker describes young Saudi men's exceptional skill at throwing sandals as weapons from significant distances (20-30 yards), noting that their hard leather sandals have blade-like edges that can inflict considerable pain upon impact, comparable to being hit by a plate.
The Black Hawk Down Pilot Who Wouldn't Leave His Rangers 😳
A Vietnam veteran reflects on the Black Hawk Down incident in Somalia, praising the extraordinary courage of helicopter pilots, particularly Dan Schilling, who kept his damaged aircraft airborne to ensure all Rangers could safely descend before crashing. The speaker emphasizes that unified command structure and pilot commitment were critical factors despite the mission's tragic outcome.
Why Doctors Put Bicycle Spokes in a Army Ranger's Leg 😳
An Army Ranger describes surviving a catastrophic leg injury requiring the Ilizarov apparatus, a Russian-invented device using bicycle spokes to stabilize shattered bone. Through innovative bone grafting and years of rehabilitation, he regained full mobility and returned to active infantry duty.
Cartel Fighters Brought THIS Home From Ukraine 😳
A speaker discusses their observations of the International Legion in Ukraine, which includes volunteers from various countries and notably former cartel and FARC fighters from Colombia. These Colombian combatants have returned home with drone warfare expertise and are allegedly using these skills to attack Colombian government and intelligence targets.
Black Hawk Down Had a Hidden Al-Qaeda Connection 😳
A firsthand account from a soldier during the Black Hawk Down incident in Somalia describes calling in sniper support, discovering that Al-Qaeda operatives trained by Osama bin Laden were assisting warlord Aidid with modified weapons, and witnessing the downing of a Black Hawk helicopter by a modified grenade launcher, after which survivors immediately engaged in combat.