True Crime Investigator's Scariest Interaction with a Murder Suspect in Alaska
A true crime investigator describes his undercover operation to investigate a murder suspect named Oregon John in Alaska, where he posed as a fake Facebook user to gain the suspect's trust, eventually arranging a polygraph test that the suspect failed twice while admitting to withholding information from law enforcement.
Summary
The investigator recounts his investigation into the disappearance of Florence Oil, a Native Alaskan woman last seen with a man nicknamed Oregon John, who had a lengthy criminal history including animal cruelty, rape, and assault. The investigator located Oregon John in Ketchikan, Alaska, working on cargo ships with unusual schedules. Rather than attempt direct confrontation, which had yielded poor results in past cases, the investigator created a fake Facebook account with a believable backstory. He messaged Oregon John under the guise of a young man from Kodiak interested in becoming a certified seaman, eventually arranging an in-person meeting at a bar in Alaska. The investigator flew to Ketchikan with a friend as backup and surveillance team, where Oregon John arrived at the bar. During their three-hour conversation, the investigator repeatedly circled back to questions about the missing woman, with Oregon John eventually making implausible statements and blaming another person. Midway through the encounter, Oregon John expressed suspicion, saying he initially thought the investigator might be "this podcast guy," but had not yet Googled him. The investigator deflected and continued the charade. Four months later, the investigator revealed his true identity to Oregon John via a rescheduled McDonald's delivery, apologized for the deception, and offered him a platform to clear his name. Oregon John agreed to take a polygraph test, which the investigator arranged in Portland, Oregon by flying him from Ketchikan and maintaining operational security about their true locations. During the polygraph, Oregon John failed twice and notably admitted on one question that he had not been completely truthful with law enforcement about his involvement in Florence's disappearance. The investigator emphasizes this admission as the most valuable information gathered. The investigator expresses ongoing concern about the case given Alaska's limited investigative resources, though notes the FBI has recently taken both cases seriously.
Key Insights
- The investigator found that creating elaborate undercover personas was more effective than direct confrontation with suspects, as past attempts at direct engagement resulted only in short angry exchanges or refusals to cooperate
- Oregon John remained unsuspicious of the fake Facebook account for months because he interpreted the investigator's interest in his newly obtained seaman certification as normal social engagement, responding positively to being asked about his accomplishments
- When Oregon John grew suspicious and mentioned the possibility that the investigator was a podcast figure, the investigator had not actually been Googled by the suspect yet, as he had only recently learned about the investigator through another woman
- During the polygraph test, Oregon John failed twice but critically admitted on one specific question about truthfulness to law enforcement that he answered yes, meaning he had withheld information from police about his involvement in the disappearance
- The investigator maintained significant security protocols for the polygraph meeting, booking multiple hotel rooms and an Airbnb unknown to the suspect, and stationed himself outside the interview ready to intervene if needed due to concerns about his team's safety
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] What's the scariest interaction you've had with a murder suspect? A man with the [music] nickname Oregon John. This guy had the same long bad rap sheet. I mean, animal cruelty assault. I knew that this was the last person to see Florence alive. He admitted that she was in his tent and then she just vanishes off this beach. I located this man and I did something that I've never done before. I pretended to be somebody else. Organ [music] John walks in the bar and he goes, "You know [0:30] what? To be honest, I thought you might be this podcast guy." Holy. This this native woman, she disappeared. And she was last seen with a man…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Shawn Ryan Show
The Largest Pyramid Ever Found in St. Louis 🤯
The Mississippian civilization built Cahokia, a sophisticated city outside St. Louis featuring a massive pyramid covering eight football fields at its base, with a population of around 50,000 people in the region. The civilization demonstrated advanced engineering capabilities including hydraulic systems, but these achievements are often overlooked because their structures were built from earth rather than stone.
How Do You Find a 30,000-Year-Old Turd?! 🤯
The transcript discusses coprolites—fossilized feces—and how archaeologists extract DNA from ancient fecal matter that can be tens of thousands of years old. Rather than decomposing into dirt, fecal matter preserved in anaerobic cave environments can mineralize into rock, allowing DNA extraction by laboratory scientists.
What If Epstein Left His Cell Alive? 😳
The transcript presents a conspiracy theory claiming Jeffrey Epstein left his prison cell alive, arguing that authorities presented a false choice between suicide and murder to control the narrative around his death. The speaker suggests a hyoid bone fracture controversy and the official hanging conclusion were deliberately used to distract from a third, unstated option.
WW2 Enemies Meet After Iwo Jima 😳
A WWII veteran recounts an encounter with a Japanese family after the war, where he reveals his identity as someone who fought at Iwo Jima. The family's reaction—initially surprise, then apparent acceptance—reflects the complex emotions between former enemies. The speaker references the significant casualties from the battle, suggesting the weight of this meeting.
1,770 Nukes Are Ready to Launch Right Now 🤯
The transcript discusses U.S. nuclear deterrence policy, explaining that 1,770 nuclear weapons are currently ready for immediate launch, with the president having only minutes to make a counterattack decision under the 'launch on warning' policy. It contrasts current arsenals with historical peaks, noting the U.S. has significantly reduced its stockpile from a Cold War high of 10,070 warheads in 1986.