StoryDiscussion

Payne Lindsey - “He Was the First Monster I Ever Really Encountered” | SRS #357

Shawn Ryan Show

Payne Lindsey, creator of the true crime podcast Up and Vanished, discusses his journey from filmmaker to investigative journalist, detailing his work on multiple cold cases including Tara Grindstead's disappearance in Georgia, cases in Colorado and Montana, and his experiences with dangerous suspects. The conversation also explores his spiritual transformation, encounters with the paranormal, and beliefs about UFOs and higher power.

Summary

Payne Lindsey started as a broke freelance filmmaker who created Up and Vanished as a proof-of-concept podcast after watching HBO's The Jinx. The podcast unexpectedly became a phenomenon with 800 million downloads, leading to the arrest of suspects in Tara Grindstead's 11-year-old cold case within six months of its first episode. However, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation appeared to rush to judgment, arresting Ryan Duke based on an incoherent drug-fueled confession while missing evidence pointing toward Bo Dukes, who confessed to burning Tara's body and later committed violent crimes including rape and assault with a gun. Despite Ryan Duke's acquittal, the case remains unsolved.

Lindsey has since investigated cases in Colorado (Crystal Risinger's disappearance, involving a suspect called 'Catfish John'), Montana (Ashley Luring HeavyRunner on the Black Feet Reservation), and Alaska (Florence Oil's disappearance involving 'Oregon John'). These investigations revealed patterns of narcissistic criminals who enjoyed the podcast attention, dangerous individuals with histories of violence, and systemic failures in law enforcement and tribal jurisdiction. He developed a methodology of appearing unannounced to suspects, initially with a documentary filmmaker's approach rather than confrontational interrogation.

A significant turning point occurred during a psychedelic experience and subsequent trip to Sedona, Arizona, where Lindsey experienced what he describes as a profound divine intervention. A stranger read his mind regarding internal conflicts about gender ideology and other topics he hadn't vocalized, his wife's father (whom he'd recently bonded with) died before the trip, his daughter reached out through the deceased's phone, and a priest's homily the next morning directly addressed his spiritual struggle about loving family more than Christ. This experience led him to Catholicism and regular Mass attendance, fundamentally shifting his worldview away from politics, crystals, and energy vortexes toward Christian faith.

Lindsey and Ryan Smith also discussed paranormal experiences, UFO sightings, and spiritual phenomena. Smith shared experiences of unexplained sounds in an old Massachusetts house (footsteps on stairs) and a Civil War cabin with cowboy boot sounds and electrical anomalies. Both discussed the credibility of military pilots' UFO testimonies, the Seraphim angels' appearance in biblical texts versus modern UFO descriptions, and theories about interdimensional beings versus extraterrestrial aliens. Smith described his own spiritual awakening triggered by a psychedelic experience revealing what he perceived as hell, leading him to daily Mass and discovering coinciding scripture readings.

Key Insights

  • Payne Lindsey claims the Georgia Bureau of Investigation appeared to follow his investigative leads in real-time, including searching a crawl space for Tara Grindstead's body shortly after he independently received a tip and searched the same location, suggesting law enforcement was reacting to the podcast rather than conducting independent investigation
  • Lindsey argues that his greatest advantage in interviewing suspects and witnesses is appearing as a non-threatening, relatable person rather than law enforcement, which makes people more willing to divulge information and creates an atmosphere of comfort rather than interrogation
  • In the Crystal Risinger case, the suspect 'Catfish John' exhibited simultaneous narcissistic engagement with the podcast (wanting to be discussed) and defensive anger when confronted, demonstrating a pattern where criminals relish notoriety while claiming innocence
  • Lindsey describes his Sedona experience as a divine intervention where a stranger read his mind about internal conflicts he hadn't vocalized, his recently deceased friend's daughter reached out the same day, and the next morning's church homily directly addressed his exact spiritual struggle, which he interprets as undeniable evidence of God's communication
  • Both Lindsey and Ryan Smith argue that paranormal phenomena and UFO sightings may represent interdimensional beings or spiritual entities rather than extraterrestrial aliens, with religious concepts like Seraphim angels resembling modern UFO descriptions, suggesting overlap between religious and paranormal experiences

Topics

True Crime Podcasting and Investigative JournalismCold Cases: Tara Grindstead, Crystal Risinger, Ashley Luring HeavyRunner, Florence OilLaw Enforcement Failures and Jurisdictional IssuesSuspect Psychology and NarcissismSpiritual Awakening and Religious ConversionParanormal and Unexplained PhenomenaUFO Sightings and Extraterrestrial TheoriesDivine Intervention and SynchronicityDangerous Undercover Investigation Techniques

Transcript

[0:05] Pay Lindsay Sean Ryan. >> Welcome to the show, man. >> So, dude, nice nice shades. >> Okay, the story is my buddy bet me 50 bucks I wouldn't put them on. So, I'm trying to collect. >> So, gotcha. >> There you go, man. 50 bucks richer. >> Yep. It's all took to collect. Well, dude, you've been digging in up some crazy [ __ ] Like, whoa. >> Going through the outline. I was like, [0:36] damn, dude. So, we got a lot of stuff to cover. >> We do. All right. I'm going to give you a very brief introduction here. Pay Lindsay, you're the creator and host of Up and Vanished, the true crime podcast…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Shawn Ryan Show

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.