Expat Insurance Expert Phil Eitman on the Nosara Podcast
Phil Eitman, an insurance broker with 18 years of experience in Costa Rica, discusses comprehensive insurance solutions for expats including health, home, car, and estate planning. He emphasizes the critical difference between Costa Rica's public healthcare system (CAJA) and private healthcare, warning that public care involves long wait times and potential serious health consequences.
Summary
Phil Eitman shares his journey moving to Costa Rica 18 years ago after a financial setback, finding happiness in the local culture and deciding to stay. He discovered international health insurance when his daughter moved down to finish high school, which became the foundation for his insurance business covering approximately 3,000 policies across multiple categories.
On health insurance, Phil emphasizes that international health insurance costs roughly 40% of US premiums while covering both Costa Rica and the US. He provides two compelling examples: a woman who had a $525,000 head-on collision claim covered except for her deductible, and a man who received back surgery in Houston through his plan. He stresses the critical importance of private health insurance over the public CAJA system, which is known for extremely long wait times (citing an example of an 8-month wait for surgery and an appointment scheduled for July 2028). Phil warns that relying on public healthcare can result in serious consequences including blindness from untreated infections.
Regarding home insurance, Phil explains that construction costs approximately $200 per year per $100,000 in value, so a $1 million house costs roughly $2,000 annually. Coverage includes fire, tsunami, earthquakes, and fallen trees, but excludes maintenance-related damage. Unlike the US, Costa Rica is not litigious, so liability policies are much lower ($100,000-$200,000 versus $1 million in the States), and Phil reports never seeing a liability claim in 15 years.
For car insurance, he recommends full coverage for vehicles worth over $15,000-$17,000 (costing $800-$1,500 annually depending on value), and at minimum roadside assistance for cheaper vehicles. He also mentions coverage for motorcycles, construction vehicles, and commercial insurance. Phil and his wife additionally provide legal services including wills, trusts, and estates planning.
The conversation also touches on broader Nosara community issues, including the tension between tourism development and local preservation, the farmers market on Tuesdays, comparisons between Nosara and Tamarindo, and Phil's new standup comedy venture. He emphasizes the importance of community members "chipping in" through donations, volunteerism, and support for local businesses and conservation efforts. Phil compares Nosara favorably to Tamarindo, describing it as a more secluded, chic beach town less affected by surrounding larger population centers.
Key Insights
- Phil handled a $525,000 head-on collision claim in the US where the insured woman only paid her deductible because he coordinated directly with the insurance company, hospital, and obtained payment guarantee letters, demonstrating that comprehensive international coverage can eliminate catastrophic financial exposure for expats
- Costa Rica's public CAJA healthcare system has severe wait times, with Phil citing examples including 8-month waits for surgery and appointments scheduled years in advance (July 2028), making private health insurance critical for reliable medical access
- Home insurance in Costa Rica is calculated at approximately $200 per year per $100,000 of construction value (not land value), so insurance cost is independent of whether a house is worth $2 million in a valley or $5 million on the beach
- Costa Rica is fundamentally non-litigious compared to the US, exemplified by insurance companies viewing accidents through a lens of fault-finding (e.g., 'did the school cause it?') rather than automatic liability assumption, resulting in much lower recommended liability coverage amounts
- Phil attributes part of Nosara's success to its geographic isolation with no large surrounding population centers, unlike Tamarindo which is surrounded by towns like Santa Cruz and Burial, making it harder for Nosara to suffer from city sprawl problems and excessive density
Topics
Transcript
[0:05] Phil, welcome to Noara podcast. It's good to have you in. >> Thank you, man. >> You cover a lot of ground here and I've known you a lot a long time as a client. Also sent you a bunch of people and insurance is just something people have questions about whether it's their home, their car, their health, their life, just all these different things. Just tell us real quick. Let's start with a 30 or 60 second overview of who you are and your wide range of services and then we can talk about each one and whatever. >> All right, cool. So, I'm Phil. How you doing, Phil Lightman? I moved down here [0:36] about 18…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Rich Burnam
Protect nature areas on your property in perpetuity
This transcript discusses a wildlife corridor initiative in Nosara, Costa Rica, where landowners can permanently protect portions of their property for conservation. The program has already added 35 acres to conservation in perpetuity, and speakers argue Nosara could serve as a global model for balancing development with nature preservation. The initiative is framed as a community-unifying cause, rooted in the area's unique history of failed development and sea turtle conservation.
Nitzan Solan on wastewater treatment in Nosara
Nitzan Solan discusses his background in chemical engineering and its focus on wastewater treatment. He has been researching the field extensively and connecting with relevant projects and companies. He feels the time is right to begin taking action on wastewater treatment in Nosara.
How Andy became ‘Longboard Andy’
Andy discusses how he got into longboarding, crediting a person nicknamed 'Cheetah' (Marcelo) for introducing him to the sport. He reflects on how longboarding was not considered cool in the past but has gained popularity more recently. The transcript cuts off as Andy begins describing the excitement of feeling like a beginner.
Costa Rica invented the word ecotourism, but has no plan b
A speaker claims that Costa Rica invented the term 'ecotourism' and that the country's economy is heavily dependent on foreign investment and tourism. They express concern that there is no alternative economic plan if this reliance were to fail.
Coconut Harry’s Board Swap Saturday in Nosara, Costa Rica Episode 4
Coconut Harry hosts Episode 4 of Board Swap Saturday in Nosara, Costa Rica, revisiting two surfboards — a beloved Ricky Carol and a previously disliked WRV. He experiments with fin setups, particularly removing fins to loosen up boards, and ends the session riding one of his original longboards after exhausting himself.