i raised my prices 20% expecting to lose customers and lost almost none
A small business owner shared their experience of raising prices 20% and retaining almost all customers, contrary to their fears. The community largely validated this outcome, with broad agreement that business owners typically overestimate customer price sensitivity, and that pricing increases often signal quality rather than damage business relationships.
Summary
The original post describes years of undercharging due to fear of losing customers, followed by a bold 20% price increase that resulted in only two complaints and no actual departures. The poster notes that remaining customers began treating the work more seriously, suggesting the higher price communicated professional value.
The community response was predominantly supportive and confirmatory. Multiple commenters shared their own experiences of successful price increases, including one user who systematically raised prices 10% quarterly while tracking close ratios, eventually settling at a much higher price point (75-80% closing ratio dropping to 22-26%) while becoming more profitable and selective about clients. Another commenter noted that when their father's decades-old family business finally raised prices after 20+ years, only one customer noticed—and that customer said it was overdue.
Several commenters articulated key economic principles underlying this phenomenon. One contributor explained the asymmetrical math: a 20% price increase flows entirely to profit margins (assuming fixed costs), so if profit margins are 40%, a 20% price hike yields approximately 50% profit growth—meaning most customers need to stay for the increase to pay off. Another noted that lower prices can paradoxically reduce customer trust and signal lower quality, particularly in service industries like tourism.
The community also discussed strategic approaches: one commenter described offering current customers a grace period at the old price before implementing increases, ensuring customers feel rewarded rather than surprised. Another emphasized the value of gradual annual adjustments over sudden large increases for maintaining customer perception of fairness.
Notable counterarguments emerged. One skeptical commenter cautioned that the outcome is too recent to evaluate, and that customers may silently explore alternatives without openly complaining. They argued that sudden 20% increases can be perceived as arbitrary pricing rather than justified value increases, and that gradual annual adjustments are preferable. Another raised the concern that lower historical pricing may indicate the work can be done more cheaply by competitors, creating vulnerability if new market entrants offer lower rates.
A third critical voice suggested that losing some customers is actually beneficial, as price-sensitive departures typically eliminate the most demanding, energy-draining clients—reframing attrition as a form of client quality filtering.
About this episode
i undercharged for years out of fear. every time i thought about raising prices i pictured customers walking, so i stayed cheap and quietly resented the work. this year i finally raised everything about twenty percent. i braced for a wave of cancellations. what actually happened: two people grumbled, nobody left, and the customers who stayed treated me a little more seriously, like the price signaled i knew my worth. the fear was doing more damage than the price ever would. for small busin...
Key Insights
- A 20% price increase flows entirely to profit margins (unlike discounts), so profit increases disproportionately more than the percentage increase—if margins are 40%, a 20% hike yields ~50% profit growth, meaning most customers only need to stay for the math to work
- Lower prices can paradoxically reduce trust and signal lower quality to customers, particularly in service industries, inverting the business owner's assumption that cheap = accessible
- One commenter's experience: systematically raising prices 10% quarterly while tracking metrics revealed that their close ratio dropped from 75-80% to 22-26%, but profitability increased significantly while allowing them to reject problem clients
- A family business that hadn't raised prices in 20+ years found only one customer noticed the increase—and that customer affirmed it was overdue, suggesting customers may actually expect regular adjustments
- A skeptical commenter cautioned that silent customer dissatisfaction may not emerge immediately, and that sudden large increases (vs. gradual annual ones) risk being perceived as arbitrary rather than justified, potentially making customers more receptive to competitor switching
Topics
Transcript
[Original Post] (score: 104, upvote ratio: 95%, by u/Odd_Report6798) Title: i raised my prices 20% expecting to lose customers and lost almost none i undercharged for years out of fear. every time i thought about raising prices i pictured customers walking, so i stayed cheap and quietly resented the work. this year i finally raised everything about twenty percent. i braced for a wave of cancellations. what actually happened: two people grumbled, nobody left, and the customers who stayed treated me a little more seriously, like the price signaled i knew my worth. the fear was doing more damage than the price ever would. for small business owners who raised prices: did you lose the customers you feared, or did…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from r/smallbusiness
I had to fire a guy today, 4 days after his wife was diagnosed with cancer. People suck. I suck.
A small business owner fired an underperforming employee who had lied about his qualifications and caused significant financial losses, only 4 days after the employee's wife was diagnosed with cancer. The community was divided between those who saw it as a justified business decision and those who questioned the timing, the owner's hiring/management practices, and whether the cancer diagnosis was even legitimate.
I interviewed someone for a position at my bakery and they left a negative review on Google after I didn't hire them.
A bakery owner received a retaliatory negative review from a rejected job applicant. The community overwhelmingly agreed that a public, factual reply combined with a formal Google appeal citing conflict-of-interest policies is the most effective response, with most commenters emphasizing transparency and calm professionalism over passive reporting alone.
Facing burn out after almost 22 years
A 45-year-old service business owner working 7 days a week for 22 years sought advice on scaling his profitable but solo-dependent business. The community consensus emphasized that without the ability to operate without him, he owns a job rather than a business, and recommended prioritizing price increases, process documentation, and selective hiring of part-time help before pursuing full-time employees.