I left society
A 22-year-old posts about abandoning their functional family and society to live as a homeless vagabond, claiming happiness through rejecting the capitalist system. The community is largely skeptical, with commenters questioning the logic of cutting off family, pointing out the contradiction of using society's products while rejecting society, and expressing concern about the sustainability and wisdom of the decision.
Summary
The original post presents a philosophical critique of modern capitalism and societal structure, arguing that humans are engineered into wage slavery through systems like healthcare-linked employment and the two-party political system. The poster claims they've achieved greater happiness through homelessness and dumpster-diving than they ever experienced in their functional family home. However, the community response is overwhelmingly critical on several fronts. Multiple commenters question why the poster would sever ties with a loving, non-abusive family if their issue is with systemic problems rather than their personal circumstances (u/gabbidog, u/Fayraz8729, u/Rafalo57). Others point out the logical contradiction in the poster's position: u/marcusdipaola notes that the backpack, jug, and other visible items come from the capitalist society being rejected. Several commenters express concern for the poster's wellbeing and decision-making, with u/the-bug-guy suggesting the poster needs help, u/Orangutanion warning about the real dangers of freight train hopping with a specific example (Stobe the Hobo), and u/jesusgrandpa noting the poster appears to have an injury. A few commenters are supportive or sympathetic (u/Falcor_IRL, u/Crimson_Boomerang), with u/Crimson_Boomerang offering a balanced perspective that validates the desire to step away while suggesting constructive re-engagement later. The community largely views this as idealistic but practically unwise, with some seeing it as performative rebellion rather than genuine systemic critique.
About this episode
Im 22, and I just cut off my family. I hitchhiked a few hundred miles away from my home and now im about to hop a freight train south. No, i did not come from an abusive household, it was actually rather functional. My reasoning is because I feel that society has a real problem, and I see through the bullshit. We were made to wake up with the sun, our purpose was to hunt for our food and provide for our tribe. Now we wake up to an alarm we set because an employer told us so, we work jobs we h...
Key Insights
- Multiple commenters point out the logical inconsistency: the poster criticizes society while relying on its products (backpack, water jug, medical devices), suggesting their 'exit' from society is illusory rather than genuine.
- u/gabbidog and others identify a category error in the post: cutting off a functional, loving family conflates personal family relationships with systemic critique, harming people who aren't responsible for the systems being rejected.
- u/Orangutanion provides a practical safety concern rooted in real tragedy (Stobe the Hobo's death), suggesting that ideological commitment to rejecting society doesn't protect against material dangers.
- u/Crimson_Boomerang offers a nuanced counterpoint, validating the desire for freedom while suggesting that re-engagement with constructive fields (nonprofits, social work, politics) might better achieve the poster's stated goal of systemic change.
- u/Itchy_Stick7579 raises a political insight: by removing oneself from society entirely, the poster also removes their capacity to vote or participate in the democratic processes needed to actually change the systems they critique.
Topics
Transcript
[Original Post] (score: 67, upvote ratio: 85%, by u/Key-Cicada-3718) Title: I left society Link: https://i.redd.it/9c77n7zyy9wh1.jpeg Im 22, and I just cut off my family. I hitchhiked a few hundred miles away from my home and now im about to hop a freight train south. No, i did not come from an abusive household, it was actually rather functional. My reasoning is because I feel that society has a real problem, and I see through the bullshit. We were made to wake up with the sun, our purpose was to hunt for our food and provide for our tribe. Now we wake up to an alarm we set because an employer told us so, we work jobs we hate because theβ¦
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from r/GenZ
The kids are alright (and pissed off)
A post highlighting youth-led global protests sparked discussion about generational activism and disruptive protest tactics. Commenters generally supported young people "standing up for themselves," though disagreed on specific movements and methods, with some defending property destruction as necessary activism while others criticized vandalism.
French police officers caught looting a store
A video showing French police officers looting a store sparked minimal discussion in this thread. The limited comments suggest skepticism about mainstream media narratives and some dark humor about opportunistic looting, but there was insufficient community engagement to establish a clear consensus beyond concerns about police conduct.
Are we winning yet ?
A post asking "Are we winning yet?" (likely referencing a policy or political development) prompted discussion about student loan debt enforcement. The community expressed skepticism about the practical effectiveness and fairness of the policy, with concerns about enforcement mechanisms and political implications.
πββοΈπββοΈπββοΈ
A political meme post (content unclear from emoji title) sparked debate about the relationship between ideological conviction and humanitarian claims. Commenters disagreed on whether 'deep love for humanity' is genuine motivation or a rhetorical cover, with particular tensions around left-right political divisions and specific policy positions like abortion.
Does Gen Z feel like they got screwed over?
The discussion reveals a divided Gen Z community on whether they've been unfairly disadvantaged. While most commenters express frustration with economic conditions, political decisions by older generations, and existential concerns, one notable dissenting voice argues that privileged Gen Z members with lucrative careers haven't actually been significantly harmed and that generational complaints are overblown.