The Modern Football Graveyard.
A sports card collector discusses the poor performance of ultra-modern NFL quarterbacks and argues that investors should sell most football cards before the season starts rather than holding them hoping for price appreciation. The speaker analyzes specific players like Caleb Williams, Justin Herbert, Jackson Dart, and Jaden Daniels, highlighting how injuries and underperformance have devastated card values.
Summary
The video opens with a sponsorship message for The Penny Sleeper card storage products before diving into analysis of the current NFL quarterback landscape. The host criticizes several highly-hyped young quarterbacks whose card values were inflated during the preseason but have since underperformed or been injured.
Justin Herbert receives particular criticism for not delivering on expectations despite his Prismatic Silver card selling for around $1,500-$1,600 at season start. The host questions why Herbert's cards commanded such high prices given his actual on-field performance, attributing some of his pre-season hype to his personal life rather than football ability.
Jackson Dart is described as "an absolute lunatic" prone to injury due to his reckless playing style. The host recounts drafting him opposite to a close friend in their fantasy league, noting that everyone in their circle knew Dart's injury-prone tendencies. Dart suffered a season-ending injury early in the season.
Jaden Daniels is presented as talented but cursed, compared to Robert Griffin III—both had magical rookie seasons followed by devastating injuries. Daniels has suffered multiple elbow dislocations, with his arm bending back and snapping when his elbow dislocates. The host expresses sympathy for Daniels investors who held cards expecting a breakout season.
Caleb Williams' trajectory illustrates the volatile nature of quarterback card investing. He started at $1,500, peaked at $2,000 after a strong first week, dropped to $1,500 after a scary injury, then recovered slightly to $1,625 as injury concerns lessened.
The core investment thesis presented is that investors should sell most football cards before the season starts, keeping only cheap speculation plays on backup quarterbacks who might get inserted into games. The speaker argues that highly-priced cards like Herbert's need unrealistic performance to justify their valuations, making them poor investments. Historical examples support this approach: Burrow and Dak Prescott cards became cheap during the season before potentially spiking during playoff runs.
The host acknowledges the temptation to hold cards and regret selling them if a player succeeds, using the hypothetical of selling Tyler Shaq cards that could become $3,000 cards if the Saints made a deep playoff run. However, he argues that the losses avoided by selling high-profile quarterback cards early outweigh the occasional miss on a breakout player.
The speaker contrasts football card investing with basketball and baseball, noting that football is uniquely built for overreaction due to having only one game per week. He advocates for focusing on position players like receivers (Denzel Boston example) rather than quarterbacks or running backs, or building personal collections of established Hall of Famers like Jim Brown and Joe Thomas.
The video concludes by soliciting audience opinions on how they're navigating the modern football card market—whether they avoid it completely, double down, or search for promising players.
Key Insights
- Justin Herbert's $1,500-$1,600 Prismatic Silver card was overvalued at the start of the season given that he was a 2020 rookie six years later still failing to perform, representing a fundamentally flawed investment based on outdated preseason pricing
- Caleb Williams' card prices spiked to $2,000 after a strong week one performance but dropped back to $1,500 after a serious injury scare, demonstrating the extreme volatility and risk of holding high-priced quarterback cards into the season
- Highly-priced quarterback cards at season start require unrealistic levels of performance to justify their valuations, making it mathematically unlikely that investors will see returns on cards like Herbert's $1,600 Prismatic Silver
- Jackson Dart's injury-prone playing style was predictable to experienced collectors, and his season-ending injury means he lost another year of player development as a second-year player, compounding the investment loss
- Football is uniquely prone to overreaction compared to basketball and baseball because players only compete once per week, causing script changes for players to happen very quickly when results don't meet expectations
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Ah, YouTubers. Instead of talking about fake cards, let's talk about terrible quarterbacks . Today we're just going to talk a little bit about the current state of ultra-modern football. My God. Before we get too deep, let's welcome today's video sponsor , The Penny Sleeper. Come on in to The Penny Sleeper. Link in the description below. You can use the code Neo2026 to get 10% off . And they just put together a small set. Do n't want to deal with the assessment? I understand. I don't [0:31] blame you. Leave these things raw if you want. If it's just for your PC, don't waste your money on an evaluation. They could be displayed beautifully in The…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from NEO Cards & Comics
2026 Topps Chrome Football, PSA Says No More Drop Offs & More.
A weekly sports card market update covering Topps Chrome Football's upcoming release with premium patches and Mahomes autos, PSA's elimination of walk-in Wednesday drop-offs through 2026, the launch of a Fanatics credit card with 5% cashback on platform purchases, and an analysis of current basketball and football card market trends.
PSA Is Considering a MAJOR Collectors Club Overhaul?
A YouTuber discusses a PSA survey about potential Collectors Club membership overhauls, reviewing various proposed perks and expressing preferences for benefits tied to grading services rather than merchandise or entertainment perks. He speculates that PSA will likely announce price drops soon as they clear their backlog and need more cards to meet demand.
Repacks Turned Cards Into a $2 Billion Casino
A YouTube creator discusses a Bank of America report revealing that digital repack apps have grown to 1.7 million weekly active users and $2 billion in annualized revenue, arguing that repacks are a critical liquidity engine propping up the entire trading card market and will likely face regulatory scrutiny in the future.
Is The Hobby Is Trapped in a Cycle of Negativity?
The speaker discusses how negativity dominates collectibles content due to algorithmic rewards, examining whether this negativity cycle affects collectors' actual enjoyment of the hobby. He argues that while some negative topics deserve coverage, finding balance is crucial to prevent the hobby from becoming overshadowed by drama and market pessimism.
The PSA FedEx Heist Was Bigger Than We Thought
PSA discovered additional trading cards were stolen in the October 13th FedEx heist beyond the initially reported numbers, updating their statement on November 10th without providing specific cert numbers for the newly identified missing items. The discovery suggests vault orders may have been particularly affected, with some customers only learning their cards were impacted after contacting customer service.