PSA’s Stolen List Revealed: 6,451 Items Gone—What Will PSA Pay Collectors?
PSA released an official update on the theft of 6,451 items from their facility, providing a complete itemized list and outlining compensation procedures. The company will compensate customers based on fair market value up to their declared maximum insured value, with payments already being distributed, while working with law enforcement and the FBI on the investigation.
Summary
PSA published a formal statement regarding the theft of 6,451 cards and packs from their facility. The stolen items include a mix of trading card game non-sport cards, sports cards, and notably more One Piece cards than any individual sports card category. The company provided investigators with video footage, shipment manifests, item-level records, and has maintained daily contact with law enforcement and the FBI. A critical detail remains unknown: the exact location of the physical truck at the time of the theft, as the police call was made from PSA's address but may not indicate where the actual theft occurred. PSA is immediately compensating customers without waiting for the investigation to conclude. Compensation eligibility depends on return shipping method: customers who used PSA's return label and insurance can begin the compensation process immediately with payments already being distributed; those who used their own return labels will work with PSA to resolve their claims; and orders submitted through dealers should contact those dealers directly. PSA will compensate based on fair market value of each item up to its declared maximum insured value, in accordance with their terms and conditions and insurance requirements. This maximum insured value cap is expected to be a significant point of contention for affected collectors. If stolen items are recovered in the future, customers will have the choice between keeping their compensation or receiving the original items back, but cannot receive both. The presenter notes this represents an extreme outlier in the hobby's history, with PSA shipping approximately 2.6 million cards monthly with only a tiny fraction experiencing loss. PSA indicated they will re-evaluate shipping partners going forward. The presenter advises collectors to verify PSA authentication numbers through the PSA app when purchasing cards, particularly recent serial numbers and high-value items, though most stolen cards are likely already removed from their slabs.
Key Insights
- PSA provided investigators with video footage from their facility, which could potentially capture the stolen truck since surrounding businesses and security cameras outside the building may also have recorded footage
- The exact physical location of the truck at the time of theft remains the biggest unknown in the investigation, as the police call being made from PSA's address does not necessarily indicate where the theft actually occurred
- More One Piece trading cards were stolen than any single sports card category, which the presenter notes was a surprising finding from the 6,451 total items
- Compensation is capped at customers' declared maximum insured value even when fair market value exceeds it, which the presenter predicts will become a focal point of contention in the hobby's discussion of this incident
- If stolen items are recovered in the future, customers must choose between keeping their compensation money or receiving the original item back, but cannot receive both
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Ah YouTube people Friday afternoon actually Friday evening video is never a good sign. Well uh in this case it's an important update. PSA has given a much more formal update. There's a lot of good information in here. A lot of stuff we still don't know but uh I wanted to get this out there as quickly as humanly possible. Probably be a little bit of a shorter video. Uh but let's just go ahead and dive into what they put out. This just got published about 20 minutes ago or so over on the PSA website. And [0:31] the big thing that they give us here is the total number of cards missing and the complete list.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from NEO Cards & Comics
2026 Topps Chrome Football, PSA Says No More Drop Offs & More.
A weekly sports card market update covering Topps Chrome Football's upcoming release with premium patches and Mahomes autos, PSA's elimination of walk-in Wednesday drop-offs through 2026, the launch of a Fanatics credit card with 5% cashback on platform purchases, and an analysis of current basketball and football card market trends.
PSA Is Considering a MAJOR Collectors Club Overhaul?
A YouTuber discusses a PSA survey about potential Collectors Club membership overhauls, reviewing various proposed perks and expressing preferences for benefits tied to grading services rather than merchandise or entertainment perks. He speculates that PSA will likely announce price drops soon as they clear their backlog and need more cards to meet demand.
Repacks Turned Cards Into a $2 Billion Casino
A YouTube creator discusses a Bank of America report revealing that digital repack apps have grown to 1.7 million weekly active users and $2 billion in annualized revenue, arguing that repacks are a critical liquidity engine propping up the entire trading card market and will likely face regulatory scrutiny in the future.
Is The Hobby Is Trapped in a Cycle of Negativity?
The speaker discusses how negativity dominates collectibles content due to algorithmic rewards, examining whether this negativity cycle affects collectors' actual enjoyment of the hobby. He argues that while some negative topics deserve coverage, finding balance is crucial to prevent the hobby from becoming overshadowed by drama and market pessimism.
The PSA FedEx Heist Was Bigger Than We Thought
PSA discovered additional trading cards were stolen in the October 13th FedEx heist beyond the initially reported numbers, updating their statement on November 10th without providing specific cert numbers for the newly identified missing items. The discovery suggests vault orders may have been particularly affected, with some customers only learning their cards were impacted after contacting customer service.