NewsOpinion

PSA May Be Weeks Away From Clearing the Backlog

NEO Cards & Comics

PSA is trimming approximately one million cards from its backlog every two weeks and is approaching a clearing point within weeks. The speaker predicts PSA will reopen lower-tier, cheaper grading service levels soon—likely around $40-45—to increase incoming volume and maintain market dominance against competitors like CGC and TAG.

Summary

The speaker provides a PSA backlog update, noting that PSA has removed another million cards from its backlog in just two weeks, representing one of their highest outputs for a two-week period. At the current pace of clearing one million cards every two weeks, PSA could reach the 5 million card mark by the end of November, getting dangerously close to clearing the entire backlog.

The speaker speculates that before reaching that point, PSA will likely reopen a new lower-tier service level, probably around $40-45 per card, rather than jumping directly to cheaper options. This follows PSA's past strategy of gradually easing back into service offerings, as they did with the $60 tier. The speaker highlights a key sentence from PSA's recent statement about reopening services in phases with 'dynamic demand' pricing that adjusts based on incoming volume and available grading capacity.

Using data analysis combining backlog updates with GemRate data, the speaker estimates incoming card volumes. The analysis reveals that PSA is not receiving enough cards at the $80 and $60 price points to sustain current output levels. This is by design—PSA deliberately priced high to work down the backlog, but now they need to lower prices to get more cards through the door.

The speaker argues that PSA wants to grade cards at all price levels, even lower-margin items, because each card in a PSA slab is one less card going to CGC, TAG, or other competitors. PSA dominates the secondary market through sheer volume and holder recognition, and they want to maintain that market position. The speaker uses the example of Topps Chrome football cards—at current pricing, it doesn't make financial sense to grade base cards, but PSA wants to get back to price points where it does.

The speaker concludes that while recent FedEx-related drama around shipping, insurance, and declared values may create some friction, it won't significantly impact PSA's dominance. Most collectors will continue sending cards to PSA because they sell for the most money and offer the best liquidity, which collectors prioritize over other concerns.

Key Insights

  • PSA is clearing approximately one million cards from its backlog every two weeks, which is one of their highest outputs for a two-week period, putting them on track to reach 5 million by end of November
  • PSA deliberately kept prices high ($80, $60) to work through the backlog quickly, but incoming volume data shows they're not receiving enough cards at these price points to sustain current output levels, necessitating price reductions
  • PSA wants to grade all cards regardless of profit margin because each card in a PSA slab prevents a competitor like CGC or TAG from getting that card, protecting PSA's dominant market position through sheer volume and brand recognition
  • The speaker estimates PSA will introduce a new service level around $40-45 per card as the next price tier, based on incoming volume data and PSA's historical pattern of stair-stepping prices down rather than making large jumps
  • Recent FedEx-related drama around shipping insurance and declared values will not significantly reduce PSA submissions because collectors prioritize resale price and liquidity over other concerns, and PSA remains the market leader on both metrics

Topics

PSA backlog reduction and timelineService level reopening strategyDynamic demand pricing modelCard volume analysis and estimatesMarket competition with CGC and TAGPricing strategy and market positioningFedEx shipping and insurance issues

Transcript

[0:00] Ah, YouTube people, a lot of PSA news this week. Uh, and we have some more because it is Tuesday and it's the every other Tuesday. So, that means we get a PSA backlog update. And spoilers, they trimmed another million off the total in just two weeks. One of their highest outputs yet for a two-eek period. And I think we can safely say we're like we're dangerously close to [0:32] the backlog being cleared. You know, they're clearing off a million every two weeks. If that pace holds in the next four weeks, you know, by the end of November, we're going to be at the 5 million mark. Now, I have a sneaking suspicion that before…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from NEO Cards & Comics

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.