Fake PSA Slabs Invade Fanatics Collect Premier Auction?
A YouTuber investigates potentially counterfeit PSA graded cards being sold on Fanatics Collect's premier auction, including a $288,000 Dragonite where the original owner claims to still possess the real card. The fake slabs can be identified by examining the fugitive ink technology on PSA labels, which should contain a distinctive dot-pattern wave design that appears absent on the questionable cards.
Summary
A recent Fanatics Collect premier auction sale of a Dragonite card for $288,000 has raised serious concerns about counterfeit PSA slabs entering the high-end collectibles market. A Reddit user posted claiming to be the original owner of the card submitted for grading five years ago, stating the card remains in their possession and never sold, complete with photographic evidence and original submission documentation. This discovery prompted internet detectives to compare the sold card with the owner's actual card, revealing multiple suspicious discrepancies. Notably, older PSA-graded cards lack scanned images in the PSA database, making them harder to verify and potentially exploitable for fraud. The speaker identifies several distinguishing features between genuine and fake PSA slabs: printing irregularities on the label, differences in the slab's bumper appearance, corner construction issues, and most tellingly, the absence of the fugitive ink dot-pattern on the label's wave design. Genuine PSA labels from 2017 onward feature a distinctive blue wave pattern made up of tiny dots or squares, which is clearly visible when examined closely; the questionable slabs lack this characteristic. Additionally, the holographic patterns on the front and back of the legitimate card differ completely from those on the card sold at auction, despite sharing the same certification number. Fanatics Collect CEO Nick Bell acknowledged the issue on social media, stating the company is investigating. The speaker suspects PSA representatives will need to examine the physical slabs in the Fanatics Collect vault to determine if the cards are genuinely fake, lower-grade copies fraudulently upgraded to 10s, or legitimate cards in counterfeit holders. The discovery appears to be part of a larger pattern, with additional potentially fraudulent cards identified in other Fanatics Collect sales, active eBay listings, and possibly other platforms. The fact that this card not only made it into the premier auction but also received a top 30% eye appeal designation is particularly concerning. The speaker emphasizes that while this investigation focused on Pokémon cards, the same fraud likely extends to sports cards and other collectibles, urging buyers to conduct due diligence by checking for PSA scans, verifying label authenticity, and examining card condition before purchasing high-end items.
Key Insights
- A Reddit user proved the Dragonite sold at Fanatics Collect for $288,000 is a counterfeit slab by posting evidence that they still own the authentic card and never sold it, complete with original submission documentation from five years prior
- The most identifiable difference between genuine and fake PSA slabs is the fugitive ink wave pattern on the label, which should consist of tiny dots or squares forming a checkerboard-like pattern when viewed closely, a feature absent on the questionable cards
- Older PSA-graded cards without scanned images in the PSA database are particularly vulnerable to fraud, making them easier targets for counterfeiters to exploit since verification is more difficult
- The counterfeit Dragonite not only passed through Fanatics Collect's highest tier premium auction but also received a top 30% eye appeal designation, suggesting significant failures in authentication and quality control procedures
- Evidence indicates this fraud is not limited to Fanatics Collect but potentially extends across multiple platforms including active eBay listings and possibly other auction houses, with total suspicious sales combined approaching $600,000
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] Well, YouTube people, we might have a little bit of a problem here. Uh, and for the time being, Fanatics Collect, but it might be spreading well beyond that. And God knows how far and deep this potentially goes. Um, yes, I have Pokemon cards on the screen, but this affects anything in a PSA holder potentially, and it's something that we need to keep our eyes open for. Uh, let me give you the quick rundown here. [0:32] This Dragonite recently sold on the Fanatics Collect premier auction that just ended uh a few days ago. 288,000. I have no idea if that's a good price, bad price. Uh, I don't follow follow vintage Pokemon singles very much.…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from NEO Cards & Comics
2026 Topps Chrome Football, PSA Says No More Drop Offs & More.
A weekly sports card market update covering Topps Chrome Football's upcoming release with premium patches and Mahomes autos, PSA's elimination of walk-in Wednesday drop-offs through 2026, the launch of a Fanatics credit card with 5% cashback on platform purchases, and an analysis of current basketball and football card market trends.
PSA Is Considering a MAJOR Collectors Club Overhaul?
A YouTuber discusses a PSA survey about potential Collectors Club membership overhauls, reviewing various proposed perks and expressing preferences for benefits tied to grading services rather than merchandise or entertainment perks. He speculates that PSA will likely announce price drops soon as they clear their backlog and need more cards to meet demand.
Repacks Turned Cards Into a $2 Billion Casino
A YouTube creator discusses a Bank of America report revealing that digital repack apps have grown to 1.7 million weekly active users and $2 billion in annualized revenue, arguing that repacks are a critical liquidity engine propping up the entire trading card market and will likely face regulatory scrutiny in the future.
Is The Hobby Is Trapped in a Cycle of Negativity?
The speaker discusses how negativity dominates collectibles content due to algorithmic rewards, examining whether this negativity cycle affects collectors' actual enjoyment of the hobby. He argues that while some negative topics deserve coverage, finding balance is crucial to prevent the hobby from becoming overshadowed by drama and market pessimism.
The PSA FedEx Heist Was Bigger Than We Thought
PSA discovered additional trading cards were stolen in the October 13th FedEx heist beyond the initially reported numbers, updating their statement on November 10th without providing specific cert numbers for the newly identified missing items. The discovery suggests vault orders may have been particularly affected, with some customers only learning their cards were impacted after contacting customer service.