OpinionNews

Can PSA Keep up This Record Breaking Pace?

NEO Cards & Comics

PSA grading continues its record-breaking pace with 2.79 million cards graded monthly, projected to exceed 3 million by year-end. The speaker analyzes grading output across major companies (CGC, SGC, TAG, Beckett), noting that European expansion and operational efficiencies are driving PSA's dominance while other graders show mixed results.

Summary

The speaker opens by highlighting PSA's record-breaking monthly gem rate at 2.79 million cards, with a 13% month-over-month increase that suggests the company will crack 3 million cards before year-end. The analysis anticipates more affordable grading tiers opening, particularly around the $40 price point, as PSA continues expanding capacity.

A key factor discussed is the impact of PSA's European office (based in Germany) opening approximately 1-2 months prior to recording. This development significantly reduces international submission volume that previously had to cross the Atlantic, effectively removing a substantial portion of incoming volume from the domestic grading ecosystem. Combined with Japan's existing operations, this geographical expansion allows PSA to process more cards while reducing logistical burden on domestic facilities.

The speaker compares grading output across competitors: CGC remains under 1 million with flat month-over-month growth but strong year-over-year increases; SGC shows impressive 20% month-over-month growth following expansion efforts to meet customer demand; TAG remains stagnant at approximately 50k cards monthly; and Beckett provides no updated data pending POP report clarification.

An important distinction is made regarding interpretation of grading statistics: the numbers represent cards graded from existing backlogs, not new submissions. This explains why SGC's 20% increase doesn't reflect proportional new incoming volume, especially following their price increases.

Smaller graders receive brief mention—AGS at 84,000 cards monthly with unclear market penetration, and PCG potentially approaching TAG's volume with higher-quality slabs. CGC's sports numbers require adjustment, with 70,000 of 966,000 total cards being semi-rigid unslab cards for Fanatics Collect rather than traditional slabs, artificially inflating sports category reporting.

The speaker projects future market dynamics, anticipating a potential value bulk tier around $30 per card (possibly requiring collector's club membership) as PSA clears current backlog. TCG submissions are expected to soften as Pokemon's 30th anniversary cycle concludes, clearing runway for incoming sports card submissions as major releases approach (Topps flagship basketball and Topps Chrome update).

The broader commentary suggests the hobby is entering an interesting transitional phase with mixed market signals: Pokemon values declining, some softening across categories, yet record-breaking sales data contradicting downward perception. Mixed reports from the Nashville show further suggest market uncertainty.

Key Insights

  • PSA's European office opening has cut incoming international volume significantly by eliminating the need for European submissions to cross the Atlantic, reducing overall domestic grading ecosystem load while PSA maintains or increases total grading output
  • SGC's 20% month-over-month increase represents cards flowing from existing backlog rather than new submissions, meaning the increase doesn't indicate proportional growth in incoming orders despite recent price increases
  • CGC is inflating its reported sports grading numbers by including 70,000 semi-rigid unslab cards (soft sleeves with stickers for Fanatics Collect) rather than traditional slabs, artificially boosting sports category metrics
  • PSA's TCG submissions are expected to soften as Pokemon's 30th anniversary release cycle concludes, which could clear capacity for incoming sports card submissions from major releases like Topps flagship basketball and Chrome update
  • The hobby is showing contradictory market signals with record-breaking sales data from card ladder coexisting with softening values in Pokemon and other categories, and mixed reports even from typically strong shows like Nashville

Topics

PSA grading volume and capacity expansionInternational grading offices impact on domestic volumeCompetitive grading company analysisPricing tier availability and future offeringsSports and TCG submission trendsHobby market signals and softening demandGrading statistics interpretation methodology

Transcript

[0:01] Ah, YouTube people, how's a nice round three million look? We're not quite there yet, but we are damn close. We're looking at the gem rate numbers today. And PSA, no one should be shocked by this. Uh, record-breaking month at 2.79 million. And this just keeps going back to what I've been talking about. They're going to crack 3 million cards probably by the end of the year. And this is why you are going to continue to see cheaper grading tiers [0:32] open up. Now, I am recording this prior to a backlog update. I am assuming we are getting a backlog update this week. Maybe we're not. I don't know. But there should be one out…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from NEO Cards & Comics

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.