MurmurCast
ResearchDiscussion

Zero-Click Marketing: How to Win When Google Stops Sending Traffic

Marketing Against The Grain34m 8s

Zero-click searches now represent 68% of all Google searches, with only 32% resulting in clicks to websites. This shift requires marketers to fundamentally change their strategy from chasing volume traffic to building loyal, niche audiences and meeting customers where they actually search—across multiple platforms beyond Google.

Summary

The transcript discusses a fundamental transformation in how search and digital marketing work. Amanda Natividad and the hosts explain that in 2026, only 32% of Google searches result in a click, with 39% yielding no action and 29% leading to another search. This zero-click phenomenon has been growing for a decade—in 2016 only 45% of searches were zero-click, but today it's 68%. Of the 32% that do click, only about 6% go to the open web, with the rest going to paid ads or Google properties like AI overviews.

The hosts use HubSpot as a case study, noting that while the company lost 140 million visits in 12 months, this was actually a positive development. HubSpot retained traffic on high-intent search terms (CRM, automation software) while losing low-quality, non-converting traffic (movie quotes, emoji searches). Despite losing 80% of organic traffic in Q3-Q4 2025, HubSpot reported all-time revenue highs, demonstrating that traffic quality matters far more than volume.

The book's five rules for zero-click marketing success are: (1) Gain deep audience understanding, (2) Go where your people are, (3) Stop fighting the tide and give platforms what they want, (4) Build a zero-click marketing flywheel with decreasing friction, and (5) Lean on measurement rather than attribution. The hosts emphasize that marketers must balance optimizing for people AND algorithms simultaneously—they're not mutually exclusive.

Search behavior has diversified significantly. While 80% of search still happens on traditional search engines (mostly Google), people also search on e-commerce sites, social media, and AI tools (representing only 3% currently). This means there's a one-in-five chance users are searching for solutions outside Google. The discussion highlights that successful modern marketing requires understanding exactly which platforms your audience uses through tools like SparkToro, then creating platform-native value that doesn't require clicking through to your website.

The transcript discusses the difference between horizontal creators (like Stephen Bartlett) who chase algorithm virality across diverse topics versus niche creators who build deep expertise. The hosts argue that depth is now more valuable than breadth due to AI democratizing general knowledge access. Building genuine audience loyalty creates 'value debt'—where audiences feel obligated to support creators who've provided consistent value. This contrasts sharply with the previous inbound marketing era (mid-2000s to 2022) where marketers could monetize transient, one-time searchers.

About this episode

Free: 15 prompts to keep your brand visible in search  https://clickhubspot.com/ikub Ep. 454 Did you know that today, 68% of all Google searches end without a single click? Kipp, Kieran, and guest Amanda Natividad (founder of Zero Click Marketing, and co-author of the forthcoming book, Zero Click Marketing) dive into the era of zero-click marketing, covering how search behavior is changing, what it means for your company’s growth, and what you must do to thrive. Learn more on evolving beyond Google to meet your audience where they are, rethinking the purpose of SEO in a diversified search landscape, and building lasting value by focusing on the right audience—not just more traffic. Mentions Amanda Natividad https://www.linkedin.com/in/amandanat/ Zero Click Marketing https://zeroclickmarketing.co/ Zero Click Marketing (book) https://www.damngravity.com/products/zero-click-marketing SparkToro https://sparktoro.com/ Loop: Outlearn. Outmarket. Outgrow https://www.hubspot.com/loop-marketing-book Get our guide to build your own Custom GPT: https://clickhubspot.com/customgpt Resource [Free] Steal our favorite AI Prompts featured on the show! Grab them here: https://clickhubspot.com/aip We’re on Social Media! Follow us for everyday marketing wisdom straight to your feed YouTube: ​​https://www.youtube.com/@matgpod  Twitter: https://twitter.com/matgpod  TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@marketingatg Thank you for tuning into Marketing Against The Grain! Don’t forget to hit subscribe and follow us on Apple Podcasts (so you never miss an episode)! https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/marketing-against-the-grain/id1616700934   We really appreciate your support. Host Links: Kipp Bodnar, https://twitter.com/kippbodnar   Kieran Flanagan, https://twitter.com/searchbrat  ‘Marketing Against The Grain’ is a HubSpot Original Podcast // Brought to you by Hubspot Media // Produced by Darren Clarke.

Key Insights

  • 68% of Google searches now end without any click to a website, compared to 45% in 2016, representing a decade-long acceleration that continues to intensify
  • HubSpot lost 140 million visits but maintained all-time revenue highs because it retained high-intent search traffic while shedding low-converting informational queries, proving that traffic quality outweighs volume
  • Of the 32% of Google searches that do result in clicks, only 6% go to the open web while 27% go to AI tools or Google properties, demonstrating the concentration of traffic within walled gardens
  • Search behavior is now diversified across platforms—80% remains on traditional search engines but significant portions happen on e-commerce sites and social media, meaning marketers must reach audiences across multiple discovery channels
  • Marketers must simultaneously optimize for both people and algorithms; attempting to optimize for only one approach results in lower success than balancing both needs together
  • Audiences who frequently use Claude over ChatGPT reveal specific behavioral patterns and sophistication levels that inform how to market to them, as evidenced by the LED mask audience analysis
  • The modern value exchange in marketing has shifted from monetizing transient one-time searchers to building loyal audiences who develop 'value debt' and feel obligated to support creators after sustained content consumption
  • Niche, deeply-focused creators with specialized expertise are now more valuable than horizontal creators chasing algorithm virality, because AI has democratized access to generalized knowledge across all topics

Topics

Zero-click searches and declining website trafficSearch diversification across multiple platformsQuality versus quantity in audience buildingHubSpot case study and traffic transformationFive rules of zero-click marketing playbookAudience research and platform selectionNiche expertise versus horizontal content creationPlatform-native value and zero-click value proposition

Transcript

What might shock you is today less than 32% of people who search actually click on a link in Google and this shift is destroying your business. Today we're joined by Amanda Natividad. She is the co-author of Zero Click Marketing, a new book that's out, as well as chief evangelist at SparkToro. We're here to help you understand how search is actually changing, the rules to succeed in this new world, and you're gonna want to stick around because we got a load of more data points that are going to really change how you think about growing your business. Let's get into today's show. You know, on today's show, we are talking about an interesting dynamic that search,…

Full transcript available for MurmurCast members

Sign Up to Access

More from Marketing Against The Grain

Get AI summaries like this delivered to your inbox daily

Get AI summaries delivered to your inbox

MurmurCast summarizes your YouTube channels, podcasts, and newsletters into one daily email digest.