i tried running only AI ads for 30 days (it printed lol)
Mark documents how he generated $2.2 million in sales using 100% AI-generated ads over 30 days, spending just over $1 million on ads. He argues that AI has eliminated the quality-speed-cost tradeoff in ad production, but warns that the real competitive edge now lies in deep customer research and finding a 'winning message' rather than chasing winning ads or flashy AI tools.
Summary
Mark opens by sharing his March results: $2.2 million in sales from just over $1 million in ad spend, all driven by AI-generated creatives. He frames the core shift AI has brought to advertising through what he calls the old 'pick two' tradeoff — quality, speed, or low cost — arguing that AI now allows advertisers to achieve all three simultaneously. While this lowers the barrier to entry dramatically, it also causes an exponential increase in competitor ad volume, making the landscape far more competitive.
To address this, Mark argues that the true competitive moat is no longer creative volume or technical quality — both of which are now commoditized — but rather the thinking and research behind each creative. He introduces the concept of finding a 'winning message' rather than a winning ad, drawing on direct response marketing history and referencing author Michael Masterson. His thesis is that a strong sales message can be adapted across hundreds of ad formats, while competitors merely copying surface-level creatives will consistently underperform.
Mark then outlines what he calls 'AI non-negotiables.' The first is that copywriting remains the foundation, and that psychographic research — which he says should consume 60–80% of a marketer's time — must precede any creative production. He references a 'foundational docs SOP' he built using AI to extract copy ingredients like unique mechanisms, discovery stories, and levels of awareness. The second non-negotiable is funnel quality as a creative multiplier, using a 'rising tide raises all ships' analogy to show that improving conversion rate and average order value raises the performance floor and ceiling of all creatives simultaneously. He argues funnel diversity is more impactful than creative diversity.
On the technology side, Mark breaks down his specific AI stack. For images, he relies almost exclusively on Flux Dev (Nano Banana Pro via Hailuo/Higgsfield) with Canva's Magic Layer for post-editing. For video, he uses Kling 3.0 as his primary model for quality-cost balance, Veo 3.1 for speed and image-to-video workflows, and Seedance 2.0 exclusively for remaking already-proven top performers due to its high cost. He emphasizes always doing image generation first in Flux, then passing to image-to-video models.
Mark then analyzes three real ad examples: an AI UGC video using a first-person 'I was just like you but worse' framework targeting a solution-aware thyroid/eye disease market; a native static image ad using visual contrast and provocative copy ('Please stop buying oral B12 for neuropathy'); and an AI animation ad for a liquid collagen product, which he notes performs well despite — or because of — its deliberately simple, non-realistic aesthetic. He concludes that AI realism is no longer the goal, that animation and stylized formats drawn from TV commercial history can outperform hyper-realistic content, and reiterates that AI is a vehicle and multiplier, not a strategy in itself.
Key Insights
- Mark argues that the real competitive moat in AI advertising is not the technology itself — which is rapidly commoditized — but the thinking and systemization behind creatives, specifically finding a 'winning message' that can be transmitted across hundreds of ad formats and styles.
- Mark claims that funnel diversity is actually more important than creative diversity, using a 'rising tide raises all ships' analogy to argue that improving funnel conversion rate and AOV raises both the floor and ceiling of all creative performance simultaneously.
- Mark states that deep psychographic research should consume 60–80% of a marketer's time before any writing or creative production begins, citing historical direct response copywriters who said the actual writing should be the minority of their effort.
- Mark argues that AI realism is no longer the goal for video ads, claiming that some of his top-performing ads from the past month were deliberately simple animation-style creatives, and that formats drawn from decades-old TV commercial history can outperform hyper-realistic AI content.
- Mark claims that for image ad production, Flux Dev (Nano Banana Pro) combined with Canva's Magic Layer is the only toolset needed, and that with good prompting and reference images there is 'literally nothing you cannot accomplish' — dismissing newer models like ChatGPT's image generator as essentially equivalent clones.
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access