Ai made your ads worthless
AI-generated creatives have become commoditized due to their accessibility and infinite availability, eliminating AI as a competitive moat. The real competitive advantage now lies in the strategic thinking and philosophy behind creatives, with quality and deep understanding of why ads work being the primary differentiators.
Summary
The speaker argues that artificial intelligence has fundamentally disrupted the creative advantage that marketers previously held. Because AI tools and knowledge about producing AI creatives are widely accessible and essentially infinite in supply, AI-generated creative content has become a commodity with diminished value. This commoditization means that simply using AI to produce creatives is no longer a sustainable competitive moat—a unique advantage that's difficult for competitors to replicate.
With creative volume and AI usage no longer being differentiators, the speaker identifies that quality and strategic thinking are the only remaining levers for competition. The critical skill becomes understanding the underlying philosophy and strategic reasoning behind creative decisions. The speaker emphasizes that successful marketers must understand why ads work at a granular level, identifying and extracting the winning variables that drive performance.
The speaker expresses frustration with the common approach of testing numerous ads without strategic understanding, which he characterizes as futile repetition of mediocrity. For those who understand direct response marketing principles, this shift away from volume-based competition represents an opportunity, as the bar for strategic thinking among entrepreneurs remains relatively low. True competitive advantage now requires clarity and confidence in understanding the fundamental mechanisms that make advertising effective.
Key Insights
- The speaker claims that AI-generated creatives have become a commodity because accessibility to AI and knowledge about producing AI creatives is virtually infinite, and infinite supply destroys value
- The speaker argues that AI is no longer a moat or competitive advantage because everyone has access to the same technology
- The speaker identifies that the thinking philosophy and strategic reasoning behind creatives is the only real moat that remains in a commoditized AI landscape
- The speaker contends that quality is the only remaining lever to pull with creatives when creative volume is no longer a differentiator
- The speaker believes that entrepreneurs must understand the specific winning variables in their ads with clarity and confidence, otherwise they will only produce more ineffective creatives
Topics
Transcript
[0:00] AI [ __ ] every single one of us because it got too good too fast. The accessibility of AI and the information of how to produce AI creatives is virtually infinite. When something is infinite, it loses its value. So, now what we have is AI with creatives as a commodity, which means AI is not a moat anymore. So, it's not something you can compete on. So, what is the real thing that you can compete on? And I think that the thinking philosophy behind your creatives is the real moat because if you can't compete on creative volume, there's only one other thing to compete on with your creatives. Well, it's [0:30] quality. That's the only…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Mark Builds Brands
Intentional doom scrolling
To become a better advertiser, create burner social media accounts and intentionally doomscroll through content your target customers follow, focusing on organic posts rather than ads. When you notice organic content appearing repeatedly (at least three times), that signals it's worth testing as paid advertising creative.
Your funnel is a creative multiplier
A funnel acts as a creative multiplier that can dramatically improve the performance of the same creatives. By upgrading your funnel's conversion rate, average order value, or LTV, creatives that previously underperformed can become winners, making it easier to discover high-performing creative without necessarily creating better ads.
Don't split test the first page
Facebook penalizes split testing on landing pages after ad approval because it views post-approval changes as potential cloaking or non-compliance. The speaker demonstrates this through a failed listicle test that only succeeded when retested using new post IDs instead of modifying the original approved landing page.
Why winnings ads eventually die
Winning ads don't actually die; they hit a profitable spending cap that can be extended through strategic media buying, funnel testing, and improved unit economics. A creative is only truly dead after exhausting all optimization options within these levers.
Comparison is a net negative
The speaker argues that comparison is harmful before achieving initial success, but becomes motivating afterward. Social media distorts reality through lies and exaggeration, making premature self-comparison counterproductive and emotionally damaging.