MacroVoices #465 Rory Johnston: Oil Markets Under Trump 2.0
Rory Johnston discusses oil market fundamentals entering 2025, arguing that despite Trump's drill-baby-drill rhetoric, proposed tariffs on Canadian and Mexican crude would significantly disrupt U.S. refining operations since these heavy crudes are essential for blending with U.S. shale oil. He sees modest supply deficits continuing with gradually higher prices.
Summary
Rory Johnston provides comprehensive analysis of oil markets under Trump's second term, beginning with current fundamentals showing low inventory positions and modest supply deficits that point toward gradually higher prices in the low-80s range for Brent. He argues that while Trump promises energy dominance and drill-baby-drill policies, U.S. production growth is likely to slow to around 300,000 barrels per day in 2025 due to geological constraints and industry discipline, despite reduced regulatory burdens. The discussion extensively covers Trump's proposed 25% tariffs on Canadian and Mexican oil imports, which Johnston considers highly disruptive since Canadian heavy crude is structurally difficult to replace due to crude quality requirements and pipeline infrastructure. U.S. refineries were built before the shale revolution to process heavier crudes, requiring Canadian heavy oil to blend with ultra-light U.S. shale oil for optimal refining. Johnston estimates tariff costs would be split roughly equally between Canadian exporters, U.S. refiners, and consumers, potentially adding 13 cents per gallon to Midwest gasoline prices. He notes the irony that tariffs could push Canada to accelerate pipeline construction to its own coasts, reducing dependence on the U.S. market. Regarding sanctions policy, Johnston expects Trump to tighten enforcement on Iran and Venezuela, potentially removing over a million barrels daily from markets, but suggests Trump would first seek commitments from OPEC to replace lost barrels. He speculates about potential territorial expansion scenarios involving Venezuela's massive oil reserves. The interview concludes with analysis of how broader market volatility from events like China's DeepSeek AI breakthrough might affect oil prices, and discusses OPEC's likely resistance to Trump's requests for increased production given their focus on maintaining higher price levels.
About this episode
MacroVoices Erik Townsend & Patrick Ceresna welcome back, Rory Johnston. They discuss everything crude oil - from the current fundamental landscape and the impact of Trump’s tariff policies to why crude quality remains crucial and where refineries can source the heavy blend stock needed to process U.S. shale oil. https://bit.ly/42z5yIQ ⚫ Follow Rory on X: @Rory_Johnston 🔻Download Big Picture Trading Chartbook 📈📉: https://bit.ly/3WF7BHg ✅Sign up for a FREE 14-day trial at Big Picture Trading: https://bit.ly/4cMmu0d 🔴 Subscribe to Patrick’s Youtube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@Patrick_Ceresna 🔴 Subscribe to Erik's Substack: https://eriktownsend.substack.com/ 🔴 Check out Energy Transition Crisis on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@EnergyTransitionCrisis1 Please visit our website https://www.macrovoices.com to register your free account to gain access to supporting materials
Key Insights
- Johnston argues that Trump's proposed 25% tariffs on Canadian crude would create a roughly one-third split of costs between Canadian exporters, U.S. refiners, and American consumers, potentially adding 13 cents per gallon to Midwest gasoline prices
- He contends that U.S. production growth will slow to around 300,000 barrels per day in 2025 despite Trump's drill-baby-drill policies because geological constraints and industry discipline matter more than regulatory relief
- Johnston explains that Canadian heavy crude is structurally irreplaceable because U.S. refineries need to blend it with ultra-light shale oil to achieve the medium-grade crude they were designed to process optimally
- He predicts that Trump's tariff threats could accelerate Canada's construction of pipelines to its own coasts, reducing long-term dependence on the U.S. market in an unintended consequence
- Johnston suggests Trump is more likely to successfully implement sanctions on Iran and Venezuela than meaningfully increase U.S. production, since sanctions can be imposed immediately while drilling takes time
- He argues that oil prices remain fundamentally anchored to supply-demand dynamics despite being the most financialized commodity, meaning broad market selloffs would only temporarily affect prices unless they caused recession
- Johnston claims that OPEC learned from Trump's 2018 reversal on Iranian sanctions and will likely wait to see actual supply losses before increasing production rather than acting preemptively
- He identifies a core paradox in Trump's energy policy between wanting higher U.S. production and lower overall oil prices, noting these goals often conflict
- Johnston speculates that removing all OPEC production cuts could crash oil to $30-40 per barrel, but this would primarily hurt U.S. producers who are the highest-cost marginal suppliers
- He suggests there are limited U.S. sources of heavy crude that could replace Canadian imports even with a 25% price incentive, as the scale required doesn't exist domestically
- Johnston argues that 2024 represented a fundamental shift toward lower volatility and slower supply-demand growth after the extreme disruptions of 2020-2023
- He contends that current low inventory positions combined with modest supply deficits point toward gradually higher prices reaching the low-80s range for Brent crude
Topics
Transcript
This is Macro Voices, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. Macro Voices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Eric Townsend and Patrick Ceresna. Macro Voices episode 465 was produced on January 30th, 2025. I'm Eric Townsend. Commodity context founder and energy markets guru Rory Johnston returns as this week's feature interview guest. Rory and I will discuss all things crude oil from the current fundamental backdrop to Trump tariff policies and their knock-on effects to why crude quality stands. Still matters and potential sources for…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Macro Voices
MacroVoices #540 Adam Parker: Beyond the AI Bubble: Diversifying Portfolios in an Earnings-Driven Market
Adam Parker of Trivariate Research discusses a U.S. equity market supported by strong earnings growth rather than bubble dynamics, advocates for portfolio diversification away from concentrated AI/semiconductor exposure into energy and healthcare, and analyzes how geopolitical risks like the Hormuz crisis are unlikely to meaningfully impact equity fundamentals.
MacroVoices #539 Rory Johnston: Hormuz Crisis, is it Really Over?
Rory Johnston discusses how the Strait of Hormuz crisis has evolved from an expected supply shock into a managed situation through Chinese demand destruction and SPR releases, resulting in unexpected crude oil contango despite four months of closure. The petroleum market shows a critical split where refined products remain tight while crude oil faces downward pressure from oversupply that refineries cannot fully process.
MacroVoices #538 Lyn Alden: Is The War Really Over and What’s Next For Markets?
Lyn Alden discusses the Iran conflict resolution, Federal Reserve policy under new leadership, persistent U.S. fiscal deficits, the AI investment boom and its sustainability, stablecoin growth, and energy demands for AI infrastructure. She argues that while the conflict appears to be ending, significant negotiation details remain unresolved, and that fiscal dominance—not monetary policy—remains the primary driver of asset markets.
MacroVoices #536 Larry Mcdonald: The Migration is Upon us
In Macro Voices Episode 536, Larry McDonald discusses the current market dynamics amidst escalating geopolitical tensions and major upcoming IPOs, emphasizing a potential shift from crowded growth sectors to value and hard assets. He highlights the impact of insider selling and the likelihood of a continued inflationary environment, suggesting significant trading opportunities in healthcare and energy sectors.
MacroVoices #535 Michael Every: NAFTA and NAPTHA – Warcraft & Fartcraft
MacroVoices Episode 535 (June 4, 2026) features Rabobank's Michael Every and Commodity Context's Rory Johnston discussing the ongoing Strait of Hormuz closure, now three months into the Iran crisis. Key themes include the shift from economic policy to economic statecraft, the puzzling underreaction of oil prices despite massive supply disruptions, and China's mysterious drawdown of invisible oil reserves that appears to be buffering global markets.