MacroVoices #402 Lakshman Achuthan: A Soft Landing Still A Dream
ECRI co-founder Lakshman Achuthan maintains his recession forecast despite recent market rallies, arguing that underlying economic weakness persists. He explains why the 'soft landing' scenario remains unlikely based on ECRI's cyclical indicators showing continued economic deceleration and sticky inflation.
Summary
Lakshman Achuthan from the Economic Cycles Research Institute discusses why he maintains his hard landing prediction despite recent strong market performance and GDP numbers. He explains that ECRI's US Coincident Index shows clear economic slowdown rather than acceleration, and argues that focusing solely on GDP can be misleading since it doesn't capture the full picture of economic activity including employment, income, and sales. Achuthan attributes the unusually long lead time of their recession indicators to post-COVID structural imbalances, particularly massive labor supply disruption and policy responses that created labor market distortions. He demonstrates how job growth is increasingly concentrated in non-discretionary sectors (education and health) while discretionary employment is weakening - a classic recessionary pattern. On inflation, Achuthan argues it will remain 'sticky' longer than markets expect, with ECRI's forward-looking inflation indicators showing underlying price pressures have stopped falling rather than continuing to decline. He suggests that even if inflation reaches near the Fed's 2% target during a recession, this could represent just a cyclical low in a new structurally inflationary era, similar to the 1970s when cyclical lows were under 3% but highs exceeded 13%. Globally, ECRI's 21-country leading indicators suggest continued weakness in world trade and economic activity, meaning the US won't be rescued by international growth. Achuthan addresses concerns about Chinese economic data reliability but argues that cyclical frameworks are robust against data manipulation since inflection points remain reliable even when levels are distorted.
Key Insights
- ECRI's US Coincident Index shows continued economic slowdown with no signs of reacceleration, contradicting soft landing narratives based on GDP growth alone
- Job growth is increasingly concentrated in non-discretionary sectors like education and health while discretionary employment weakens, creating a classic recessionary pattern masked by overall job numbers
- Post-COVID structural imbalances including massive labor supply disruption and policy responses have created unusually long lead times for recession indicators
- Forward-looking inflation indicators suggest underlying price pressures have stopped falling, making inflation stickier for longer than markets expect
- Even if inflation reaches 2% during a recession, this could represent just a cyclical low in a new structurally inflationary era rather than a return to the previous low-inflation regime
- ECRI's 21-country long leading index indicates continued global economic weakness with no international growth to rescue the US economy
- Labor hoarding due to previous hiring difficulties is preventing the typical recession signal of mass layoffs, despite managers using other adjustment levers like reducing hours and temporary workers
- Cyclical analytical frameworks remain reliable even when underlying data quality is questionable because inflection points are harder to manipulate than absolute levels
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access