MacroVoices #400 Rory Johnston: All Things Oil
Commodity analyst Rory Johnston discusses why the predicted massive oil supply shortfall of 3 million barrels/day in Q3-Q4 didn't materialize as expected, analyzing data inconsistencies from China demand and Iranian exports. He views geopolitical escalation risks from the Israel-Hamas conflict as tail risks rather than base case scenarios.
Summary
Rory Johnston, founder of Commodity Context, analyzes why the widely predicted massive oil supply deficit of 3 million barrels per day in Q3 and Q4 failed to materialize despite consensus forecasts from major banks. Johnston's independent supply-demand analysis confirms the deficits exist on paper, but identifies several factors explaining the disconnect: understated Iranian production (200-300k bpd), exceptionally strong Chinese demand that appears disconnected from broader macro data, and significant EIA data adjustments including crude oil supply adjustments and understated blending demand. He suggests China may be building strategic refined product inventories, potentially 500k-1 million bpd during peak months, either for economic reasons or national security purposes related to potential Taiwan tensions. Regarding geopolitical risks from the Israel-Hamas conflict, Johnston views Iranian escalation as unlikely, arguing Iran wouldn't risk its primary economic lifeline to China or provoke direct US retaliation with two carrier groups positioned for deterrence. He expects looser sanctions enforcement on Iranian crude to tighten, potentially removing 500k+ bpd from markets. On OPEC dynamics, he notes Saudi Arabia controls the market through voluntary cuts (2 million bpd unilaterally, plus organized cuts), estimating total global spare capacity at 3-3.5 million bpd concentrated in Saudi Arabia and UAE. Johnston discusses Venezuela sanctions relief as limited upside (200-300k bpd over 6 months) contingent on electoral reforms. He explains the current gasoline-diesel crack spread dislocation, where diesel trades at $40/barrel while gasoline has collapsed to $5/barrel, driven by refiners chasing diesel margins while creating gasoline oversupply. This reflects the challenge of heavy crude shortages from Saudi cuts affecting refinery yields.
About this episode
MacroVoices Erik Townsend & Patrick Ceresna welcome Rory Johnston as this weeks guest. Erik & Rory will discuss everything from the predictions of massive supply shortfalls to the U.S. SPR. https://bit.ly/49hmVPb Check out Energy Transition Crisis on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@EnergyTransitionCrisis1 Download Big Picture Trading Chartbook 📈📉: https://bit.ly/3MOUvCL ✅Sign up for a FREE 14-day trial at Big Picture Trading: https://bit.ly/2JjZR7J Please visit our website https://www.macrovoices.com to register your free account to gain access to supporting materials
Key Insights
- Johnston's independent analysis confirms the predicted 3 million barrel per day supply deficits exist on paper, but real market conditions suggest significant data inconsistencies
- Chinese apparent oil demand has grown by 2 million barrels per day year-to-date, representing two-thirds of global demand growth, which seems disconnected from China's broader economic slowdown
- Johnston theorizes China may be building strategic refined product inventories of 500k-1 million barrels per day during peak months, potentially for national security reasons related to Taiwan tensions
- EIA data shows large crude oil supply adjustments that are actually bearish, indicating either understated supply or overstated demand by approximately 600-700k barrels per day
- Johnston views Iranian escalation as unlikely because it would cut Iran's 1.5+ million barrel per day lifeline to China and provoke immediate US retaliation
- He expects tighter sanctions enforcement on Iranian crude despite no official policy change, potentially removing 500k+ barrels per day from markets
- Total global spare capacity is estimated at only 3-3.5 million barrels per day, concentrated primarily in Saudi Arabia and UAE
- Saudi Arabia effectively controls the oil market through 2 million barrels per day of unilateral voluntary cuts plus additional organized OPEC+ cuts
- Venezuela sanctions relief offers limited upside of only 200-300k barrels per day over six months, contingent on electoral reforms that appear unlikely
- Current refining margins show extreme dislocation with diesel at $40/barrel while gasoline has collapsed to $5/barrel, making gasoline effectively a waste byproduct
- Heavy crude shortages from Saudi cuts are reducing diesel yields at refineries while oversupplying gasoline markets
- The energy transition poses long-term challenges for refiners as diesel demand may persist longer than gasoline demand due to heavy equipment requirements
Topics
Transcript
This is Macro Voices, the free weekly financial podcast targeting professional finance, high net worth individuals, family offices, and other sophisticated investors. Macro Voices is all about the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics telling it like it is, bullish or bearish, no holds barred. Now, here are your hosts, Eric Townsend and Patrick Ceresna. Macro Voices episode 400 was produced on November 2nd, 2023. I'm Eric Townsend. Commodity Context founder Rory Johnston returns to talk all things crude oil in this week's feature interview. We'll discuss everything from predictions of massive supply shortfalls in Q3 and Q4 that didn't quite happen as expected, to geopolitical escalation risk in the Israel-Gaza conflict. To the U.S. Strategic Petroleum…
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to AccessMore from Macro Voices
MacroVoices #554 Yasir Arafat: Mass Manufacturing Nuclear Power Plants
Yasser Arafat, CTO of Allo Atomics, discusses the company's plans to mass-produce advanced nuclear reactors at scale, arguing that cost-competitive nuclear energy (cheaper than coal and gas) could be achieved within years, not decades, by leveraging manufacturing principles similar to Tesla's approach. He addresses fuel supply chain constraints, nuclear waste recycling potential, and competitive threats from China while outlining a pathway to transition global energy systems away from fossil fuels.
MacroVoices #553 Brent Johnson: Disparate Housewives
Brent Johnson discusses the dollar's breakout above 102, analyzing why the greenback continues strengthening despite expectations for decline, while also exploring the deepening coordination between the Federal Reserve and Treasury Department in what he calls the "Disparate Housewives" framework. He argues the US remains positioned to weather higher rates better than other economies, and frames the current geopolitical environment as analogous to the early Cold War era with China rather than a replay of the 1970s.
MacroVoices #552 David Rosenberg: Navigating The Noise
David Rosenberg argues that inflation concerns are overblown despite recent energy price spikes, contending that without wage pressures entering the labor market, price shocks will remain transitory. He identifies the November 3rd midterm elections and November 4th Treasury refunding announcement as pivotal catalysts that could trigger significant bond market rallies and economic slowdown as fiscal stimulus ends and gridlock returns.
MacroVoices #551 Michael Every: Decoding The Global Geopolitical Puzzle (Part 2)
Michael Every from Rabobank discusses the interconnected geopolitical tensions between the U.S. and China, analyzing how conflicts in Ukraine, the Middle East, and potential Taiwan invasion scenarios serve as strategic moves in a broader great power competition. He examines emerging policy shifts including potential diesel export bans, AI arms races, and nuclear escalation risks while arguing that national security concerns are overriding traditional free market economics.
MacroVoices #551 Michael Every: Decoding The Global Geopolitical Puzzle
Michael Every of Rabobank discusses interconnected geopolitical crises spanning Iran, Ukraine, and the Middle East, arguing that oil prices don't reflect true disruption risks and that energy will increasingly become a tool of statecraft. The conversation covers potential diesel shortages, U.S. policy responses, the Greenland-Denmark security deal, and China's strategic positioning amid global instability.