MacroVoices #395 Simon White: Inflation, Stocks & Why TINA is Coming Back
Bloomberg's Simon White argues that a recession is more likely than consensus believes, driven by stress in both hard and soft economic data, and that secular inflation will return due to large fiscal deficits being monetized by central banks. He contends that the Fed's rate hikes have had little direct impact on inflation, which has instead been driven down by China's deflationary pressures that may soon reverse.
Summary
Simon White, Bloomberg's Markets Live macro strategist, presents a comprehensive case for an imminent recession and the return of secular inflation. He argues that current economic conditions show stress in both hard data (industrial production, retail sales) and soft data (market and survey data like ISM), which historically creates feedback loops leading to abrupt recessions. White emphasizes that recessions are characterized by being pronounced, protracted, pervasive, and precipitate, often catching markets off guard due to data revisions that obscure turning points.
Regarding inflation, White traces the root cause to central bank monetization of large fiscal deficits, which began before the pandemic. He argues that the Fed's 500+ basis points of rate hikes have had minimal direct impact on inflation reduction, with most of the decline coming from China's deflationary pressures via the acyclical component of core PCE. As China's economy shows signs of recovery and PPI begins to rise, White expects inflation to re-accelerate globally.
White discusses significant market implications, particularly the breakdown of traditional stock-bond correlations due to elevated inflation. He argues this fundamental shift undermines the portfolio hedging function that bonds have served for decades, potentially leading to a 'TINA with a vengeance' scenario where investors pile into equities due to lack of alternatives. He also highlights credit market distortions, noting that traditional indicators like credit spreads aren't reflecting underlying deterioration due to suppressed volatility and the growth of opaque private credit markets.
The interview concludes with White's observations on dollar strength, driven by real yield curves, and his view that despite current gold weakness, it remains well-positioned in an elevated inflation environment as insurance against financial upheaval.
Key Insights
- White argues that recessions occur when hard and soft economic data interact to create cascading feedback loops, and current conditions show stress in both categories past thresholds historically associated with recession
- The speaker contends that the real cause of inflation is central bank monetization of large fiscal deficits, not just pandemic and Ukraine disruptions which were merely proximate causes
- White claims the Fed's 500+ basis point rate hikes have had virtually no direct impact on inflation, as evidenced by the cyclical component of core PCE remaining unchanged
- The author argues that China's deflationary pressures have been the primary driver of inflation decline through the acyclical core PCE component, and this trend may reverse as China's economy recovers
- White asserts that unemployment claims data by state shows deterioration across a high percentage of states consistent with recession patterns, providing more information than national data
- The speaker argues that positive stock-bond correlation eliminates bonds' traditional portfolio hedging function, potentially leading investors to increase equity allocations despite higher risk
- White contends that credit spreads are providing false signals due to suppressed VIX levels caused by low implied correlations and option speculation, masking underlying credit deterioration
- The author argues that bankruptcy filings are rising while credit spreads remain stable, indicating a disconnection between market pricing and fundamental credit conditions
- White claims that private credit markets totaling $1.5 trillion are obscuring price discovery and delaying recognition of credit problems
- The speaker argues that traditional recession playbook of selling stocks and buying bonds won't work in an elevated inflation environment due to unstable Phillips curves
- White asserts that real yield curves provide better dollar direction signals than nominal curves in inflationary environments, and the primary dollar trend remains downward medium-term
- The author argues that excess liquidity in dollar terms remains supportive for risk assets despite recession risks, creating conflicting signals for investors
Topics
Full transcript available for MurmurCast members
Sign Up to Access